News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:03AM (#6032599)
You're presenting a false choice: It's entirely possible to care about privacy, and still use Facebook and GMail.

Simply pretend that everything you post on Facebook and GMail is in the public domain, posted in the public square.

If I never share anything I don't want public, then my privacy is guaranteed. I'd advise others with privacy concerns to do the same.

Given that you NEVER KNOW, EVER that you can 100% trust the people you're sharing with (no matter which media you use), I think people are kind of crazy to act any other way.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by deelowe on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:24PM (#6033461)
This only considers the current state of 3rd parties, governments, and laws. The gigantic issue with all this is that everything is stored indefinitely. Also, laws and governments change. What's to stop you from suffering tomorrow for seemingly innocuous actions you performed today? And I'm not just talking about getting prosecuted for some specific crime. This data is used as a means of proactive prosecution and profiling. This means that the powers that be are actively looking for signals in the noise that indicate crime(and most likely just things they don't agree with, illegal or not). If the profile created off your various seemingly innocent actions and "meta-data" over the course of many years puts you within the error bars, you could become a false positive. With secret courts, secret prisons, and indefinite detention all possible, what's to stop you from simply disappearing? Or, at the vary least, what's to stop all of this from ruining your life even if you are never convicted of anything(e.g. months of detention and interrogation without prosecution, inability to travel, holds placed on bank accounts, calls to employer, etc...)?

That said, the focus shouldn't be on the companies that collect this data. They are simply doing the best they can to make a profit within the bounds of the law. No, the issue is government. There should be strict laws regulating how data is collected and stored(even non "PII") and even stricter laws around how 3rd parties are allowed to consume, store, and use this data, especially governments. But alas, this is asking the police to police themselves, so I guess this will never happen.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by crpatino on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:34PM (#6035349)
I opted out of facebook, years ago. Now I am seriously considering the possibility to go back because I fear the lack of an idiot FB profile will at some point be a strongly weighted part of the very signal you are mentioning.

So, cat pics for everyone!!!

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by laxatives on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:54PM (#6035831)
It's sad that the default state for most people is to have a facebook account and that you have to decide to opt out. I did the same a few years ago and its a painful process with lots of downsides (missed invitations and opportunities to track people down). Taking your privacy seriously means its also harder for friends and family to find you.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by jamesbritt on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:57PM (#6036402)
Taking your privacy seriously means its also harder for friends and family to find you.

I don't follow. My friends and family have always know how to find me. This has been true even without Facebook.

They know because I've told them. Often in person. Or by phone.

I'm sort of puzzled by the idea of there being people who are important to me who I don't keep in regular touch with without having to rely on some specific Web site.

If anything, sites like Facebook are good for looking into people I don't really care about, or who don't really care about me.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by dinduks on Saturday July 13, 2013 @03:01PM (#6038374)
That's not the case for everybody.

I personally live thousand kilometers away from my family and friends, and it's just hard to keep in touch with everybody without a social network. Phone calls, mails and chat would never be as efficient/cheap/time-saving that social networks. Plus, they lack that "social" thing.

Regarding that "elitism" when you talk about your friends, there's "family and close friends", and there's "friends", the ones that are not _that_ important in your life, but with whom you'd still like to be in touch with.

Take for example the "keeping in touch" point. I'm going home in few weeks, I just had to post a Facebook status to tell all my friends so we can meet. How would I do it without Facebook? Send mails? Not everyone use emails. Call them, it's freaking expensive.

Privacy concerns scare me, and that's why I'm trying to leave Google stuff, but leaving Facebook is just impossible at the moment, simply because it's useful and there's no alternative.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by pyre on Saturday July 13, 2013 @03:13AM (#6036947)
I guess it's different if you have a large extended family. Personally, the extended family on my mother's side keeps a directory (she had a large family) of email + phone + address for all of the aunts, uncles, cousins, etc. Someone just updates it once a year.

I can see people relying on Facebook to keep track of this rather than needing to have someone manually manage it. On the other hand, since it's family, you can just call someone you do have the number for, and work your way through the chain to get to someone that has the correct info.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by k-mcgrady on Saturday July 13, 2013 @09:00AM (#6037447)
Facebook has become an essential communications platform. Opting out is like someone opting out of the telephone 50 years ago because the operator could listen in to your calls.

The privacy concerns we have about Facebook I know older relatives had about the telephone. To this day they still refrain from giving out much information on it and keep calls as short as possible.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by ladzoppelin on Saturday July 13, 2013 @02:53PM (#6038351)
This is not true and Facebook is getting tedious for many people. The web is what matters not Facebook.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by Sven7 on Friday July 12, 2013 @08:43PM (#6036222)
A good time time to join Facebook would be after their first major data loss/leak/scam/disaster.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:04PM (#6034025)
Tell me how I can share private information, but avoid the consequences you describe. I don't believe you can. Therefore, I see no particular disadvantage to Facebook and GMail (over any other possible solution), as long as I realize that the government IS watching me.

And yes, the issue is government.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by ownagefool on Saturday July 13, 2013 @07:12AM (#6037270)
It's technically possible with encryption. One cannot be sure that said encryption will not be trivially broken in the future, but theres a massive difference between using a service that doesn't know how to read your data now and one that does.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Monday July 15, 2013 @12:08PM (#6046433)
It doesn't matter if it's technically possible, because the legal framework can still punish you:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Key_disclosure_law

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by deelowe on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:29PM (#6036571)
I wish I knew... :-/
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by LoganCale on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:34AM (#6032786)
Facebook tracks your external web browsing history through the use of their embedded buttons, and links that history with your profile. So even if you don't post private information to Facebook, they're tracking your private activity unless you take measures to block such buttons across the web.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:31AM (#6033105)
...or use Facebook in a different browser (or Incognito), or specifically log out of Facebook when you're not using it.

Or only use it in the Facebook App on your phone, but never log your browser in to it.

"Logging in" is completely broken on the internet - no argument, there.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by LoganCale on Friday July 12, 2013 @01:08PM (#6033709)
The other two approaches may work, but

> or specifically log out of Facebook when you're not using it

will probably not, because they set tracking cookies that remain even when you log out.

Complete speculation here, but if they're willing to do that, who's to say they don't link traffic from known IP addresses as well? It might be linked less strongly but in many cases could still be associated in some way. They track web browsing for non-users already anyway, so if they can connect that to existing users by IP I'd be fairly surprised if they didn't.

In order to prevent this, you have to block trackers in all your browsers and devices with Ghostery or similar tools.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by Orva on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:22PM (#6035285)
Browser user agent string alone is quite accurate identification [1]. Just add IP/country data on top of that..
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by flyinRyan on Friday July 12, 2013 @03:32PM (#6034644)
If people can't be bothered to care about security, they won't be interested in doing this.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by wutbrodo on Friday July 12, 2013 @01:14PM (#6033753)
With the immaturity of the app permissions model and Facebook's abysmal record, I feel like you're far better off using a mobile browser (in incognito, of course) than the mobile app.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by chris_mahan on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:57AM (#6033246)
or on a different computer.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by crpatino on Friday July 12, 2013 @05:39PM (#6035377)
connected to the neighbor's open wifi?
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by disgruntledphd2 on Saturday July 13, 2013 @06:41AM (#6037234)
Nope, not if you're outside the US. Seriously getting sick of repeating this, but whatever. Facebook Ireland (mmm, double Irish) is the data controller for all Facebook users outside the US, and they released a report which prevents facebook from doing this. AFAIK, they said that this data can only be retained for 30 days and cannot be linked to user profiles and/or used for targeted advertising.

For some strange reason, the same requirements do not apply to Google, and Twitter are currently being investigated.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by rcabrillo on Friday July 12, 2013 @09:07PM (#6036292)
Facebook can't track you regardless of whether you have an account much less whether are logged in IF you use Firefox's RequestPolicy plugin.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by GoodIntentions on Saturday July 13, 2013 @11:03AM (#6037669)
was about to post the same. Request policy + noscript ftw
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by rhizome on Friday July 12, 2013 @03:43PM (#6034725)
Facebook tracks your external web browsing history through the use of their embedded buttons, and links that history with your profile

Not if you log out of FB. Conveniently, the "Like" button tells you when you're logged in and the "(Not You?)" link allows you to log out of FB whenever you notice you're still logged in. Hmm, this gives me an idea for an indicator browser extension.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by LoganCale on Friday July 12, 2013 @06:33PM (#6035712)
Yes, it does, through the use of tracking cookies that persist after you log out. They also track non-users.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by cdrxndr on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:12PM (#6033367)
They say they don't keep shadow profiles of your external Web traffic [though I can't imagine that's true].

In line with other responses, I use a browser plugin that blocks all traffic to Facebook when I'm not on a facebook.com domain, and I exclusively sign in via incognito mode so the session is destroyed when I'm finished.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by marssaxman on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:59PM (#6033662)
Easy enough: I have a separate browser for connecting to Facebook. I also have the usual set of tracker-blocking plugins installed on Firefox, which I use for normal browsing.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by ahsiduhfisuh on Friday July 12, 2013 @04:42PM (#6035052)
Google also tracks you on non-Google sites that use Google-hosted Ajax libraries, which is a huge chunk of the web.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by pyre on Saturday July 13, 2013 @03:30AM (#6036972)
If they do, that's a lot more devious that Facebook's "like" button, because if you block it, then the site doesn't work.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by gcb0 on Sunday July 14, 2013 @02:31AM (#6040158)
That's silly. I block it (via the someonewhocares host file) and not it works but makes browsing faster.

Only downside is when i click done actual useful advertising result on gsearch i get a 404 :)

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by pyre on Sunday July 14, 2013 @04:48AM (#6040374)
How is it silly? When someone loads jQuery from Google, and their site depends on jQuery, do you expect the site to still work when you block Google's CDN?
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by gcb0 on Monday July 15, 2013 @01:03PM (#6046870)
no major provider serve ads and jquery/yui mirrors from the same CNAME...

i know your example is moot because google doesn't

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by coda_ on Friday July 12, 2013 @10:39AM (#6032813)
I agree with you that it's a false choice.

But the part about never sharing anything private with anyone, regardless of the media used... maybe I'm misunderstanding it. That sounds like a terrible way to live. By living that way, you are not retaining your privacy... you've already lost it.

You could die when get on plane, but you still do it, because the reward is worth the risk. Someone could wire tap my house, but I don't let that stop me from having private conversations with my family. There's a risk/reward balance that each of us have to set with respect to our privacy and our ability to share and interact with other people. To say the risk always outweighs the reward seems a little extreme.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:17AM (#6033026)
Pretend I choose that the risk of me sharing something with you (that you might make it public) is worth it.

By doing that, and using any given media that I don't entirely control and that I can't guarantee I can perfectly secure, I'm also accepting the risk that either the provider of the service(s), or a hacker, could also make the information public or share it with the government.

Think about the risk of my friends making the information public, intentionally or unintentionally (they have lousy passwords, or share passwords with friends, or don't use SSL in a cafe, or have an easy to guess Password Recovery answers, or they forget to log out on a computer someone can sneak onto, or they get hit by a keylogger and don't use two-factor authentication like I do, or they get hit by phishing).

I think that risk is ORDERS OF MAGNITUDE more likely than the risk that the media provider (Google, Facebook) will, intentionally or unintentionally, make the information public. Or somehow use it to harm me.

Also, the damage, should that risk occur, to me, is very low. (Based on the type of information I share.)

Now, every layer of the service provider is also demonstrably sharing with the government. That's happening.

And many people here are blaming Google (the victim) rather than the government (the abuser), which makes no sense to me.

I accept the argument that we ALL need protection from government spying. I really do. But I have yet to see someone propose how to avoid using an ISP. And many of the people abandoning Google are still running Windows. Or how to abandon a major cell provider.

Dropping Google, while continuing to use major ISPs and Cell providers is like changing which STAMP you put on your postcard, and expecting that will somehow stop the postman from reading it.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by mariuolo on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:55PM (#6034406)
Given the scope and reach such services have, one ought to be parsimonious with any private information put online, because it might eventually be correlated with the former.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by jancborchardt on Saturday July 13, 2013 @05:33AM (#6037128)
The problem with that is that while you might be conscious of that, other people might not be. And you using Facebook and Gmail pulls these people in, for example an email sent to you by someone not using Gmail will still end up on Google’s servers.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by lupatus on Friday July 12, 2013 @11:42PM (#6036593)
Better yet, pretend that everything you say/post/share will be seen on a jumbotron at a packed sporting arena.

This way, you will have data security, better grammar, and fewer embarrassing personal moments.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by alan_cx on Friday July 12, 2013 @12:54PM (#6033639)
It is a difficult choice, not a false one. That is why you and others are trying to justify not making one. Writing it off as false is a convenient excuse.
Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by VikingCoder on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:00PM (#6034000)
You just asserted that BECAUSE I use Facebook and GMail, that PROVES I don't care about privacy.

Your assertion is false.

Re:Don't be evil: Moving everything off of Google by nollidge on Friday July 12, 2013 @02:48PM (#6034364)
> It is a difficult choice, not a false one.

Please state your case for this. VikingCoder stated theirs.