I really don't know what to make of this. You surely can't think that "cooking by fire" was the height of technological sophistication in the year 1813?
My comment is wondering what he really meant; your explanation makes him sound like an idiot, frankly.
For most of human history, the vast majority of people cooked their food over open fires. Cooking with anything more advanced is an aspect of modern living that is only a very recent development, especially given that the time scale I was addressing is a billion years long.
Remember the timeframes involved are of many million years. The Sun will change very slowly until the very end and moving the Earth any faster would create climate problems of their very own.
BTW, we'll have some problems before that, when the Milky Way merges with Andromeda. I imagine lots of stars will gain excessive mass from fast moving gas clouds and may decide to go nova/supernova in the millennia it will take for both galaxies to pass through each other.
You shouldn't be. Basing your argument on "incredible technological progress since the industrial revolution" and "a billion years" passing is mere extrapolation.
Extrapolation of this form is like saying "I ate 1 burger on Monday, 2 on Tuesday and 4 on Wednesday. Given this rate, I'll be eating billions of burgers by next week".
For one, early discoveries, when science started its' pacing were easier. They are "low hanging fruit". We got the most basic stuff in 2-3 centuries (electricity, magnetism, gravity, modern math, evolution, boolean algebra, sets, engineering), refined them in another (relativity, quantum physics, computing, DNA). At some point you reach a plateau. We are not increasing anywhere near the same pace as in the start in breadth and quality: mostly in volume (more research into various aspects of stuff) and detail (more detailed results).
Second, there are other limits. For example, handling stuff below or above some natural limits requires (by the physics of the thing) enormous energy -- and we either don't have that or couldn't use it without melting earth.
There are also limits to our resources -- the very stuff we use to make our tech. From minerals to water. And then there's social limits. We could have been wiped out from a WWIII style thing several times during the cold war -- and could be even worse going forward, if on top of the usual greed and diplomatic expansion games there's also something like a fight for natural resources (draught, famine, etc).
It may be sad to lose the home planet, with all its historical importance, but maybe then we are routinely terraforming other planets and moving them around.
If you're interested in really long term survival, arguably the thing to do is to work out how to store the energy, or to turn the temperature down a bit so you're using less fuel, or to find out how to live on less fuel ourselves. Or all of the above.
Lots of energy going to waste out there - and the underlying point behind the article, I suppose, is that the universe has a limited energy budget. Like cancer - if you live long enough something will get you.
I don't think it works like that. There is no known principle that allows energy to be created or destroyed. So theoretically, the total amount of energy in the universe must remain constant.
So when one star disappears the energy gets transferred as radiation, mass and heat that eventually will be used to create new starts in a process known as "stellar evolution"[0].
However this process may stop in the far further, as the ultimate fate of the universe is currently unknown, but some theories has been made: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimate_fate_of_the_universe#T...
Its total potential to do work within the reference frame of any given system, which is what we're interested in here, doesn't remain a constant. It's like... if you think of it like water: If you have all your water at the top of a cliff in a big reservoir and it runs down into a turbine linked up to a generator, then you can get a lot of work out of that water. But once it's gone down the cliff, despite it still being the same mass of water, your ability to extract useful work from that water is dramatically less. You'd have to pump it back to the top of the cliff to repeat the exercise (at a loss since the system you're playing with is never going to be perfectly efficient, i.e. the second law of thermodynamics - so there'd basically be no point in doing so.)
What we really want are high concentrations of energy; low entropy sources. We're looking for those situations where the water is still at the top of the cliff. A star is fussing down through the various elements, and in the process it emits a lot of radiation during its lifetime. And it's not getting that energy back. Once the elements have undergone the process you'd have to put energy back into them to return them to their earlier states. But that energy's been leaving the star for years, and some of it travels at the speed of light so it's very far away - so... it's just not gonna happen. Stars do go through life cycles and produce various phenomena but always at a loss of their potential to do useful work, always at an increase in entropy.
^^;
Given the incredible technological progress since the industrial revolution (cooking by fire to walking on the moon and nuclear power in under two centuries), I am highly skeptical of this assumption.
The only things that can stop us are regressions to the primitive, of which I know of only two forms: the first is belief in the supernatural and its primacy as the basis of abstract thought. The second is nihilistic hatred of man and progress masked as practical necessity and love of nature.
I stand for life, and for progress. I am proud, and you should be, too. Whatever challenges nature holds in store for us, we can figure it out!