News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by shrughes on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:19PM (#6092984)
I would expect a product named Facemail to be something created by Facebook.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by amirmc on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:34PM (#6093065)
> "...what company they thought made a product called FACEMAIL. Only 36.2% chose Facebook, Inc"

So you're in the 36.2%. Was there another point you were trying to make? (fwiw, I'd be in the 63.8% of that poll).

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by rickhanlonii on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:39PM (#6093095)
I would expect a product named Facemail to be something created by Facebook either less than or as much as I would expect a product named Facetime to be something created by Facebook.

When we start making these decisions more heavily on the subjectivity of users more than objectivity (e.g. the colors would be completely different, and if they aren't then a trademark infringement could be filed at that time), then we're just giving the free market to large corporations.

The more popular a brand is, the more likely more people are to associate related names/colors/symbols to that brand. Trademark law simply does not exist for cases like this. It exists to prevent genuine outright infringement.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by DanBC on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:38PM (#6093375)
> Trademark law simply does not exist for cases like this. It exists to prevent genuine outright infringement.

The link steps through the decisions, and gives case law for the reason. Which step do you disagree with?

EDIT: The link says clearly that a well known mark gets more protection just because it is well known.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by rickhanlonii on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @08:09PM (#6093734)
I don't disagree that a well known mark should get more protection because it is well known--otherwise people could just trademark every word in the dictionary and enforce it with equal weight as Google.

But OP wasn't using Facebook, he wasn't using Facebok, he wasn't using Facbook, he wasn't pretending to be Facebook, we wasn't competing with facebook, he wasn't using the colors, the image, or anything related to the brand.

No, he was punished (i.e. the government used force against him to hider his free market ability) for using a name that started with Face. That's simply not a threshold that we, as a society, should accept as protected--no matter the popularity of the brand, no matter the laws a group of 435 people influenced heavily by corporations have managed to actually pass.

Besides that, the ruling is by it's very nature a subjective decision. I disagree with their subjective decision.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by willchilcutt on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:31PM (#6093052)
So did a third of other random people surveyed. You would not be in the majority apparently, and after seeing a logo or web page you would hopefully be able to figure out it is not created by Facebook.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by DanBC on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:22PM (#6093305)
If 20% said Apple, and 20% said Google, and 10% said YouTube, and the rest said "don't know" then a majority did think it was Facebook.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by aaronbrethorst on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:34PM (#6093354)
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by DanBC on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:57PM (#6093466)
...and yet, it doesn't matter.

36% were confused by FACEMAIL, and 0% were confused by THINKMAIL.

29% is considered enough to be confusing.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by shrughes on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:36PM (#6093075)
It doesn't matter whether it's a majority. A third of people is a large proportion.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by amirmc on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:51PM (#6093161)
So what's your point? Does this mean Facebook has some right to the 'face-' prefix? I strongly disagree.

Might be worth looking over the history between Apple Corps and Apple Computer [1]. Who should have had the trademark there?

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Corps_v_Apple_Computer

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by toomuchtodo on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:57PM (#6093188)
There is only so much stupid you can engineer around, technically and legally.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by thinkcomp on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:37PM (#6093085)
I think the question is whether you find yourself confused by the fact that Apple makes FaceTime while Facebook makes Facebook (and Think makes FaceCash).

At some point, and this is why the Star Trek / Star Wars example matters, consumers realize that the prefix is generic within the scope of a given market. Telecommunications and faces overlap a lot these days.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by Ellipsis753 on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:03PM (#6093211)
Personally I would think that FaceTime and FaceCash were made by Facebook Inc. (As I had actually never heard of either of those). I also thought that Star Trek and Star Wars were related or the same thing for most of my childhood. I didn't want Star Wars because I'd seen Star Trek on TV and not liked it (I was young).

It's just something people do (or at least I do). I think it's maddness to prevent the use of names starting with "Face" because of this confusion. I thought that iPlayer was apple related like iTunes for a long time. It's confusing yes but I don't feel you should be able to prevent someone using a similar sounding name.

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by matthuggins on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:37PM (#6093079)
And I would not.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by RexRollman on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:59PM (#6093196)
Maybe it's for the best, since Facebook sucks and I would expect something called Facemail to suck as well.
Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by gee_totes on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @05:47PM (#6093146)
Wait, but there is a product created by Facebook... @facebook.com e-mail addresses[0]... which is what imagine what a Facemail product would do

https://www.facebook.com/help/224049364288051

Re:Facebook wins right to police “face-” trademark prefix by darkarmani on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:00PM (#6093202)
Well they did create facetime, right?