Re:The Drone that Killed my Grandson
by InclinedPlane on Thursday July 18, 2013 @05:11AM
(#6062570)
A response which includes fighting conventional wars is, I think, justified, but tossing our freedoms out the window is not and never will be "the only effective response" to terrorism.
Going to a foreign land to plot against your home country isn't one of your freedoms.
Due process is
You can't apply due process on foreign soil when the local government isn't willing or able to arrest the person in question.
Did Confederate soldiers get due process on the battlefield?
Thats the thing about democracies. Sometime they sacrifice efficiency in their operations for their values. At least thats how its supposed to work.
>Thats the thing about democracies. Sometime they sacrifice efficiency in their operations for their values.
But not to the point of stupidity. As justice Jackson said, the constitution isn't a suicide pact.
If you think not killing a 16 year old would have materially harmed U.S security, I don't think you're qualified to judge where the stupidity starts.
I disagree. That's the only effective response. bin Laden said as much in communications to his underlings. I agree we should have them arrested where it's possible, but if it isn't a drone strike is the right thing to do.