The most natural, diameter based, definition I can think of is, for any given point on the circle, the distance to the farthest point is a constant, D. You probably need to add additional restrictions to make this rigorous (such as requiring the circle to be form a continuous, closed loop).
You could also imagine rotating a line segment about its center. This has a nice sense of symmetry, as we are rotating about the center, not an arbitrary end. This also implies a generalization to off center rotations.
Here's a similar argument: In mathematics, do we measure angles in radians or diameterans? Why is that?
>that is not the only way to define a circle
Ok, let's hear 'em! What rigorous definition of a circle is more simply expressed in terms of diameter?
The only one I can think of is, "the smallest volume shape that can contain a length D line segment at any angle", but that seems contrived to me. I shutter at using the solution to optimization problem as a definition, except when there is no other choice. What's worst, it seems like a trivial derivative of the radial definition, just with extraneous concepts tacked on.