If you were following the Bitcoin forums at the height of the Ponzi, anyone who suggested it was a Ponzi was called a troll who was libelling pirateat40 by what felt like half the forum. Everyone insisted that unless they had actual proof it wasn't a genuine investment, they should shut up, and that the only reason for them to make a big fuss about it was to . This comment was about par for the course, and bear in mind this was after the scheme imploded: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=101377.0
A number of widely-respected members of the Bitcoin community supported the Ponzi and even ran pass-through schemes for it.
(And made all the same points which are also obvious in hindsight...)
I have been following the whole development of his Ponzi scheme. Yes it was obvious to some in the community that it was a Ponzi. I remember writing a few lengthy posts on bitcointalk.org accusing him of a Ponzi. But surprisingly, many people adamantly chose to believe in Shavers and argued against me, ignoring my warnings, telling me why I was wrong. Their argument boiled down to "it has to be legit since he has been paying everybody so far". Sigh... Money prevents people from thinking straight.
It doesn't really make a ton of sense when you think about it: "Laundering" Bitcoin doesn't really do you a ton of good as you still end up with a bunch of inexplicable Bitcoin, and if you were laundering it a service where people put coins on deposit and then got returns forever doesn't produce the right kind of transaction patterns for laundering.
True enough. But crazy returns like that do occasionally exist, though I have never seen them be a "sure thing" nor an ongoing thing. That's just crazy, or cheating.
I was getting APR's in the hundreds of percent for a very short time by lending USD to margin traders. It happened over the course of a few weeks after the latest big gold rush. I was afraid the whole time that something would happen to the exchange and I would lose my (tiny) account.
Given this, is anyone algorithmically analyzing the ledger for anomalies like Ponzi schemes? That could be an interesting project.
Anybody that is not skeptical about 7% weekly returns on anything is just asking for it. That's 33x your money in 1 year. How can that sound legit to anybody?
> In reality, BTCST was a sham and a Ponzi scheme in which Shavers used Bitcoin from new investors to make purported interest payments and cover investor withdrawals on outstanding BTCST investments.
Since the bitcoin ledger itself is public record anybody could analyze the addresses associated with the fund and see the inflows and outflows[1]. Even if new addresses are generated for each transaction at some point the fund manager would need to roll them up and combine them. It would be possible to see the ponzi flows in the ledger itself.
[1]: Assuming the fund manager isn't using some kind of bitcoin mixer. If he is then that's probably a sign that something bad is going on. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Mixing_service