News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by ricardo_ramirez on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:16PM (#6110334)
The % transaction fee is a turndown. I have been looking for a solution to distribute digital goods, and I try to stay away from anything that is a percentage, it does not scale once you have hundreds of sales.

They are not absorbing the Paypal transaction fee, which means that on top of the 5% I would still be charged the 2.6% that Paypal wants (amount vary). So, unless the service provides a payment gateway, where is that 5% coming from? That starts adding to the cost really fast.

It might not be pretty but ejunkie (http://www.e-junkie.com/ej/pricing.htm) has a fixed cost of 5 dollars. It ends up being cheaper as soon as I sell more than 10 copies of any $10 digital goods.

For something prettier than ejunkie (but with way less features), PulleyApp does a fixed price of $6 (http://pulleyapp.com/signup). The only reason I am not using PulleyApp is because I wanted different paypal email addresses (for microtransactions vs. regular one - different fees), and at some point the ability to call a backend service does matter for integration.

I don't really see why I would use a service that takes a commission and does not charge a fixed price unless they have a value added service. As it stands, there are better alternatives already that do the same thing.

The new thing in here is the DropBox and Google Drive integration, but that is not enough for me to justify using them.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by zrail on Friday July 26, 2013 @06:33PM (#6110969)
I ended up writing my own app to sell my ebook and it wasn't all that hard using Stripe. Deploying to Heroku is free if you're ok with their wildcard https certificate.

<shameless plug> The book is called Mastering Modern Payments: Using Stripe with Rails. It's a guide to integrating Stripe with your Rails app and includes a bunch of goodies that help make your integration robust in the face of failure.

http://www.petekeen.net/mastering-modern-payments </plug>

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by pbhjpbhj on Friday July 26, 2013 @10:26PM (#6111643)
Yo dawg!??
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by zrail on Friday July 26, 2013 @10:39PM (#6111665)
Yeah!
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by 6thSigma on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:33PM (#6110400)
Those are subscription prices. So on the other hand, if you sell 0 digital goods in a month you will owe nothing with this service but $5 on the other service. With % pricing you will never go in the negative.

Edit: Not saying this is a better pricing model - just playing devils advocate.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by ricardo_ramirez on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:40PM (#6110435)
The % model would indeed work better with a low volume sales. So, if I wanted to distribute a file just once or twice, then this would work, since I end up paying just 50c (if the price of the digital goods were $10) instead of a fixed price for the subscription.

But if someone intends to sell several hundreds of copies, or the price is bigger (say, 5% of $10,000), then it is not a good deal.

So, I really only see the target audience as someone that must have DropBox integration (though other services also have integration with your webserver, and mounting a DropBox folder and exposing that through the webserver seems trivial), or maybe people with such a dispersion of files that the other services won't work (they allow you a fixed number of products).

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by clarky07 on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:57PM (#6110537)
while true, it seems if you are selling 0 for too long, you just take it down. i'd rather plan for success than failure, and $5 is pretty trivially worth it to test a product out.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by mwilcox on Friday July 26, 2013 @06:36PM (#6110976)
https://gumroad.com/ is another that uses 5% (+ 25c per transaction) but doesn't go through paypal or Dropbox. The ease of use and customisability provides a lot of value in itself.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by eli on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:25PM (#6110693)
I've used e-junkie before. It is certainly not pretty, but it works.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by jackmaney on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:09PM (#6110296)
A very interesting concept, but after clicking on "Start with Drive", one of the permissions requested is the ability to "Upload, download, update, and delete files in your Google Drive"

Now, I don't know if there are more granular permissions than that, but if so, you might want to restrict things further so that files can only be added to my Google Drive (and possibly updated, for those that I've purchased via Sellbox).

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by andrewmunsell on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:18PM (#6109957)
I've used them for selling a couple of Mac apps[1] (along with Gumroad, for credit card buyers), and it's turned out just fine.

I'm not too worried about the 5% fee because the apps were ~$5, and it's nice to get an instant deposit into my PayPal account. I could pretty easily build my own system for payments to eliminate their fee, but it isn't worth it to me for lower volume stuff, which this is targeted towards.

That being said, I still prefer Gumroad. It's all about the user experience, and Sellbox's isn't very good at all. The dashboard kind of sucks (though, it's usable).

[1] http://analytics.wizardapps.net/

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by smarx on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:01PM (#6109864)
I don't have a PayPal account, so I couldn't really try out the integration. Do the files remain in Dropbox/Drive, or do they get copied to Sellbox's storage?

This might be a good candidate for the Dropbox Chooser: https://www.dropbox.com/developers/dropins/chooser/js, which gives nice UI for picking files and then only grants the app access to those specific files.

(I work at Dropbox and am happy to answer questions. Email: [email protected])

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by csdreamer7 on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:04PM (#6109877)
> Do the files remain in Dropbox/Drive, or do they get copied to Sellbox's storage?

Good question.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by snoonan on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:13PM (#6109929)
The 5% cut is a big problem. It's inherently not fair.

They aren't making a market (like an App store), promoting my files, creating my content, or otherwise providing value that scales with the growth of the success of my product. Why are they entitled to $5 on my $100 or $10 on my $200 if that's the price I choose? Charging a fixed price per sale is more fair + any %fees you might incur from payment processing.

Clearly many businesses are based on the same % transaction fee, but it's not really fair if you look closely.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by umsm on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:57PM (#6110206)
Well, you're paying for the middle man. They setup and main the infrastructure for persons that are not technically inclined and for whom it's not feasible to hire a coder to do it for them.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by snoonan on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:00PM (#6110231)
No argument! They should charge for the service, but not a % of the value I create.

It costs them the same to deliver a $5 file as it does a $50, apart from the transaction fees claimed by their upstream payment processor.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by monkeyspaw on Friday July 26, 2013 @08:19PM (#6111287)
This sounds pretty much exactly the opposite of what I hear from pricing experts. Charge based on the value you provide to the person using your service, not based on your costs.

An easy system to post ebooks and charge for them is probably worth more to a person selling $200 ebooks rather than $100 ebooks.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by tossedaway on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:23PM (#6110362)
Interesting...and I don't disagree.

How would you like them to charge for a service like this?

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by w0rd-driven on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:07PM (#6110583)
1) Cover the standard 2.6% from paypal. Make that obvious. 2) Add a flat rate on top to cover operating expenses.

The current model makes a lot of sense for small to medium amount transactions but I too have a problem with 7.6% total of a much larger transaction this company didn't do any extra work for.

Alternatively you could have multiple rates based on the size of the payload. If you're really using their storage, which I doubt, then that percentage cost would cover the bandwidth to serve it. With that you would have people like me that would check their work though, to make sure if I'm really paying bandwidth costs, you better not be leveraging Dropbox's infrastructure for that too.

Personally, I do like the idea over a Zapier though that's a flat monthly fee. I couldn't possibly determine if the monthly rate is enough on principle but a cut of my profits is much less of an "up front" cost I can't adequately measure yet.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by wavesounds on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:43PM (#6110451)
A flat fee per file seems to make the most sense, since their operation costs are per transaction. They should just figure out how much it costs them per transaction, then bake in a percent of their startup costs to reach the black in a reasonable time and use that as a flat fee. I can't see a justification for a percentage approach, its the same amount of work either way on their end.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by snoonan on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:38PM (#6110428)
Since they are charged a percent upstream, then they will have to pass that on to operate.

So I would imagine they could pass on the percent component of cost with no markup, and then charge a flat fee (ex: $1). I'm assuming they are never stuck with the bill in a fraud case. If they are, then the price should include that risk component as a percentage as well.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by untilHellbanned on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:34PM (#6110047)
I really like the idea but scary immediate stuff for layperson:

Screen 1) Login. Screen 2) Dropbox: "This app will be able to read and modify everything." Screen 3) Paypal: Login to Paypal, go to "Resolution Centre" and "Remove Limitations".

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by bryanh on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:25PM (#6109990)
Very nice!

We wrote a blog post on doing this with Zapier: https://zapier.com/blog/the-ultimate-guide-to-selling-downlo... except you can mix and match any payment, storage and email/notification system and start to augment it however you like.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by hawkharris on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:43PM (#6110447)
Cool service! I spent a few months researching and writing an article about self-driving cars. I'm selling my research for $1 just as an experiment.

https://sellboxhq.com/l/A6KW/How-Google-Cars-Will-Change-Com...

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by samstave on Friday July 26, 2013 @06:32PM (#6110967)
It would be cool if sellbox would tell me more about the file. If PDF - tell me how many pages, how big the file etc.

While $1.00 is not much in this particular case - I have no idea what the actual details of the file are that I am looking to buy.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by dools on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:14PM (#6110323)
I don't understand the advantage of using cloud storage instead of uploading a file. Unless I were selling a 4GB file and it was already in Dropbox and I was in a hurry...
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by daniula on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:15PM (#6110640)
Dropbox and Google Drive made uploading file super easy. You just drag&drop file on your hard drive and they take care about the rest. In addition to that, whenever you are going to update the file, you don't have to login. Again just drag&drop and Dropbox + Sellbox do the magic.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by eli on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:21PM (#6110675)
I agree it's convenient, but I'm having a hard time imagining people who would be selling digital content, if only they didn't have to upload it to a storefront...
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by bostonvaulter2 on Friday July 26, 2013 @08:49PM (#6111382)
Are there any generic examples of a digital storefront that you can easily self-publish files (preferably up to 25MB or so)? I'm not currently aware of any (although I haven't actually tried to search them out).
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by eli on Friday July 26, 2013 @08:58PM (#6111400)
I've used http://www.e-junkie.com/ before
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by dools on Saturday July 27, 2013 @08:59PM (#6115107)
gumroad.com
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by hrjet on Saturday July 27, 2013 @11:28AM (#6113230)
This is interesting. Similar services seem to be: 1. GumRoad (5% + 25cents) 2. InstaMojo (5% + 30cents) 3. e-junkie (it's complicated) 4. Pulley (per month starting from $6)

Pulley seems like the most promising to me (nice UI + appropriate pricing model).

But what I am really interested in is a store model, where there are categories, and ratings and users can discover more stuff and generic enough to host music, apps, etc. In short, an amazon for digital goods. And slim processing fees.

The tricky part is handling VAT for some geographies (such as Euro). What I would love is a service which either: a. Handles all VAT concerns b. allows me to limit sales for such countries. (to an Indie seller it can be a hassle).

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by slaven on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:06PM (#6110580)
I love this idea - I just wish they implement their own billing via Stripe instead of PayPal (not a big fan of PayPal for the obvious reasons).
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by daniula on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:13PM (#6110624)
There are plans of integrating that. However, Stripe is limited only to US market, so still looking for better worldwide (at least US and Europe) solution.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by slaven on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:15PM (#6110638)
Ah makes sense (we just got it in Canada recently)
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by draugadrotten on Friday July 26, 2013 @02:51PM (#6109820)
High risk service for a business.

From T&C: "Sellbox does not pre-screen Content, but Sellbox has the right (but not the obligation) in their sole discretion to refuse or remove any Content that is available via the Service."

Then add in Paypal account freezes on top of that.

I wouldn't want to depend on a combo like that for my company's cashflow.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by MichaelApproved on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:09PM (#6109904)
It's a great option for low budget projects. I could see it working well for hobby or MVP projects.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by eberfreitas on Friday July 26, 2013 @02:36PM (#6109747)
This is really useful for artists like musicians and so on... How do you plan to market it? What is the core audience?
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by joshmn on Friday July 26, 2013 @06:17PM (#6110920)
I have a client whose concept is to do exactly this. Expect to see some details about it. It's going to change everything, especially for indie bands.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by thrush on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:06PM (#6109885)
Completely agreed. This is a genius way to bypass the iTunes Store and Kindle Book Store.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by CompiledCode on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:18PM (#6109959)
It reminds me of gumroad.com
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by voltagex_ on Saturday July 27, 2013 @12:59AM (#6111928)
bandcamp.com does this far, far better. Sorry - I won't trust most musicians to encode their own files properly.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by minimaxir on Friday July 26, 2013 @03:17PM (#6109952)
What would be interesting would be a) ability to sell entire folders and b) ability to automatically generate sell links for files. Combined, you could create an instataneous online storefront automatically.

I am a currently planning a project that might be able to make good use of Sellbox. :) we'll see how that works.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by ArekDymalski on Saturday July 27, 2013 @06:32PM (#6114743)
That's a nice option for bloggers who don't want to be bothered with business scale setup. I guess it would be great if you had an embeddable widget for Wordpress.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by mark_sz on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:38PM (#6110431)
I love the idea. It works like Bandcamp, but its for all type of files and it takes smaller cut (5% instead of 10%).

Well done.

Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by adamnemecek on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:15PM (#6110635)
Bandcamp takes 15% until you hit $10,000 in sales, then scales back to 10%.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by andrewroycarter on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:24PM (#6110689)
I'm working on a pebble app- May use this to distribute it until a non crappy pebble store comes out!
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by nikunjk on Friday July 26, 2013 @07:37PM (#6111155)
This looks freakishly similar to Gumroad. Even the 'I want this' button seems copied.
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by deweller on Friday July 26, 2013 @04:13PM (#6110316)
I wonder what that muchacho file is. Anyone know?
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by daniula on Friday July 26, 2013 @05:10PM (#6110608)
As far remember Muchacho is a font file: http://www.behance.net/gallery/Muchacho-Free-Font/8042679
Re:Sellbox – Sell your files from Dropbox and Google Drive w... by arcticf0x on Saturday July 27, 2013 @02:04AM (#6112037)
How to verify the stuff we buy is legit?