Re:Canary - Smart home security device for everyone
by ynniv on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:52PM
(#6086992)
No it's not. If you live in a detached house your phone line, power, water, cable, etc, is readily accessible from outdoors. I've never robbed a house, but it seems pretty prudent to cut those things with an axe before you enter. Maybe thieves aren't doing that because security systems are commonly battery backed? They would have to be cellular as well. I'm not sure, but your original concern does not seem far fetched.
And yes, I recognize that something is better than nothing. I was motivated to post by two things: firstly, my security system comes with a battery backup, and my sense is that this is a standard feature. I assume if that didn't provide useful additional security, it wouldn't be a standard feature. Secondly, if you're going to have a side-by-side table that lists a bunch of ways your security product is better than the industry-standard product with which it's meant to compete, as they do on their indiegogo (going so far as to call current technology "broken"), you should be honest if it does so by being less secure. They imply an equivalence that isn't justified.