Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by haven on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:04PM
(#6049818)
OpenOffice isn't the OpenOffice you used to know (just a fork of LibreOffice with Oracle's TMed name). If I recall, Oracle just handed it off to the Apache Foundation after losing developer support and being dropped by prominent linux distros. Oracle called LibreOffice a fork, but that is nonsense since it is the original maintainers and code with only a new name. I'm actually curious why Apache Foundation took on OpenOffice following Oracle's misteps and what the rationale is for its existence alongside LibreOffice. (There is one, right?) To be fair, I haven't used them side by side or followed OpenOffice since the Oracle debacle.
TL;DR: Oracle forked OpenOffice and kept the name. Long live LibreOffice!
It doesn't matter which people do or do not work on the project at this point. The original owners of OpenOffice donated the project to the Apache foundation (under less restrictive licensing terms I might add).
So at this point, it doesn't matter what happened to the project in the past, OpenOffice is now an Apache project owned by the Apache foundation.
TL;DR: The OpenOffice project (now part of the Apache Software Foundation) announced the second release candidate for the soon to be released OpenOffice 4.0.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by Shish2k on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:51AM
(#6050470)
> The accepted definition of a software fork is a copy of
> an existing project that is independently developed.
> ...
> It doesn't matter which people do or do not work on the
> project at this point
Surely if the definition is "independently developed", then which people are developing it is the only thing that matters?
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by binarycrusader on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:50PM
(#6054303)
The independently developed (in my mind) is not referring to the people developing it, but rather the fact that the new copy is developed independently of the old project.
As an example, you can have the same set of developers on a new project, but as long as it's a copy of an old project, most people still expect that to be called a fork since the development of that copy is independent of the original.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by ewzimm on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:48PM
(#6049918)
From what I can tell, OpenOffice is now the successor to IBM's Lotus Symphony (which was previously an OpenOffice fork). IBM donated their code to Apache, so anyone coming from that software can maintain UI elements that LibreOffice does not have.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by binarycrusader on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @03:53PM
(#6054318)
OpenOffice is now owned by the Apache Software Foundation; don't you think the Apache Software Foundation wanted to be able to release under the Apache License?
Complaining about the license being incompatible is a bit silly; the choice of license by the Apache Software Foundation should not be a surprise.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by vamega on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @10:27AM
(#6052058)
It's not really incompatible with LibreOffice. The difference is that you OO.o can't take code from LibreOffice, but code from OO.o can find it's way into LO without any issues.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by ExpiredLink on Tuesday July 16, 2013 @05:29AM
(#6050757)
IMO, the main problem for LibreOffice is not OpenOffice but compatibility with the industry standard. Like it or not, you need to reasonably read and write the MS document formats.
Re:Apache Openoffice 4.0 RC Released
by rdtsc on Monday July 15, 2013 @11:52PM
(#6049934)
Exactly. Why? Not only that, who contributes to it, why?
Hasn't the train left the station so to speak? Why not just say ok it is called LibreOffice. Most devs moved there. Let's focus on that product. I understand Oracle maybe continuing supporting it on their own dime because they got butthurt, why did Apache Foundation bother?
TL;DR: Oracle forked OpenOffice and kept the name. Long live LibreOffice!
In other news, LibreOffice 4 has been released: https://www.libreoffice.org
Therefore, LibreOffice is a fork:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fork_(software_development)
It doesn't matter which people do or do not work on the project at this point. The original owners of OpenOffice donated the project to the Apache foundation (under less restrictive licensing terms I might add).
So at this point, it doesn't matter what happened to the project in the past, OpenOffice is now an Apache project owned by the Apache foundation.
TL;DR: The OpenOffice project (now part of the Apache Software Foundation) announced the second release candidate for the soon to be released OpenOffice 4.0.
Surely if the definition is "independently developed", then which people are developing it is the only thing that matters?
As an example, you can have the same set of developers on a new project, but as long as it's a copy of an old project, most people still expect that to be called a fork since the development of that copy is independent of the original.
Jenkins and Hudson is other misstep. After the hudson fallout which make Jenkins, they gave Hudson to Eclipse to maintain.
Complaining about the license being incompatible is a bit silly; the choice of license by the Apache Software Foundation should not be a surprise.
Claims better document fidelity http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/Documentation/Fidelity_Impro...
and a new UI to differentiate from LibreOffice http://wiki.openoffice.org/wiki/Sidebar
Hasn't the train left the station so to speak? Why not just say ok it is called LibreOffice. Most devs moved there. Let's focus on that product. I understand Oracle maybe continuing supporting it on their own dime because they got butthurt, why did Apache Foundation bother?
This is in the same boat as Hudson vs Jenkins.
Even if a company needs to defend its trademarks and such, why is there almost a need to ruin everything else in the process?
When I recommend LibreOffice to people I invariably have to spell it out :(
And I don't know, the movie looked terrible so it never came up :)