News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by freejack on Friday July 19, 2013 @11:04AM (#6070600)
What's the difference between using a manned aircraft and an unmanned aircraft to do speed enforcement?
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by confluence on Friday July 19, 2013 @11:08AM (#6070635)
Scale and cost. You can't have hundreds of thousands of manned aircraft watching everything - it's too expensive. You can have drones do it though. Especially if their cameras work like the recent ARGUS demonstration (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5273000).
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by jack-r-abbit on Friday July 19, 2013 @12:27PM (#6071136)
Kind of funny when you think about it. We all love to complain about how inefficient the government is... and then we love to complain about how efficient they try to be.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by roc on Friday July 19, 2013 @01:50PM (#6071722)
It's not about the efficiency itself. It's about the constitutional questions that were punted, back when inefficiency made them implausible and thus unnecessary to consider.

So it's not the increased efficiency itself, it's that the efficiency has put the problems we tried to ignore directly in front of us.

And thus we can't sit back and allow "logical extension of the old system" as justification for allowing it, because, again, the old system was only allowed because the scale necessary for abuse was implausible at the time.

Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by __--__ on Friday July 19, 2013 @02:54PM (#6072140)
That's because in this case and many other cases, "efficient" is another way to say "completely bypass the legal system." People want the government to make itself more efficient, not completely bypass the civil protections we have in place.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by freehunter on Friday July 19, 2013 @03:00PM (#6072180)
A drone giving a ticket in exactly the same manner as a cop giving a ticket is not really bypassing the legal system. As long as you're able to contest it, it's exactly the same.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by jack-r-abbit on Friday July 19, 2013 @04:02PM (#6072585)
My thought too. If one plane with a person in it is not bypassing the legal system, then 2 should be fine. And 10? Or 100? Scale should not have anything to do with whether the legal system is bypassed or not. Either none can do something or all can do something.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by tanderson11 on Friday July 19, 2013 @06:05PM (#6073272)
The notion that scale is irrelevant in terms of surveillance operations fails to recognize serious issues raised by the advent of new technologies.

In the past, actual manpower has been a meaningful limit on the size of surveillance operations. The government simply cannot have every person in the country be monitored and watched. Instead - theoretically - the government only has enough resources to surveil those who it actually suspects of a crime.

I direct you to Justice Sotomayor's insightful concurring opinion on United States vs. Jones: http://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/10-1259#writing...

These quotes, in particular, are extremely releveant.

--

"And because GPS monitoring is cheap in comparison to conventional surveillance techniques and, by design, proceeds surreptitiously, it evades the ordinary checks that constrain abusive law enforcement practices: 'limited police resources and community hostility.'"

--

"The net result is that GPS monitoring—by making available at a relatively low cost such a substantial quantum of intimate information about any person whom the Government, in its unfettered discretion, chooses to track—may 'alter the relationship between citizen and government in a way that is inimical to democratic society.'"

--

In my view, this opinion sheds much needed light on how the perception that technology and scale does not influence the legality and constitutionality of government practice fails.

As a footnote, Sotomayor also discusses privacy in a digital age, and she provides a refreshing outlook on how new technologies can force a society to re-think its beliefs on the expectation of privacy.

--

"More fundamentally, it may be necessary to reconsider the premise that an individual has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily disclosed to third parties . . . This approach is ill suited to the digital age, in which people reveal a great deal of information about themselves to third parties in the course of carrying out mundane tasks."

Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by jack-r-abbit on Friday July 19, 2013 @07:45PM (#6073649)
I guess the difference I see is this: are the drones monitoring a person watching for them to commit a crime OR are they monitoring a road looking for anyone committing a crime? I think this distinction is important and you may not. That is fine.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by saraid216 on Friday July 19, 2013 @02:05PM (#6071827)
The government is the enemy. A lot of people couldn't properly live with themselves if they ceased to believe this. There would be a libertarian-shaped hole in their hearts.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by noarchy on Friday July 19, 2013 @02:25PM (#6071929)
It appears that they excel at bad things (fining us, taxing us, conducting wars, etc).
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by freejack on Friday July 19, 2013 @11:15AM (#6070690)
Modern unmanned aerial vehicles like the Northrop Grumman RQ-4 and the General Atomics MQ-1 cost in the millions. Cessna and helicopters do not.

Granted there are cheaper UAV out there, and generally its unlikely they could carry a payload sufficient for the level of surveillance necessary for traffic enforcement.

BTW - my intention isn't to advocate for drones, just to question the rationale of making a distinction between manned and unmanned surveillance, when in fact it might make more sense worrying about being aerial surveillance more generally.

Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by jlgreco on Friday July 19, 2013 @12:16PM (#6071071)
"Granted there are cheaper UAV out there"

In other news, there are smaller ships than the Queen Mary 2...

"Generally its unlikely they could carry a payload sufficient for the level of surveillance necessary for traffic enforcement."

Having been nailed with a speeding ticket from a Cessna: All they need is a camera with someone watching it that can say "blue car, coming from half a mile away". You don't even need radar or any sort of speed tracking, you just time the car between to landmarks (the same way that local police do it in states that only allow state police to use radar guns). The type of drones your local hackerspace whips up for fun on a weekend are damn near sufficient.

Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by confluence on Friday July 19, 2013 @11:27AM (#6070772)
You could jury rig as Cessna in an afternoon. The high costs of defense UAVs are almost wholly due to defense contracting rent seeking and a severe lack of competition. Drones do not cost what you think they cost. People are expensive. Robots aren't.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by speedyrev on Friday July 19, 2013 @11:57AM (#6070969)
Local law enforcement doesn't need million dollar drones or a sizable payload. There are already many small cheap drones available for local use. All that is really needed is a functioning camera.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by freejack on Friday July 19, 2013 @12:22PM (#6071111)
My point is that they don't need drones for aerial enforcement. Its been going on for years and in some ways, the "do it with a drone" element is a bit of a red herring.

The very real question that needs to be considered is whether or not law enforcement should be doing aerial enforcement at all. How they do it is less interesting to me than the question of whether or not they should.

Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by MartinCron on Friday July 19, 2013 @12:30PM (#6071153)
Any freedom that you feel you enjoy based on solely on scale and cost is a tentative one at best.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by chrischen on Friday July 19, 2013 @04:12PM (#6072652)
Cameras have got to be cheaper than drones though, although cameras are easier to avoid.
Re:Fake Signs On Bay Area Highways Say Drones Looking For Sp... by nexox on Friday July 19, 2013 @12:36PM (#6071196)
In California, it doesn't matter, since it's already illegal to give speeding tickets from a manned airplane (even though they still have plenty of signs to warn you that they might do just that.)