Re:You May Not Like Weev, But Your Online Freedom Depends on...
by tptacek on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @04:33PM
(#5980547)
Why does it have to be either/or? Shouldn't both the company and the "hacker" potentially be liable?
Re:You May Not Like Weev, But Your Online Freedom Depends on...
by sneak on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @02:33PM
(#5986568)
No, because then the collateral damage is everyone misidentified as a "hacker" because prosecutors don't know the difference between criminal actions and not because the internet is confusing to everyone who hasn't spent the last two decades staring at the underbelly. Also, prosecutors default to "criminal" because their job is to deal with criminals all day (c.f. aaronsw).
It's unreasonable for us to expect the legislature to get this right. Nothing here is criminal.
Re:You May Not Like Weev, But Your Online Freedom Depends on...
by tptacek on Wednesday July 03, 2013 @03:02PM
(#5986786)
The criminal justice system deals with fraud in more complicated settings than computer hacking. For instance, it convicted ADM executives for price-fixing lysine. I don't recall anyone being up in arms at the time about how the prosecutors didn't fully understand the lysine industry.
Since that would be a clear and basic PCI violation, yeah, it sucks for the merchant and their customers. Why have PCI compliance at all if the merchant can just throw up their hands and blame it on "hackers?"