Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books
by abalone on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @05:25PM
(#6022948)
>eBooks before Apple's price-fixing are no different than eBooks post-price-fixing
That's not true. Apple eliminated windowing. I.e. pre-Apple some ebooks were being delayed for some time after their print releases. Apple's scheme guaranteed they'd be released at the same time. That's a major difference and a major value-add.
Re:Judge rules Apple conspired to raise prices on e-books
by newbie300 on Friday July 12, 2013 @03:05AM
(#6031301)
That's not entirely accurate; the publishers already knew windowing was stupid and a short term measure. Not every publisher was using windowing. You can read about it on page 25 of the Judje's report.
The fundamental import of Apple's actions was that it significantly increased prices for eBooks without fundmentally altering the value proposition (i.e., eBooks before Apple's price-fixing are no different than eBooks post-price-fixing). The difference in price is the "harm" that consumers have suffered--it represents the increased prices they have to pay over the prices they would have paid had Apple not colluded to artificially increase prices in a way the market did not support.