News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by tsm on Sunday July 21, 2013 @06:48PM (#6080658)
These details are befuddling. "Personal information was encrypted and cannot be accessed". It can't be accessed because it's somehow stored elsewhere, or it can't be accessed because of the encryption? That is, does the intruder currently own my encrypted data?

I'm also disappointed that it took them 72 hours to tell us anything, and that the update doesn't even have a timeline for when the site may be back. "Soon" is meaningless.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by ajasmin on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:58PM (#6080978)
Apple should have kept us informed from day one.

But, in their defense it may take days to ascertain what exactly happened.

Once a system is compromised it's nearly impossible to trust anything about it. Auditing the logs, and reviewing the code, crypto, and the mix of platforms they're using (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6078854) in order to understand what data could be accessed and fix all vulnerabilities is not an easy task.

The PlayStation store was not down for such a long time without reason.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by Watabou on Sunday July 21, 2013 @06:56PM (#6080697)
Yeah I'm confused why companies tells us DAYS after something serious happened as opposed to right away. I can understand waiting a day but 3 whole days?! I just don't understand the delay.

It's our data, we should have the right to know what happened to it.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by larrys on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:25PM (#6080839)
"why companies tells us DAYS after something serious happened"

Companies are people. And all the relevant parties involved in handling this may not be accessible to make a decision as quickly as needs to be done. Or at least quickly enough to satisfy all people.

Do you feel you suffered any harm in particular by the delay of three days?

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by Watabou on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:42PM (#6080917)
I'm mainly complaining about the delay in telling us anything.

What I would love is an update whenever they suspect an intruder has accessed sensitive information. Many websites like Dropbox and last.fm do have a server status where they tell us if they have any planned maintenance or just general status of the server. Why can't Apple and the rest of the big companies do that?

Also, Apple first said it was just regular maintenance. I'm just confused as to why they said that instead of telling us the truth.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by justinsteele on Sunday July 21, 2013 @10:52PM (#6081488)
Likely because if you say "we are investigating a possible data leak" and then end with "we discovered it was an undocumented maintenance event by someone on the engineering staff, we have added more detailed logging as well as a better maintenance process so we can be clear about this in the future", many people will think the worst. It's unfortunate.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by badclient on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:01PM (#6080728)
It can take more than a day to know what happened to your data.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by lambda on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:12PM (#6080776)
Yes, but it doesn't take more than a day to know that an intruder had accessed the system in a way that may have compromised your personal information.

Basically, once the problem was serious enough that they felt like they needed to take the site down, I'm pretty sure they knew which machines had been accessed (or at least may have been accessed). They knew that some of those machines had developer's personal information. They could have posted as much up front, rather than waiting 3 days to do so.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by ptwiggens on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:51PM (#6080958)
"I'm pretty sure."

No, they likely took the portal down as soon as they knew there was a breach. Highly unlikely they left it up while they investigated, and it takes time to figure out what happened and how much information was taken.

What motivation would there be to wait anyways?

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by lambda on Monday July 22, 2013 @12:01AM (#6081678)
> No, they likely took the portal down as soon as they knew there was a breach. Highly unlikely they left it up while they investigated, and it takes time to figure out what happened and how much information was taken.

They still haven't said anything about how much had been taken.

My point is they knew how much could have been taken. They knew what machines were at risk; hence taking them down. If those machines that were at risk had sensitive personal information, they should have notified the people affected right away, not three days later.

Taking the site down, with no indication of why, and waiting three days to tell people that their personal information may be at risk (and remember, the possibly compromised information includes credit card numbers, as there are a number of things you need to pay for in your developer account) is just crazy.

You should be upfront and transparent when the breach first occurs. Of course you don't know exactly what has been compromised; but they are still being plenty vague even three days later. If they had posted three days ago what they posted today, it would be a lot more reassuring.

Re:Apple Developer Website Update by tlongren on Sunday July 21, 2013 @06:49PM (#6080671)
As I interpreted it, yes, the intruder does have your encrypted data.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by num3ric on Sunday July 21, 2013 @07:40PM (#6080905)
I hope you were using good encryption Apple. This guy cracked 400,000 md5 hashed passwords: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WPny7wk960 He says even with password salts, it could be done.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by ptwiggens on Sunday July 21, 2013 @08:05PM (#6081013)
Unsalted MD5 has been extremely easy to crack for years. Not sure why the claim would be impressive at this point.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by laumars on Sunday July 21, 2013 @08:44PM (#6081146)
To be fair, unsalted md5 hashes are only one step above storing passwords in plain text.
Re:Apple Developer Website Update by MrGando on Sunday July 21, 2013 @10:24PM (#6081435)
I could crack your unsalted md5 password with my Gameboy Color.