Think that case with the German who said on Facebook that they should visit the new NSA center in Germany, and the police visited him before he got a chance to do it. That's what we're really talking about here. If you think that developing such capabilities to stop protests is a little too paranoid for you to digest, do you really think they wouldn't do this if there was another massive protest against the banks, with the excuse that they're protecting the nation against an economic crash or whatever? The last time around, they arrested people for trying to close their bank accounts, and they weren't even that many. Let's just say that if this was an Intrade bet, I would be in favor of it happening.
The architects are liberal ex-hippies who just do not understand that they are building the framework for totalitarianism. I think there are a lot of us who just like playing with toys and do not evaluate the ethical ramifications of their actions.
Money seems to have that effect.
The internet is not just tech - it is almost a worldview. Governments don't deal well with satire, irony and cynicism.
In other words, there is nobody telling them it's wrong and to stop. That's all outside their universe.
If the idea that maybe we don't need all this militarism and surveillance does make it through the layers of filters protecting Congressmen from reality, there is a general attitude that people saying these things are naive hippies, and that the fearless Congressmen are the 'grown ups' who can make the 'tough decisions' to spend trillions of dollars on defense and violate the odd civil liberty to 'keep America safe'.
It's not just that they can't hear the critics, it's that when they do hear the critics they feel smugly superior to them.
The reality is that the people seem to want this. That is the reality Congress works from.
Has it maybe occurred to you that e.g. Pelosi and Hoyer, whose lives were defined by the Cold War, have maybe a different view on life than the HN readership, who were mostly children when the Soviet Union collapsed?
The folks looking to increase their power at the expense of the citizenry are relentless. They spend their nights and weekends thinking up new ways to be more dominant. As citizens, we can't expect to combat their never-ending efforts with luke-warm responses or apologetics for our favorite political leaders.
When it comes to privacy/liberty/freedom, the only reasonable response to government incursion is a strong and unequivocal one.
Also, before we go there, yes I am aware they also did a lot of other horrible things, but we're talking about the NSA and their activities as related to the fourth amendment right now.
EDIT: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_SHAMROCK
It does appear as though it was shut down the moment it came under scrutiny before a proper debate could be had about the legality of it.
Then I'd expect they appreciate the view that any government that perpetrates pervasive surveillance upon the populace at large with no notification & no recourse is the embodiment of Evil Communism™ and the antithesis of core American values, totally violating the US Constitution.
And yet, things turned out fine. The Soviet Union was defeated, America survived, and our biggest problem today, from their point of view, is not civil liberties but an ailing economy.
I can totally see how someone like Pelosi might think along the following lines:
1) The world is scary and the CIA/NSA serve an important purpose in protecting national security;
2) By and large government officials are trustworthy, and won't abuse their power (remember, she's a Democrat);
3) The NSA has shown colorable attempts to stay within the bounds of the Constitution (only collecting metadata, or only targeting non-US persons).
You may not agree with any of these points, but I think it's ridiculous to say that only bribery could make you agree with these points.
I didn't.
Being more paranoid than less I have a inkling that this system is being installed and police is being armed because it is known that if economy collapses, these will be instruments to quell dissent and literally destroy (imprison and/or execute) opposition - of those who might well lead the revolution.
Economy is doing good, but the external debt is mindboggling those who are in the place of power might know what we don't.