News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by pron on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:00AM (#6018871)
I'm not saying that your view is wrong, but I should point out that it neuters almost every kind of political action.

Almost every undertaking is carried out by a large group of people. Most of them are innocent. All of them are probably nice. But bad things are often done by nice people -- sometimes because they don't realize that they're bad. Sometimes because they don't care enough. There are no bond-villains in real life. People who do evil don't think that that's what they're doing.

A possibly controversial example relevant to this forum is Google. I'm personally convinced that Google is one of the most sinister and "evil" (to use their own parlance) corporations that has ever existed, and I can support that claim (though I won't be doing that now). Yet, I know that not only are most Google employees really nice and innocent, even their top management has the best of intentions. Still, Google is evil.

Once you understand that good intentions often lead to evil actions, you get a different understanding of political action. Precisely because many people have participated in the making of this film, it is important to boycott it (if you agree with the boycotter's arguments). Otherwise, people will always have the defense of "but I'm just an actor", or "I didn't know". Everything we do is a political statement, and ignoring that fact is a political statement in itself, which says "I don't care about the message my work sends, I only care about my career".

Maybe if you boycott the film, those innocent actors will learn that next time they should make it their business to learn who they're working for.

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by pron on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:05AM (#6018905)
Replying to myself:

I haven't read Ender's Game, and I don't even know what it's about, but reading the Wikipedia article I've found something ironic:

Radford's criticisms are echoed in John Kessel's essay "Creating the Innocent Killer: Ender's Game, Intention, and Morality." Kessel reasons that Card justifies Ender's righteous rage and violence: "Ender gets to strike out at his enemies and still remain morally clean. Nothing is his fault."

It looks like (according to this criticism) that the author embodies the very viewpoint I pointed at. Namely that as long as your intentions are pure -- or, more precisely, innocent -- you are not responsible for your actions.

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by Amadou on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:52AM (#6019133)
I haven't read the essay, and its been decades since I read any of Card's books. But IIRC, the ending of the first book did not excuse him at all, it wrapped up abruptly and left the reader (me at least) reeling as to the full consequences of Ender's actions. A (the?) primary theme of the sequels was Ender trying to atone for his actions.

The lesson I took from the first book was that blind faith in leaders is terribly destructive -- that a moral person can never hand over the responsibility for their morality to anyone else. I was a teenager when I read it and I'd put that down as one of the formative lessons of my teen years.

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by EnderMB on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @09:39AM (#6019366)
You've not answered why his views mean that I cannot enjoy his work. If I'm served a sandwich by a racist, does this mean that I shouldn't eat it? I just don't see why I should care what every person who creates a product or body of work should think.
Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by pron on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @10:15AM (#6019721)
Of course you can enjoy his work, but that is a political statement, like almost everything else you do. If you think his views are abhorrent and unwelcome in the society you wish to build, you may have the moral obligation to make a statement to that effect by boycotting his work.

If a racist serves you a sandwich and you find racism unacceptable in society, then rejecting the sandwich is a political action saying that such views are so unacceptable that you're unwilling to put them aside even for the sake of a meal. Of course, this is a strong political expression, and perhaps not the right one for any view you don't like.

Mr. Card in his response basically says, yeah, I know my views aren't popular, but it's not a big deal. You should "tolerate" them. Now, that is the question you should ask yourself: should you argue with Mr. Card's but tolerate his views, or do you think such views should not be tolerated in society. If it's the latter, then you have an obligation not to let him, or others who work with him, define his or their beliefs as personal and unrelated to their work.

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by EnderMB on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @11:34AM (#6020413)
Why is it a political statement, and why should this affect how I enjoy his work? As I mentioned above, it doesn't stop people enjoying Roald Dahl's work, either because they don't know of his views or feel that his views are irrelevant to one of the countless millions of replica products they own that is attributed to his work.

I'm not trying to be purposely argumentative. I just cannot see why I should view it as a political statement, rather than a "I just want to see an awesome movie" statement. Also, why should people care that others should not see this movie?

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by pron on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @05:45PM (#6023049)
Almost everything you do is a political statement. If you don't accept that, that's a political statement in itself. Feeling that someone's beliefs are irrelevant to their work is certainly a political statement. I mean, let's take it to the extreme: suppose an artist brutally murdered your entire family. Would you still be able to enjoy his work? Would you think that his actions are irrelevant? If you think that someone's beliefs and political views are irrelevant to their work, it simply means that they simply don't mean so much to you. That is a political statement.

Also, Roald Dahl is dead, and was, in his life, a quirky writer. Card, according to Wikipedia, is a political activist. An action against him would be quite effective, and meaningful.

Re:"Ender's Game" movie faces a boycott by dmansen on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @08:19AM (#6018980)
I posted it above, but here's that essay if anyone is interested: http://www4.ncsu.edu/~tenshi/Killer_000.htm