News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by VLM on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:07PM (#6086462)
"because in the history of science, whenever we begin to see how maybe something could kinda, sorta, maybe exist, it's usually just a matter of time (perhaps centuries) until we crack it."

Like mermaids, magic, the halting problem, ESP, and religion?

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by yk on Monday July 22, 2013 @08:03PM (#6087333)
> mermaids

A matter of advanced genetics. ( See C. Stross "Neptune's Brood" ;)

> magic

"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." Arthur C. Clarke

> the halting problem

Any super Turing machine that can calculate busy beaver is sufficient. ( And creates a halting problem of its own.)

> ESP

Let me guess, live TV does not count?

> religion

I am pretty sure that we developed organized religion eons ago.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @08:04AM (#6089458)
I do wish to note as a matter of my own expertise that we don't have super-Turing machines.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by foobarbazqux on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:12PM (#6086491)
To be fair, religion and the halting problem exist.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by VLM on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:19PM (#6086527)
LOL you got me. More specifically, proof of any example in the general category of one, and a solution to the other. Mix and match with the above how you'd like.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by foobarbazqux on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:29PM (#6086579)
Whether we can prove or disprove the existence of God before the heat death of the universe is undecidable?
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by gizmo686 on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:54PM (#6087008)
Wouldn't that imply that we couldn't prove/disprove God's extisnese. If we could prove it, we need only wait until we prove it, then return our answer.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by foobarbazqux on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @04:28AM (#6088837)
It means we don't know if we can prove or disprove, because it may or may not take forever.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by VLM on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:46PM (#6086674)
To throw some fun fuel on the fire, which God, including conceptualizations that may not exist in our time yet.

If a missionary religion is the correct true religion, and FTL exists anywhere in the galaxy, then by definition we should have already been contacted by missionaries and "civilized". Yet we're clearly not civilized, so at minimum at least one must not exist. So its not looking good for the FTL hopefuls.

There is another fun one in that if an all powerful being exists, it seems a bit presumptuous for a mere moral to limit "it" to sublight. Therefore if the concept of FTL exists and an all powerful being exists, then FTL must exist in practice unless we're placing irrational limitations on an inherently unlimited being. Therefore if FTL can be imagined, but not implemented, that proves scientifically most conceptions of "god" do not exist; Or at least "it" is not all powerful. Unclear what impact that logic puzzler would have; probably just about none.

That would make a much more fun rabble rousing article than "yet another star trek communicator / iphone analogy"

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by ars on Monday July 22, 2013 @07:25PM (#6087171)
You've limited yourself too much.

You could have a non-missionary religion (like Judaism). You could have a missionary-religion that considers humans unsuitable for conversion. You could have a missionary-religion that puts some kind of restriction that says they have to wait for some trigger event before contacting humans.

As for God why do you assume God is inside this universe? God could be causing the universe. (Like God would be the computer and the program, and we the results of running the program.)

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by foobarbazqux on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @11:24AM (#6090566)
Or God simply is the universe. Alternatively God is light, so what you need is an FTG drive.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by gizmo686 on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:17PM (#6086829)
>If a missionary religion is the correct true religion, and FTL exists anywhere in the galaxy, then by definition we should have already been contacted by missionaries and "civilized". Yet we're clearly not civilized, so at minimum at least one must not exist. So its not looking good for the FTL hopefuls.

Not nessasarily. Assuming FTL does not imply time-travel, FTL still does not imply the ability to search the entire universe. The alien missionaries would still be limited by their sensors to scout X cubic-meters/year/ship. They would also have a limited supply of spaceships (that may grow exponentially with time).

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by DennisP on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @06:55AM (#6089228)
If the being is all-powerful, it's not restricted by physics. We are.

Or you can say that the all-powerful being exists outside spacetime, and FTL is impossible to anything within spacetime.

So the all-powerful being sees all of spacetime laid out in front of it, like a canvas. The painter dabs paint on the left margin and they streak out toward the right in interesting patterns. The painter dabs paint here and there, the patterns respond, and he continues until he likes the picture.

Asimov had a concept like this in The End of Eternity.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @08:12AM (#6089490)
If a missionary religion is the correct true religion, and FTL exists anywhere in the galaxy, then by definition we should have already been contacted by missionaries and "civilized".

Who says we weren't?

Yet we're clearly not civilized

Says... you?

Or it could just be that God adjusts His teachings to each sapient species's psychology, so having us contacted by Starfish Aliens would be kinda useless.

Or the true religion could be a non-missionary religion, like, as someone so astutely pointed out, Judaism.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by CodeMage on Monday July 22, 2013 @05:52PM (#6086710)
That's odd, I could've sworn that he wrote -- and that you quoted him as having written -- "history of science" and also "could kinda, sorta, maybe exist".
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by gizmo686 on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:13PM (#6086809)
Mermaids: I have little doubt that genetic engineering will reach a point where we could create mermaids if we so choose.

Magic: We call it technology.

Halting problem: Closed time like curves can solve this.

ESP: Brain implants to interact with external tech.

Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 23, 2013 @08:17AM (#6089505)
I don't think that time travel is a neat solution to the Halting Problem.
Re:Faster Than the Speed of Light? by bitwize on Monday July 22, 2013 @06:39PM (#6086931)
Mermaids: SCUBA gear

Magic: Any sufficiently advanced technology

The halting problem: I got nothing for this

ESP: neural interfaces

Religion: given the above our descendants are destined to practically become gods, assuming they exist