News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @03:37AM (#6115947)
The authors response in the comments to an overzealous attempt at political correctness was wonderful.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by ddellacosta on Sunday July 28, 2013 @04:41AM (#6116063)
Not only was that comment (http://scottlocklin.wordpress.com/2013/07/28/ruins-of-forgot...) juvenile, it displays exactly the kind of privilege and ignorance which allows sexism to continue in the world of computer science and software engineering, and which dissuades women (and men who dislike this kind of behavior) from participating in the larger world of compsci/software engineering. In many cases, once you realize that these kinds of assholes rule the roost, it's easier just to go away and do your own thing, rather than disagreeing or speaking up. Especially when we get further support like your comment. "Oh, what a card he is!"

It's okay to disagree--I didn't find the "men use Apply(), not for" thing to be particularly offensive myself, honestly--but there are many ways to disagree without resorting to the kind of hateful, caustic language the author used. This is not how well-adjusted adults disagree when having a discussion.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:18AM (#6116123)
I very much doubt the response reflects his attitude to women in computer science, and your comment regarding "this is not how well-adjusted adults disagree when having a discussion" is somewhat moot, as it wasn't a discussion. This is where I believe his anger came from, and where my support of his response also stems. The cause of women in computer science (which as a student in a very male dominated CS department, I wholeheartedly support) is not helped by people derailing everything in the manner in which the commentator did. Like many political and ethical discussions, there is a time and a place. If he had said something outrightly and obviously sexist, yes, call him on it. But as it is, I think he had every right to get annoyed and want to nip that derailing in the bud.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by ddellacosta on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:27AM (#6116152)
as it wasn't a discussion

It never got the chance to be a discussion, as the author responded to the opening volley with a shotgun blast.

That's his prerogative, of course, as it is his blog, and he can take his ball and go home if he wants to.

The cause of women in computer science (which as student of a CS department, I wholeheartedly support) is not helped by people derailing everything in the manner in which the commentator did.

It's not a derail. It is a topic which came up because of language the author used, and which is an ongoing problem in the community of software developers. While you are free to believe in a platonic ideal of "pure ideas and discussion," it doesn't exist in this messy world of relationships and human language and politics. If you are still a student, I suggest you take a gender/sexual/racial politics course and try befriending some people with very much opposite viewpoints to your own. You may be surprised at your shift in thinking.

But leaving that aside for the moment, let's say the author's main intent was to "nip that derailing in the bud." What do you think the most effective, least hurtful way to approach that would have been?

1) Ignore the comment, 2) assuming he is the administrator of the WordPress blog he writes on, delete/hide the comment, or 3) lash out in a juvenile, sexist, hateful fashion.

I'm going to go with 1 or 2 being better than option 3 any day of the week.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by verroq on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:35AM (#6116170)
How is

> Apply() is the right way for grown-assed men do things.

sexist?

Am I not reading enough into it or something? As far as I can tell somebody was making a fuss about some non issue and was shot down for it.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by king_jester on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:22AM (#6116920)
If you are someone who is not a man, and you read this, how exactly are you supposed to take it? This article is written by a man and features exclusively discussion and pictures of men or languages invented by men. The whole article paints men == software developers/programmers. The only time it talks about a woman is when it tries to demean Lady Gaga for making money while extolling the virtues of male composers.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by verroq on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:41PM (#6118778)
>This article is written by a man

So?

>features exclusively discussion and pictures of men or languages invented by men

You've got to be kidding me right? The majority of programming languages are made by men, it is statistically likely any discussion of programming languages involve those made by men. You might as well attribute any discussion of programming languages as sexist.

I'm not sure if this response should have a /sarcasm tag on the end because it's more sexist then the original comment.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by reinhardt on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:02AM (#6116215)
You have to take a Herstory class at a Gender Studies Department to understand the blatant privileged sexism dripping from this quote.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by impendia on Sunday July 28, 2013 @08:45AM (#6116530)
It implies that only men are the audience, who would be deciding whether to use Apply() or something else.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by coldtea on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:16AM (#6116606)
Or it implies than in real life men WILL be 95% of the audience, and doesn't artificially alter his language.

Or it implies that whoever reads the text, man or woman, will be wise enough not to give a fuck for such minutiae.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by impendia on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:28AM (#6116637)
> men WILL be 95% of the audience

It has been postulated, I think plausibly, that the commonality of such language is one reason why this gender disparity continues to exist.

Personally, I agree with this argument. If you disagree, that is fine -- but please show a little bit more respect.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by coldtea on Monday July 29, 2013 @06:12AM (#6120145)
>It has been postulated, I think plausibly, that the commonality of such language is one reason why this gender disparity continues to exist.

The idea that "the commonality of such language" is the reason, is like the idea that video games and action movies create killers and criminals.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by impendia on Tuesday July 30, 2013 @01:49PM (#6128672)
Okay, I agree. The ideas indeed have much in common.

My point stands here equally well, for the same reason. (This idea I happen to disagree with, but that's not relevant.) The idea you mentioned is not obviously stupid. I don't see what dismissing the idea without refuting it adds to the conversation.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:39AM (#6116181)
"and try befriending some people with very much opposite viewpoints to your own." Thank you for your judgements on my friendship circles; those I have relationships with are of very diverse opinions on gender/sexual/racial/wider politicial issues.

His reaction may have been juvenile and extreme, but I certainly don't think it was sexist. What makes you say that?

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by yummyfajitas on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:01AM (#6116567)
I disagree. In contemporary professional and technical society, the politically incorrect occupy a disadvantaged position. The person being accused of political incorrectness is automatically assumed to be a person of the worst sort - sexist, unthinking, mean.

Scott Locklin is playing the game of taking proud ownership of his own labels. "I'm not a member of your cool modern hipster club, I'm just a geek who cares about fast computation." For comparison, see also "I'm a man hating dyke, meh, I get more pussy than you."

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by king_jester on Sunday July 28, 2013 @11:18AM (#6116905)
> In contemporary professional and technical society, the politically incorrect occupy a disadvantaged position.

This is not true in the least. The "politically incorrect", as you put it, get free license to say and do sexist and racist things and its up to the people affected by that to speak up. When those people do speak up, usually their attempt to bring up that point is the subject of criticism.

> The person being accused of political incorrectness is automatically assumed to be a person of the worst sort - sexist, unthinking, mean.

That someone's tears and fears of being called out on a being a sexist is considered more of a problem then their sexist words and behavior is a key part of having privilege.

> For comparison, see also "I'm a man hating dyke, meh, I get more pussy than you."

That statement drips with misogyny, homophobia, and transphobia. If someone wants to take ownership of those aspects of themselves, that's fine, but that person deserves to be ridiculed for it.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by yummyfajitas on Sunday July 28, 2013 @12:08PM (#6117050)
The "politically incorrect", as you put it, get free license

No they don't. If they phrase factually correct statements the wrong way, society condemns and penalizes them. Larry Summers is a perfect illustration of this.

That someone's tears and fears of being called out on a being a sexist is considered more of a problem then their sexist words and behavior is a key part of having privilege.

It's not considered "more of a problem" by pretty much anyone.

Accusing someone of sexism is just a rhetorical weapon used by the privileged to make dissenters stop speaking truth to power. A person who's beliefs align them with modern liberalism has an extraordinary privilege - they do not suffer the presumption that they are bad people with evil beliefs. They can make content-free assertions, make ad-hominem attacks against those who disagree, while in contrast those who disagree must present mountains of evidence for their position.

(Oh yes I am being the jerk who uses the language of political correctness against itself.)

As for the statement you describe as "drips with mysogyny, homophobia and transphobia", it's a statement I heard made by a lesbian who was taking ownership of the word "dyke". If you wish to ridicule lesbians who claim "dyke" for their own (or blacks who claim "nigger" for their own) be my guest.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by archagon on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:52AM (#6116204)
Yep. I was enjoying the article until I read that comment, at which point I lost all respect for the author.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by lclarkmichalek on Sunday July 28, 2013 @03:58AM (#6115992)
> You may now go fuck yourself with a carrot scraper in whatever gender-free orifice you have available.

How the fuck is that "wonderful"? The comment was something along the lines of "I wish people wouldn't use that kind of language", and the response was in the form "If I insult you enough, I don't have to acknowledge your argument". Looking at the other comments, the one nitpicking about the choice of Lady Gaga is equally as useless, but strangely that one didn't get an angry reply.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @04:10AM (#6116006)
That line was a bit juvenile, granted. The other comment wasn't really nitpicking. The commenter believed that Gaga has genuine musical ability, and the author wanted to make it clear that it was that classical training that made her the target of his blog. I don't want to misinterprete your meaning here, but are you trying to suggest the author would only react angrily to a female/feminist commentator?
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by lclarkmichalek on Sunday July 28, 2013 @04:42AM (#6116068)
Not to a female commentator (I've no idea if the commentator was female in this case). More to a comment that deals with issues that are usually associated with feminism. And I wouldn't use the word only; In a much more hostile manner than the response to an average nitpick? Yes, that sums it up. The Gaga comment was nitpicking; off topic and trivial. The comment on casual sexism was also. Yet only one of them actually had their issue addressed.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:29AM (#6116157)
The Gaga nitpicking wasn't completely off topic though. The selection of Gaga as the target was chosen with the express purpose of demonstrating a point; Gaga has classical training, yet still produces what most (at least the author) consider to be trash. This mirrors his comment on the poor design of modern languages versus the APL languages, and a commentator didn't get this link so he spelled it out for them. On the other hand, the casual sexism call was completely off topic.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by scottlocklin on Sunday July 28, 2013 @06:26PM (#6118352)
The one on lady Gaga had a point which relates to the content of my post. It was not only relevant, but interesting, as was his subsequent comment on Alcubierre drives, which is a subject for a forthcoming post already taking shape. The dork who was attempting to "correct" my language was not interesting, and totalitarian numskulls like that deserve nothing but whatever blistering scorn I can muster at that particular moment.

The fact that this is even "a thing" with 30-odd comments about it is a sad commentary on the illness which afflicts modern civilization. If this isn't clear: I don't like people with such "refined" sensibilities, and they are invited to never, ever read my blog. If you're that sensitive, you belong by yourself in a yurt, where nobody's language or opinions will bother you.

Personally, I've never met an actual programmer of any race, gender or creed who actually is that sensitive. People that sensitive are mentally ill, and don't have jobs. I've met plenty of power-mad Cotton Mather sickos who think they have the right to police the words and opinions of others though. The fact that people think witch hunts over a fscking word are OK; that is not OK.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by coldtea on Sunday July 28, 2013 @09:13AM (#6116594)
I, for one, find it wonderful.

As for people saying "I wish people wouldn't use that kind of language" -- those are the scum of the earth.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by SwellJoe on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:15AM (#6116119)
So, here's the thing about conversations like this: We have a broken culture in technology. We can know we have a broken culture in tech by looking at the number of women within it.

Given that reality, I'm coming down more on the side of stopping and listening when I hear a criticism of elements of our culture, rather than becoming reactionary. The criticism may not be right...but, it's worth listening and thinking about it, rather than just jumping down someone's throat with an angry and childish insult. Is it "political correctness" or actually language that turns people away? I don't have the answers...but, programming wasn't always a male-dominated field. The fact that it has become more and more so over time tells me something is wrong. Listening to ideas on what that wrong thing (or things) might be is probably a start on fixing it.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:21AM (#6116134)
I agree, but there is a time and a place for these discussions, and there are better ways of handling it than calling him out in his own comments. If you wanted to address perceived casual sexism through turns of phrases such as these, a better angle would be to collect examples from such blog posts and author a new post with the purpose of discussing this use of language.

I don't think the gender equality in the industry is worsening, as you say. It certainly has worsened in recent years, but the strong movement in support of women in CS is gaining traction. My opinion on it may be jaded by the "white male privelege", but to me it seems the balance is starting to be reinstated slightly. Numbers of females joining the department each year has been increasing since I entered the degree, and recent statistics released actually showed there is now more women than men in the post-graduate CS degrees. Whether this is the case everywhere, I don't know (and doubt), but it's certainly a start.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by SwellJoe on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:28AM (#6116156)
I think that would also be a useful approach. But, I've been involved in activist circles lately, and something I've learned in that is that calling behavior out when it happens can prevent resentments and problems from growing; and, having that culture of calling people on their shit can allow someone who may have walked away to feel empowered to speak up when they feel uncomfortable with something someone has said.

Again, I'm not sure I understand the nuances of why someone felt uncomfortable with this particular piece of language; but if I assume good intentions, all it costs me is a moment of my time to think about it and try to understand. And maybe, by taking that time and showing a little respect for that view, I'll help someone feel welcome into this community I've been a part of for so long. I think it's probably worth the trouble...and, in the end, I'm pretty sure I'm a better person than I was a couple years ago before I got involved in this kind of activism.

I don't know how to convince others to stop being reactionary, and instead simply think about what's being said. Anti-oppression training might be cool at tech conferences, but I suspect it'd be the least attended track.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:46AM (#6116190)
"having that culture of calling people on their shit can allow someone who may have walked away to feel empowered to speak up when they feel uncomfortable with something someone has said." I certainly appreciate that perspective on it; it is empowering to the victims. However, as in this case, it can also alienate those they are calling if it was not genuine sexism. There are cases where similar language is used in a sexist fashion, and it would be a bit of a stretch to call this one of them, so in this case it only caused an adverse reaction. I guess there is a careful balancing act to empowerment.

"I don't know how to convince others to stop being reactionary" If it helps, your views have helped me consider my reaction to this. I understand and empathise with why he reacted how he did, but my reaction to his post was probably a step further into inappropriate. Thank you.

Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by _delirium on Sunday July 28, 2013 @03:43AM (#6115962)
I looked for it after seeing this comment, and the response came across as kind of juvenile to me.
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jdn on Sunday July 28, 2013 @04:12AM (#6116011)
It was a juvenile response to a juvenile comment
Re:Ruins of forgotten empires: APL languages by jamesaguilar on Sunday July 28, 2013 @05:04AM (#6116099)
If it was a juvenility contest, the response won by lengths. The response also won in mean-spiritedness and unnecessary escalation.