The fundamental import of Apple's actions was that it significantly increased prices for eBooks without fundmentally altering the value proposition (i.e., eBooks before Apple's price-fixing are no different than eBooks post-price-fixing). The difference in price is the "harm" that consumers have suffered--it represents the increased prices they have to pay over the prices they would have paid had Apple not colluded to artificially increase prices in a way the market did not support.
That's not true. Apple eliminated windowing. I.e. pre-Apple some ebooks were being delayed for some time after their print releases. Apple's scheme guaranteed they'd be released at the same time. That's a major difference and a major value-add.
In this ebook deal, Apple was negotiating the prices up with multiple parties so that they could get their cut and the publishers would still make the same or more than they did from Amazon.
The difference is, if you are in negotiations with multiple publishers (read: conspiring) to raise prices, that's bad for consumers. As an analogy, imagine if Exxon, Shell, BP, Total, et al. somehow colluded to sell gas for 50 cents more per gallon. If all the major oil companies did it, none of them would lose very much business.
The only part I'm missing is how this is as bad as my analogy, because consumers could still choose to buy from Amazon. There are even Kindle apps for almost every device including iOS devices.
Maybe someone can enlighten me on that part.
You can argue whether or not Amazon is participating in predatory pricing now, but should Amazon end up raising prices (not entirely obvious that will happen)[2][3], then this case could end up being pointed to in the future as a lost opportunity to let the market correct itself.
[1] http://paidcontent.org/2013/07/09/barnes-noble-throws-out-it...
[2] http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/Saving-Money/2013/0518/Wil...
[3] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/05/business/as-competition-wa...