News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You May Not Like Weev, But Your Online Freedom Depends on... by hartleybrody on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:53PM (#5979133)
I think the parent comment's first sentence makes sense -- simply accessing that information shouldn't be a crime. But if you then make a copy and either use or distribute that information illegally, that's something different.

To be clear, that's exactly what Weev did -- accessing AND keeping a copy for himself. But I think the parent comment's argument is talking specifically about access.

Creating a precedent where a "reasonable person" is expected to "understand" that the exposure was a mistake would create a huge legal gray area. Anything that's available on the public internet should be perfectly legal to access. What people do with that content is a different matter.

Re:You May Not Like Weev, But Your Online Freedom Depends on... by tptacek on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @01:05PM (#5979199)
The law is full of judgements based on the actions of a "reasonable person". And, I agree with your first paragraph, but then, so does the CFAA; CFAA doesn't define a strict-liability crime.