Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by ScottBurson on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:18AM
(#5989539)
No. Conspiring to commit murder is definitely not protected by the First Amendment. And even fantasizing openly, which should be protected as long as no attempt is made to act on the fantasy, has tended to get people locked up in recent years.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by saraid216 on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:21AM
(#5989548)
> Conspiring to commit murder is definitely not protected by the First Amendment.
A charge of conspiracy requires at least two conspirants and an overt act.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by smsm42 on Thursday July 04, 2013 @04:36AM
(#5989727)
If no actual preparations were made to execute the plan, it would be clear violation of the 1st amendment. What is the case of being locked up for fantasizing?
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by Karunamon on Thursday July 04, 2013 @10:08AM
(#5990677)
Not even close to being the same thing.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by PavlovsCat on Thursday July 04, 2013 @11:06AM
(#5990941)
What is the case of being locked up for fantasizing?
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by smsm42 on Friday July 05, 2013 @02:29AM
(#5993654)
Looks like some judge in Texas needs a lesson in First Amendment... And some guy needs a good lawyer that would destroy this crappy indictment.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by dTal on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:07AM
(#5989522)
That's a nice theory, but there's a news article every fortnight these days about someone getting chucked in the slammer for a casual, jokey remark on twitter being interpreted as a "terrorist threat".
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by saraid216 on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:19AM
(#5989543)
Are you trying to say that it isn't protected by the First Amendment, or that law enforcement is selective?
Do remember that a police officer who threatened to kill the First Lady still has his job.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by Gigablah on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:19AM
(#5989544)
Yeah, tell that to Justin Carter.
Re:FBI Document: [DELETED] had "plan to kill local Occupy le...
by saraid216 on Thursday July 04, 2013 @03:27AM
(#5989562)
I'd rather tell that to his prosecutors, but if you want me to further his depression and risk another suicide by telling him his Constitutional rights were violated, then hey, that's your prerogative.
I won't, though, because I'm not that much of a dick. And I'd rather allow the First Amendment Center do the talking for me, since I'm not a trained lawyer.
Because making such a plan is protected by the First Amendment. Carrying it out is not.