Also: You can encrypt the server hard drives.
Hey, it sounded good on paper.
To me this is the prime definition of "too big to fail". It would only require a small percentage of these companies uniting "for the greater good" to produce meaningful results. Not cowing to the NSA is not treason in this instance so I can't even possibly understand why complying with "laws that aren't on any books so are they really laws?" has any positive merit.
Corporations (or any large centralized power base) will optimize for the most exploitable customer or user base, culturing this base if possible. To help broaden a target user base corporations need strong centralized governments more than they need even sizable (but less "culturable") segments of their market base.
Upshot: mature corporations (political parties / religions / etc) will not typically stand up to a centralized government on behalf of a rights-demanding fraction of their market... indeed, typically, they will do the opposite.
If so, are there any viable, offline alternatives?
http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2013/06/wsj-nsa-progra...
An open source service sounds interesting, but I don't think I'll ever be willing to post all my financial data to a web service again. It would be great to have a locally installed application that could keep track of all those accounts. Having some algorithms run to help me save would be great, but it would take some demonstrated assurances to get me to provide even anonymous data for the machine learning process.
The entire premise is personal finance software that learns your habits to make it easier to use :)
The policies (or location) of online budgeting tools are entirely irrelevant. Hiding financial data from the government involves well established trades dating to long before the internet (or PRISM): money laundering and tax evasion.
But as far as I know, my bank can't look at my accounts that are with other financial companies.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_accounting_softwa...
Everyone needs to reconsider their worldview and a few important definitions they hold. One of those is privacy.
My definition of privacy: anything I relay to ANY one person is no longer private. What's the old saying about three people keeping a secret? Information wants to be free and privacy is not its natural state. It's always been this way, but the physical barriers to diffusion have been completely decimated in the past two decades.
This is not a mere blip in a long term trend, it is fundamental, IMO.
That being said, I believe there are new values we can all embrace to make the most of the state of the human experience today. Perhaps someone should can a thread on Internet values for the 21st century and beyond.
PS - Anyone ever wonder how MSFT got an anti-trust pass in the US, but not in the EU?
"In the interest of national security..."
In the current state, some big companies have the means to fight such requests, some big companies are very willing to cooperate, and small companies rarely have the means to go into a legal battle.
Because of the current fragmentation and secrecy surrounding feds' requests with software companies, users do not have the possibility of knowing what they're in for with which company. Also, the divide and conquer tactics used by the Feds really allow them to extract much more information than what would otherwise be the case. Ideally there should be a union for software companies, which makes agreements with the feds concerning their access rights; agreements which then apply to all members of the union.
Currently I have two rules of thumb: 1) for critical services, avoid companies located or significantly involved in the US or UK and 2) at all costs, stay away from Microsoft.