So we should rely on your personal experiences instead of scientific studies?
I won't ruin the surprise for everyone.
Much of what is labelled as "science" turns out to be of a similar character.
Whatever its label, we tire of the bullsh-t.
I'll add my initial thought upon running across this HN title/topic: Well, if Linus is a jerk, at least he's an equal opportunity jerk.
P.S. I think it worthy of further noting that in my perception, Linus may well not be "implementing" a "reward system" and "motivation". He may be implementing a filter.
Discouraging crap, as opposed to encouraging contribution. Two different functions.
I might do things somewhat differently than Linus. But then, I'm my own, different little snowflake.
> I've worked with kind of Linus and I have learned from them far more than from most of considerate and gentle minded people(there are exceptions though).
That's because it's easier to act that way for most individuals. It takes real talent to balance the two.
I don't know about you but bar for patches going into stable is that much higher. If people futzing about making crap code they can use it on their own servers, but when patching stable - they should fall in line or submit their code to development branches.
Adding code to the kernel might be fine if you futzing about with your own server, but I sure as hell don't want Linus & Co. letting their guard down because they might hurt someone's feelings.
I've worked with kind of Linus and I have learned from them far more than from most of considerate and gentle minded people(there are exceptions though).