News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by paulftw on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:23PM (#6061170)
omg. you can be banned but still allowed to post?!

how do I check whether my account is banned?

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by lucb1e on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:36PM (#6061225)
Like someone else commenting on your post said, the entire idea of being hellbanned is not knowing that you are. For the sake of humanity around here, let's not start tonnes of threads asking whether you're hellbanned.

The fact that people are replying to you shows that you are not. Besides that, just keep on commenting and assume everything is okay.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by X4 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:32PM (#6061204)
I was as surprised as you were! Would never ever post to HN personally if I knew that.

Not letting people know that they are banned, but still allowing them to post is very egoistic.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by jlgreco on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:35PM (#6061219)
Egoist? Why?

As far as I can tell it is somewhat distasteful but ultimately too useful to not use. It's pragmatic, I don't see how ego is involved.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by X4 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:41PM (#6061242)
What if you were banned from school and still had to pay them without knowing that you got banned. Even worse, what if all of your schoolmates would ontop of that start ignoring you and nothing you do could change it? Wouldn't that be an egoistic act?

    Legend: pay = posts; schoolmates = HN people/investors
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by ctdonath on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:57PM (#6061306)
You're not paying to use HN, so the analogy is a non-sequitur.

You're a guest in pg's house; hellbanning is a generous form of dealing with the unruly by at least letting them visit and talk to those who want to hear the unruly, without either letting the unruly annoy all the guests or throwing some out entirely.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by X4 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:08PM (#6061356)
>> hellbanning is a generous form of dealing with the unruly by at least letting them visit and talk to those who want to hear the unruly, without either letting the unruly annoy all the guests or throwing some out entirely

That argument is convincing, but I still believe that it's not fair treatment to not letting them at least know about their ban. I didn't know that the unruly can still talk to others. That's changing things completely!

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by X4 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:49PM (#6061275)
Somehow can't reply under your post. By egoistic I mean that someone can continue profiting from the time you take to write posts or submit links without letting you participate with the HN users.
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by DanBC on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:51PM (#6061282)
> Somehow can't reply under your post.

The [reply] button takes longer to show as threads get deeper. This is because deeply nested threads tend to be flame-bait and argument, and slowing down posting is meant to help with that.

Usually clicking the [link] button gives you a text box.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by X4 on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:51PM (#6061283)
Thanks, yes makes sense, didn't know that :)
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by jlgreco on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:44PM (#6061259)
I would have a problem with that practice, but my problem would not be that it is egoist... Are you using egoist as a drop in replacement for "bad"? What do you mean by egoist?
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by noarchy on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:53PM (#6061288)
It is pretty passive-aggressive. An outright ban would get the point across, rather than this weird toying with people that we see in the form of hellbanning.
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by DanBC on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @10:09PM (#6061359)
It's supposed to be passive aggressive. That's the point. It's not supposed to get any point across. Hell-banning is a form of "do not feed the trolls".

Some people enjoy making useless posts. They can continue making useless posts. Just with hellbanning most people no longer see those useless posts.

Some people are accidentally hellbanned. It sucks for those people. But they can sometimes become unbanned, or they can start a new account.

Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by schrodingersCat on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:33PM (#6061211)
you're not banned
Re:Ask pg: why have hellbans become so widespread on HN? by mr_spothawk on Wednesday July 17, 2013 @09:37PM (#6061230)
You must be banned because I can't read what you post.