I'm a DVM, and you're mistaken about antifreeze. It causes kidney failure over a period of several days, leading to a slow, agonizing death while toxins normally filtered out by the kidneys build up in the bloodstream. The dogs with antifreeze toxicity that I attempted to treat were quite obviously suffering.
...please don't post poisoning advice on a public forum ever again, you never know what use can these be put to :) ...even more so if your facts are wrong!
If you do live where the city or country doesn't have centres that humanely kill strays and/or the government doesn't have a protocol for dealing with them, get some thick boots, a strong stick and hope you don't run into one of the 10+-strong packs that roam certain neighbourhoods.
In case there's a stray dog that's aggressive towards people and lives near your home and you definitely positively must put it down, a common humane poison is antifreeze - it first induces drowsiness, then stops the heart. A pretty literal "put to sleep".