News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by mrbrowning on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @11:50AM (#6013247)
So, I want to preface my comment by saying that I think this video is really well-made and entertaining, and that it's a decent attempt at making serialism accessible to a wider audience than it's traditionally had.

That said, it's littered with inaccuracies that I don't think we would tolerate if this were one of Vi Hart's math videos. Most egregiously, I think, is that she wrongly ascribes some of Schoenberg's dogma to Stravinsky: Stravinsky never had much to say about the desirability of conditioning children to understand dodecaphonic music intuitively (Schoenberg may not have either -- if I had my copy of Strunk's Source Readings in Music History on me right now I could verify this, but if I remember correctly it was either Webern or an unrelated third party who promulgated this particular vision of the ascendancy of avant garde music), nor was he particularly committed to using all twelve tones in his tone rows -- Agon, one of his most famous serialist works, employs a seventeen-tone row at one point [1]. Early on in the video, she selects a tone row at random and sort of dismissively asserts that no one would be able to tell the difference anyway. This is frustrating, because masters like Schoenberg did in fact order their rows to ensure not only structural but sonic coherence, using techniques such as hexachordal combinatoriality [2]. Now, that's not to say that these considerations are audible to most listeners -- one of serialism's greatest failings, in my opinion, is that much of its content is only discoverable on paper even by highly trained musicians -- but it's certainly audible to some, and it's worth noting that this runs counter to her assertion that musical lines don't have meaning until they're embedded in a harmonic context: it's not even true with serialism as practiced! It's certainly the case that many melodic lines can make sense in multiple harmonic contexts, but the idea that melodies imply their supporting harmony has been a foundational concept in Western music since at least the Baroque, and to counter otherwise is absurd -- otherwise we would be unable to comprehend the harmonic movements of e.g. a solo flute piece. This gets at my major frustration with this presentation, which is that to present serialism as merely a fun and basically arbitrary means of constraining your artistic output is deeply hostile to the reasons for why the technique was developed and the music that people made with it. Maybe you're rolling your eyes at this level of nitpickery, but the fact is that it's reasonable to expect someone who's posturing as an educator to have a better handle on the source material than I see here.

I've gotten flak from people for pointing out problems with her videos on music before, and I wonder if it's just because we don't have enough respect for music as a discipline to want to hear it when someone gets things wrong. For that reason I want to reiterate that this my criticism here isn't hostile, it's not meant as a takedown, but as someone with stakes in the material being presented I don't want to see it being presented inaccurately.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agon_(ballet)#Music

[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combinatoriality#Hexachordal_co...

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by stephencanon on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:18PM (#6013411)
This is a really excellent comment. I would go further and point out that it’s slightly missing-the-point to apply harmonic variation to a tone-row structure. Serialism, as practiced by the big three, represented in part a rejection of harmonic variation and a renewed focus on counterpoint instead of harmony (especially the primacy of the tone-row variational operations of transposition, inversion, and retrograde motion, which seem to be ignored entirely in the video—or at least in the first 12 minutes, which is all I’ve made it through, admittedly).

None of this is to say that one can’t build tonal structures over a tone-row, or engage in harmonic variation; some of my favorite compositions do exactly that. It’s just worth keeping in mind that this has relatively little to do with serial composition as practiced by it’s originators, who really were trying for a genuinely atonal approach.

(If I had to guess regarding the quote, I would say Berg or Webern, but I don’t have an actual reference available either).

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by kroger on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @04:57PM (#6015434)
"Serialism, as practiced by the big three, represented in part a rejection of harmonic variation and a renewed focus on counterpoint instead of harmony"

This is true, specially in Webern's compositions. The canonical (pun intended) example is Webern's Symphony op. 21, which is a four voice cannon:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XKD_tZr-ZpY

Webern was greatly influenced by Renaissance composers such as Heinrich Isaac:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqpXLTJDsWg

On the other hand, Schoenberg and specifically Berg have a more harmonic approach to their compositions as we can see in Berg's violin concerto:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oqSSHwFEn_8 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violin_Concerto_(Berg)

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by leephillips on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:23PM (#6013434)
I would have to watch the video again with your comments in mind, but before I find time for that I want to say that I'm not sure she made the assertion that musical lines don't have meaning until they're embedded in a harmonic context, by which it seems you take a context explicitly supplied by the composer. She seems to be saying that there is no meaning, anywhere, without some kind of context, which I think is inarguable. As you say, the harmonic context can be implied, or, in other words, supplied by the listener's brain.

I think she failed to point out that the goal (or a major goal) of serialism was to create lines without tonal centers. But there is a trenchant objection to the serialist program by a famous composer (I forget who), which is that the listener never hears a line floating free of tonality, but his brain insists on supplying one; the outcome being that one hears a constantly shifting tonal center, rather than atonality, and so the 12-tone technique fails in its goals.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by mrbrowning on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:35PM (#6013529)
Well, that's how I understood the comment about listening to people sing on the subway -- she casts it as though the uninitiated listener isn't going to be able to pick out the harmonic context of what the people are singing and will therefore find it semantically void. That definitely happens, but in most cases it's the result of bad singing and not lack of context. Most pop music lines are designed to project a tonal center pretty well, if only by the relatively crude means of just harping on the tonic and related chord tones rather than strictly cadencing, so I think even your average non-musician would have a good sense of the key if a single person with decent pitch were singing such a line in public. But I think we agree on that already!

As for the composer who said that, I think it was Walter Piston? It's definitely an interesting and arguable assertion, especially because it's theoretically testable. I think we probably currently lack the neurological understanding to reliably gauge by any means what tonal context a listener is holding in their mind, but to this layman it seems like a surmountable challenge.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by leephillips on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:51PM (#6013649)
Interesting - I thought she was talking about bad signing making sense to people who knew what the tune was supposed to be, but maybe not. Things fly by pretty fast in her videos; there's often not time to digest her point before she goes on to something else.

I'm not a neuroscientist, but I know that we've had a tonotopic map of the brain for many years: a mapping of frequencies heard to locations in the brain, that can be constructed for any individual. The points lie on a neat curve. And since, often, thinking about a stimulus lights up the same location in the brain associated with perceiving the stimulus, we could conceivably play notes and see what other notes the listener associates with them.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by dnautics on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @01:02PM (#6013734)
"Early on in the video, she selects a tone row at random and sort of dismissively asserts that no one would be able to tell the difference anyway."

I took this that she was saying this in the voice of the critics, setting it up to be dismissed, because later on in the video she plays a serialist piece of her own composition and you CAN hear the patterns quite easily.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by everettForth on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @02:42PM (#6014427)
Have you ever tried watching James Burke's "Connections"? A lot of facts are wrong, and connections are weak, but it's still more entertaining and educational than 99% of the stuff out there. I could say the same thing about the "Radiolab" podcast.

If you really want to help these people (and all of us), why don't you email Vi Hart, and offer your fact-checking services for her next video?

I'm sure her production team is quite small (~1). I love her videos, but I'd also to be happy for them to be more accurate.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by dusklight on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @05:13PM (#6015541)
Keeping in mind her "pi = 4" and similar videos, isn't it better for the audience to always be questioning and always be fact-checking than to blindly trust that what she says is correct?
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by gohrt on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @06:50PM (#6016229)
What's is incorrect about http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D2xYjiL8yyE ?

She points out a paradox in a seemingly intuitive method of computing a limit.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by dusklight on Wednesday July 10, 2013 @04:34AM (#6018150)
I didn't say it was incorrect, I said that the audience should always fact check. I am also not saying it is correct. Boolean logic has stunted our minds. There is not only true and false. There is true, false, unknown, and undefined.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by dusklight on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @05:05PM (#6015493)
Keeping in mind the section of the video about sports and kids on the train talking to each other, is it possible that she is not wrong, but that you misunderstood what she was trying to say? If there was some misunderstanding of communication, it is at least partially her fault because she made the choices of communications medium and communications distribution, but keeping in mind the overall tenor of her channel, who do you think she is trying to reach and what do you think she is trying to say?
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by adamdavis on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:31PM (#6013491)
Regarding the conditioning of children to understand dodecaphonic music intuitively, I seem to remember hearing a storyof how Webern would make the claim that in the future children would be whistling his music in the streets. If that is considered to be true, it was most likely he who had serious thoughts about this subject.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by Luc on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:11PM (#6013364)
We now await the comment from an even more pedantic professor of music picking the details of _your_ comment apart.

(Instead of criticizing, you could have framed this as interesting elucidation and additional info instead, and let people make up their own mind)

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by stephencanon on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:46PM (#6013602)
His comment was an interesting elucidation. It offers both meaningful criticism and valuable historical context.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by Luc on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:59PM (#6013713)
And I'm telling you, the criticism is unwarranted. Anyone who's ever attempted to explain a deep and complex subject as succinctly as possible knows that corners need to be cut. But you can be certain that when you do this, someone will want to show off their expert knowledge by finding nits to pick.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by adamdavis on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:26PM (#6013457)
Take it easy, friend.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by tankbot on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:07PM (#6013340)
You are correct. But, you are also boring.

You are also not the target audience of Vi Hart's videos.

The point is to make this stuff accessible to people who would otherwise never be exposed to it and hopefully inspire them to further investigate. Hart accomplishes this by being entertaining and generalizing some of the material.

Complaining and nitpicking the details of this video is like watching a movie with someone and calling bullshit every 5 minutes. It's irritating and it makes you look like an ass who can't relax and have fun.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by gruseom on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @12:36PM (#6013539)
No, he is not boring, and your comment is (way) out of line for being personally disrespectful.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by tankbot on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @01:12PM (#6013795)
I up-voted his comment because I personally found it interesting, but most people wouldn't. Their eyes would gloss over and they would move on, probably back to celebrity gossip or some other shallow pursuit. It's important to be self-aware enough to realize this, especially when attempting to teach others. Waxing pedantic and nit-picky alienates the audience and only hurts the subject and those who would learn it.

It was not my intention to be personally disrespectful, I probably should have worded my comment less casually.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by jerf on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @03:15PM (#6014654)
"I up-voted his comment because I personally found it interesting, but most people wouldn't."

This is Hacker News, where arguments about whether or not promises or callbacks are better in Node can run off the right side of the page. Sometime the participants are even still making cogent points at that point, though I'll admit that's probably an exception rather than the rule. Still, this isn't a site for people who are going to go back to "celebrity gossip"... or at least as I assumed you intended it, as in gossip about Brad Pitt et al, rather than, say, Snowden gossip. Still. Ahem. I keep seeming to get sidetracked here. The point I'm trying to make is, yes, we can indeed pay attention to this sort of thing. Except when we can't, and we just pick it apart mindlessly. Sorry, sorry, went off topic again there. Most certainly, we like this sort of thing here. Probably to a fault.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by munificent on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @05:19PM (#6015590)
> arguments about whether or not promises or callbacks are better in Node can run off the right side of the page.

Just like the callback-based code does! Hey-ooo!

...I'll see myself out.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by adamdavis on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @01:17PM (#6013826)
You say you found his comment interesting, but at the same time you called him out as being boring?

On the note of being self aware. While I would agree that many people would find the content of that comment 'boring'. In the context of the hackernews audience, and as a response to the parent post, I would be surprised if many people had their eyes gloss over and moved back to celebrity gossip.

Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by gruseom on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @02:17PM (#6014238)
I have that experience rather often myself. It takes a conscious effort to pay enough attention to how one is saying something.
Re:Vi Hart on Stravinsky's Atonal Compositions [video] by sanoli on Tuesday July 09, 2013 @09:05PM (#6016782)
Well, I come to Hacker News exactly for this. It helps filter out all the bullshit I don't want to waste time putting up with. And please remember that he's criticizing the video on Hacker News and not on her website or youtube page. I personally can't stand Vi's style of explaining things, but I know I'm also not the target audience. The comment you're calling out for being boring, however, goes quite nice with HN's crowd.