News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:30PM (#6064698)
> We are blowing up American Citizens sitting in cafes and legally it's "untouchable".

The crux of the debate is how much an "american citizen" can claim the protection of that citizenship while waging war against the U.S. and evading attempts to bring him to justice for a decade.

Being an American citizen entitles you to due process. Not "a court trial no matter what the circumstances," but some level of process appropriate to the circumstances.

> Stop murdering people.

It's only murder when people who are part of the same social compact and subject to the same law kill each other. When one group of people organized into a state kills people in another group, that's not "murder" it's exercise of the sovereign right of nations.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by acjohnson55 on Thursday July 18, 2013 @12:48PM (#6064801)
> The crux of the debate is how much an "american citizen" can claim the protection of that citizenship while waging war against the U.S. and evading attempts to bring him to justice for a decade.

This applies to Anwar Al-Awlaki himself, and even then the constitutionality of the killing seems highly suspect to me. But his son (the author's granson), Abdulrahman Al-Awlaki, was also killed by a drone strike in Yemen. Nobody has publicly stated a justification for Abdulrahman's death. He was simply an American citizen traveling in the country his family came from, as far as we know.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:12PM (#6064973)
Al-Awlaki's son was killed in a different drone strike a month later targeting different Al Qaeda officials. I don't think he was the intended target. But when you're traveling with Al Qaeda that kind of shit happens, you know?
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by tptacek on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:34PM (#6065143)
It's a tough situation to parse. On the one hand, if you stipulate that the US is going to engage "Al Qaeda" militarily, drone strikes probably save many lives; every alternative, from manned airstrikes through cruise missiles through (God forbid) boots on the ground --- every alternative is empirically worse.

On the other hand, the drone program in essence demands that the US conduct a long-running campaign of assassination. I might not have a moral problem with that in the specific case of actual, bona fide Al Qaeda personnel, but surely this can't be how we deal with all our adversaries moving forward?

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by tsotha on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:09PM (#6064959)
They said he wasn't the target. I doubt they even knew who he was.
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by maratd on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:14PM (#6064997)
> can claim the protection of that citizenship while waging war against the U.S.

I want to make sure we're on the same page here. A child who is not on any kill lists, a boy who according to the laws of our land does not have the capacity to make rational decisions when it comes to having sex, looking at people have sex, drink alcohol, vote, smoke tobacco, rent a car, drive a car, I can go on but it's getting boring? A child who isn't able to do any of those things ... can nevertheless wage war against the US and be executed for treason without due process or even a sham trial? You even get those in Russia, of all places.

Oh wait. They didn't accuse him of treason. Collateral damage then? I guess that's OK.

I would say something offensive that might be construed as treasonous at this point, but the NSA is reading.

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:19PM (#6065037)
I was referring to Al Awalki, not his son. The article makes a soup out of the situation, but his son was killed in a different drone strike a month later that took out an Al Qaeda official: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/16/world/middleeast/yemeni-se.... There was no indication that Al Awalki's son was the target.
Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by maratd on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:33PM (#6065127)
> There was no indication that Al Awalki's son was the target.

No, there was no indication. There was also no acknowledgement, apology, or explanation either. That's what the article is about.

What's done is done. The child is dead. What the government owes every citizen at this point is an explanation of what happened and a clear process to make sure it never happens again.

Instead, there's just silence.

Apparently you can just be killed by the US government for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, even though you're a citizen and deserve proper due process?

That's my take at this point. I wonder at what point the US government will start targeting individuals on US soil? We already have drones flying above our heads here at home. How soon until you're the collateral damage?

Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson by rayiner on Thursday July 18, 2013 @01:35PM (#6065144)
> Apparently you can just be killed by the US government for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, even though you're a citizen and deserve proper due process?

You can't blame the government for not giving due process to someone killed in a military strike where the government didn't even know he was going to be there.

> I wonder at what point the US government will start targeting individuals on US soil?

The slippery slope argument here just doesn't hold up. It's not the first time in history an American has been killed collaterally in a military strike targeted at a foreign enemy. Thousands of American citizens, including POW's, were killed in Hiroshima: http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20118397,00..... It's regrettable and unfortunate, but not a sign of some slippery slope leading to drone strikes on U.S. soil.

The fact is that the rules are different for engagements abroad versus engagements at home and always has been. Not just for the U.S., but for every country in the history of the world.