News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by MarkSweep on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:06AM (#5993732)
If the United States is becoming more repressive, where can one go? Other English speaking countries such as Australia, England, and Singapore have problems with freedom of expression.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by antocv on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:21AM (#5993777)
You cant flee anywhere nice, Snowden is trying to you and you see 99.9% of the world countries are willing to stuff their own constitutions and human rights treaties up their asses and stick their head in the sand at request of USA.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by tobiasu on Friday July 05, 2013 @06:40AM (#5994297)
Russia is more like 11%, not 0.01 ;)

scnr

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by toyg on Friday July 05, 2013 @10:01AM (#5994858)
Russia is not doing anything different: they are not going to grant Snowden asylum or citizenship. So they're well and truly in that 99.99% at this point, together with China and Venezuela.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by tobiasu on Friday July 05, 2013 @10:27AM (#5994966)
They did offer him asylum, with the condition to shut the fuck up and not continually interfere in international politics.

He rejected it for his own reasons.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by lttlrck on Friday July 05, 2013 @04:12PM (#5996556)
Did you really take Putin at face value?

I think it is a safe bet that they knew what Snowdens values were before making the offer and they fully expected him to turn it down. Or they knew it for certain...

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by toyg on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:57PM (#5996494)
Their offer was clearly meant to be rejected; it was like offering Richard Stallman a job at Microsoft as long as he shut up about this whole Free Software stuff.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by ajuc on Saturday July 06, 2013 @06:44PM (#6000330)
Try to do to Russia what Snowden did to USA and you will find polonium in your food. Also falsified elections. Not that good place if you like freedom.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by el_zorro on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:12AM (#5995201)
This sounds ridiculous, but lately I've been of the opinion that this planet is borked. I hold out serious hope for Elon Musk and his Mars colony. I seriously believe that we as a species need a fresh start in a new place. We need a new planet so we can try new things, create new ideas, and generally liberate ourselves of traditional conventions. It sounds pie-in-the-sky, but people are actively working on it and I hope to one day count myself among them.

America used to be the place where things like this could happen, but that's not so much anymore. There's still innovation, but the trend doesn't look good and most of the world just doesn't care.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by flyinRyan on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:31PM (#5995588)
What do you imagine will happen if Musk lands on Mars? Various countries will be claiming jurisdiction before he lands (assuming they don't already). They could simply call mars an extension of their country and hold him accountable to their laws for anything he does on Mars.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by el_zorro on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:07PM (#5995732)
They could, but I'd like to see them enforce it. The worst they could do on Earth would be to stop rocket launches to Mars (which would be bad) but rockets can be launched in a variety of places. They represent a large injection of wealth into an area, and the economic benefits of hosting rocket infrastructure outweighs the cost of dealing with a loud but ultimately toothless colony. By the time Mars would represent a 'threat' it will be essentially self-sufficient and then there is little hold Earth would have over it.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by flyinRyan on Thursday July 11, 2013 @04:06AM (#6024966)
Those on earth would still have the biggest military and as soon as the martian colony made it clear that they didn't submit to which ever overlords claimed them, that army would be in space on its way to Mars.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by adventured on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:15PM (#5995763)
Fleeing earth doesn't instantly change human nature. The risks to liberty will remain no matter where you go.

The George Washington willing-to-cede-his-throne type will be just as rare on Mars in 2095 as it is today, as it was throughout history.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by el_zorro on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:31PM (#5995830)
True, but it might allow the freedom to implement alternative methods that clamp down on such things. Just as the New World allowed for the political innovations that has lead to modern democracy (however flawed), Mars would be a new frontier that could be used to create a better government with all the lessons the past 400 years has taught us. It would be an even better frontier, as Mars doesn't have the pesky problem of people already living there with all the historical baggage that accompany it. It doesn't have the terrible legacy of slavery and the social problems that that implies. It is a fresher start than we as a species have ever had, and we now how the proper perspective to avoid the pitfalls that we're currently saddled with. In time, much as democracy filtered its way back to Europe, a better system of governance could find its way back to Earth.

In any case, it would be a bold experiment. To go in with the intention of building a better social contract, or to rethink what that even means, is something that we should keep in mind. Mars shouldn't just be a joyride in 0.4 g, but an intentional effort to rethink society.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by sneak on Sunday July 07, 2013 @02:19AM (#6001244)
"You can have peace. Or you can have freedom. Don't ever count on having both at once." —Heinlein
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by gizmo686 on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:10PM (#5996014)
I think a better bet would be to create a nation in international waters.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by johnbm on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:15PM (#5996041)
So you've moved to Mars. Through a stunning feat of engineering, humanity has designed a ship that can make the journey, land tons of people and equipment without crashing, and has deployed a habitat of some kind intact.

Well congratulations. You now live in a tube or box in a freezing, unbreathable, radiated, barren desert. The only way you can go outside is by donning a bulky environmental suit and breathing apparatus. You may have brought a dune buggy of some kind along for exploration, but you can't go very far. If something happens to it, your spare parts are numbered and you probably won't survive the night out there, spending your last moments staring at yet more sand and rocks.

You don't have real mining or manufacturing capabilities and a resupply takes years. At best, you might have a high-end industrial 3D printer for parts, but your (specialty!) raw materials will run out very quickly, and you can't 3D print truly complicated things.

The remainder of your life now depends on you maintaining a delicate, miniature artificial ecosystem inside, so you can produce food and oxygen indefinitely. This is a feat which, when we tried it back here on Earth, failed miserably (Biosphere 2). That was with the luxury of Earth-based construction, at atmospheric pressure, without having to ship materials out and in of two enormous gravity wells. Environmental integrity was a question of science, not one of life and death. Besides, there is no reason to believe that Earth's ecosystem itself is stable long-term, never mind an artificially picked subset of it.

Once the honeymoon period is over and you've settled in, you will slowly come to understand what it means to be truly alone. You will never again see the people you left behind. You cannot move away if you get into irreconcilable conflict. Your survival depends on maintaining social cohesion above else, despite none of the usual comforts being available.

If, above all odds, people manage to not go insane on their own, there's always Dunbar's number: a suggested upper limit on the size of stable social groups. In case of ideological rifts, it is impossible for people to move away and start over: unlike on Earth, a new colony can only be started with the full and unconditional cooperation of an existing one.

If you want to try new things, Mars is the last place to do so. Whoever goes there will be clinging to the way things were.

We already have a vague approximation of colonizing Mars anyway: Antarctica. Go read about life on McMurdo base for example, or this: http://www.theage.com.au/environment/big-stink-brews-in-anta...

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by el_zorro on Friday July 05, 2013 @04:02PM (#5996518)
There are perfectly good engineering solutions to all of the points you've raised which I won't go into here, because I don't want to waste your time or mine. I'll just state that Biosphere 2 was a terrible experiment that in no way reflects the proper way to do a mission of that sort. Additionally, there are myriad ways of generating resources in-situ, especially with using the Martian atmosphere.

The point is that I'm not talking about a society a year or even a decade into a mission. Once the groundwork is laid, though, the possibilities emerge. The colonies didn't revolt until 169 years after Jamestown was founded. I'll finish by saying that your pessimism is unfounded, as very smart people have figured out solutions to most of the problems you have presented. Furthermore, just because you personally do not find such a situation to your liking doesn't mean that others feel the same way.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by johnbm on Friday July 05, 2013 @06:24PM (#5997028)
Cheer up, I was being cynical because of this specifically:

"We need a new planet so we can try new things, create new ideas, and generally liberate ourselves of traditional conventions."

Of all the places to try out 'new conventions', the harshest frontier in human history does not sound like a good idea. And I agree, BioSphere was terrible, but the important thing is that it failed (mainly) for human reasons, not scientific ones. I think it is entirely possible we lack the capacity as a species to thrive outside our world.

I don't think the scientific problems are impossible to overcome, but I do think anyone who flies there with any notion of romantic exploration and a new beginning is going on a suicide mission.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by el_zorro on Friday July 05, 2013 @08:08PM (#5997297)
I'm sorry if that came off rather strongly - I'm very passionate about the subject!
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by marklit on Friday July 05, 2013 @06:16AM (#5994227)
I you can write code there are a lot of countries you could support yourself in. I've visited and in some cases worked in 49 countries with minimal foreign language skills.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by rgrieselhuber on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:21AM (#5993776)
Learn another language? :-)
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by MarkSweep on Friday July 05, 2013 @05:33PM (#5996849)
I'm learning Japanese, but what I hear about their criminal justice system is not inspiring.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by randomchars on Friday July 05, 2013 @05:00AM (#5994025)
And then go where?
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by Svip on Friday July 05, 2013 @06:53AM (#5994333)
Form a new country? Speaking as amateur cartographer, I support all independence movements, because it will give cartographers new borders to draw on maps and thus a reason for people to buy new maps.

Declare the East Coast US States independent and be done with it; I am tired of waiting.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by ctdonath on Friday July 05, 2013 @10:06AM (#5994885)
The Southern US States tried that. Didn't go very well. (Bloodiest war the USA was involved in.)
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by jerf on Friday July 05, 2013 @09:40AM (#5994790)
"Declare the East Coast US States independent and be done with it; I am tired of waiting."

How does that solve this problem? I mean, I can't even guess which side of this issue you think the "East Coast" is on.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by Svip on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:20AM (#5995238)
Oh, it is entirely unrelated to this particular issue. But the population of America could benefit from more local democracy rather than something far away as Washington, D.C..

Now one may argue that that is already defined in the Constitution and that even if it wasn't, more local politics could be enforced by law by reducing the reach of the federal government. But I doubt either of us are that naïve.

The USA have proved that democracy does not scale well. And that is why it has moved to centralise power ever since the Constitution was signed.

It may not be a victory for privacy, but it would be a victory for democracy.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by jerf on Friday July 05, 2013 @11:50AM (#5995377)
Ah, now that I can almost get behind.

One of the few plausible ways out of the mess we find ourselves in right now is a strong movement towards states rights. Nominally, the states have a lot more power in our system then they are currently exercising, so it doesn't require any new law, just some assertions of what already exists (albeit in the form of Constitutional Conventions rather than simply asserting laws, which would be simpler). It's not my perfect ideological solution by any means, but it's one of the few practical ones, inasmuch as it does involve walking up to a group of people and asking them to go grab more power as competing interests, rather than asking people with power to unilaterally disarm, which is pretty much a "fat chance" option.

Secession is in some sense the ultimate State's right extreme, but I wouldn't advocate it until more normal avenues were tried and failed. It has... proved hazardous, to say the least.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by Svip on Friday July 05, 2013 @01:52PM (#5995924)
I realise of course you refer to the American Civil War. But there are some striking differences between then and now.

I imagine it would be like this; a state (or more) announce that they will hold a referendum on independence, months (or even years) before the actual referendum will take place (similar to how it will take place in Scotland). This will give the President and the Federal Government time to react without having to sort to arms right away.

Furthermore, a referendum is particularly what will set it apart from the American Civil War; this will be the will of the people (of that state, obviously) and not merely the will of the state (which was the case during the American Civil War, it was merely the legislatures that decided to secede, and not by referendum).

This will make it much harder to justify for the federal government to intervene with military. Seeing as the process will open and peaceful, it would be seen as a considerable overreaction by the federal government to strike down with force on a seceding state.

In addition because war has gotten so much more terrible, and I doubt you'd even convince the army of doing so.

In short; I do not believe that you should be afraid of a military response to an independence, as long as you play fair. That's just intimidation. It would be sad to see that the only thing keeping the American states united was fear.

However, I do agree with you that independence should be the last resort. But considering the last few decades, it seems many things have already been tried.

Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by gizmo686 on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:14PM (#5996032)
The point of the Constitution was to create a stronger central government then we had under the articles of confederation.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by notdrunkatall on Sunday July 07, 2013 @07:34AM (#6001764)
...and the point of Svip is that since then, the central government has grown much stronger to the point of being detrimental.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by rgrieselhuber on Friday July 05, 2013 @05:15AM (#5994055)
That's a whole other question but at least it opens your options up a bit more.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by agilebyte on Friday July 05, 2013 @04:23AM (#5993911)
Also, you can go to country X that may not be repressive, but if you want to call abroad or use the internet, you are still inspected by routers in all the other countries that you would consider repressive.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by rwmj on Friday July 05, 2013 @03:56AM (#5993855)
There are no more wild frontiers until we move into space, unfortunately.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by notdrunkatall on Sunday July 07, 2013 @07:35AM (#6001766)
This Snowden affair made me realize that if no government wants to claim you, you are truly screwed. That's a modern development that I do not like.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by wcbeard10 on Friday July 05, 2013 @09:05AM (#5994677)
Seasteading?
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by ctdonath on Friday July 05, 2013 @10:07AM (#5994891)
Possible, but terribly expensive. There's been much discussion (see "Oceania" and other projects) but little progress.
Re:If PRISM is Good Policy, Why Stop with Terrorism? by gee_totes on Friday July 05, 2013 @12:57PM (#5995696)