News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by AmVess on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:13AM (#5951315)
Punishments can be either cruel or unusual. They just cannot be both.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by majelix on Thursday June 27, 2013 @06:29AM (#5951523)
Cute, but I[0] don't think the law is that straightforward to interpret. At least according to Wikipedia[1], "cruel and unusual punishment" is a legal phrase all into it's own, regardless our lay interpretation of the individual words.

In Furman v. Georgia, 408 U.S. 238 (1972), Justice Brennan wrote, "There are, then, four principles by which we may determine whether a particular punishment is 'cruel and unusual'."

* The "essential predicate" is "that a punishment must not by its severity be degrading to human dignity," especially torture.

* "A severe punishment that is obviously inflicted in wholly arbitrary fashion."

* "A severe punishment that is clearly and totally rejected throughout society."

* "A severe punishment that is patently unnecessary."

These "principles" probably themselves have oblique legal meanings seperate than what we'd expect, and there's probably been a new ruling or two on the 8th amendment in the past 41 years.

--

[0] IANAL.

[1] Yes, I know.

Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by jlgreco on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:30AM (#5951356)
So we could bring back the stocks if we just make sure to use them a lot?

Seems like bullshit. Cruel punishment does not become okay if you do it frequently.

Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by knowtheory on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:18AM (#5951330)
Would you like to explain further how you think that cruelty and unusualness are mutually exclusive, either in general or in the eyes of the law?
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by btilly on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:44AM (#5951394)
I personally thought it was an obvious point of logic.

The ban in the 8th amendment is on "cruel and unusual punishments". Therefore punishments that are cruel or unusual, but not both, are not banned.

For example it would be hard to argue that excessive prison time is at all unusual in this country. So no matter how cruel it may be, it passes muster. Conversely Shena Hardin was given the unusual punishment of having to stand on a particular sidewalk wearing a sign that said, "Only an idiot would drive on the sidewalk to avoid a school bus." (She was, in fact, said idiot.) The punishment was unusual, but not cruel. It therefore passed constitutional muster.

However being kept in an overly crowded prison without appropriate medical care qualifies as both cruel and unusual punishment and is therefore unconstitutional. (As a variety of courts have had to repeatedly point out to California. Personally I'd love to see the fraction of the prison population that is over the design capacity of prisons in California become the portion of the year that key officials should have to spend inside of said prisons. I'm sure that we'd see Jerry Brown stop dragging his feet on the issue fairly promptly...)

Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by RyanMcGreal on Thursday June 27, 2013 @07:40AM (#5951768)
The 8th Amendment is based on Cesare Beccaria's On Crimes And Punishments and the term "cruel and unusual" specifically means the punishment should be proportionate to the crime.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by btilly on Thursday June 27, 2013 @10:36AM (#5952487)
I find this theory unlikely given that many sources and a number of US legal cases cite a clause of the English Bill of Rights of 1689 as the source. Said clause being, That excessive bail ought not to be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted;

See http://www.constitution.org/eng/eng_bor.htm for the full bill in question.

That Cesare Beccaria's comments could have given the idea more force I can believe. But they are not the source. Nor am I aware of any court case that has specifically discussed Cesare Beccaria for trying to understand this clause. By contrast search https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/501/957/case.htm... for comments about Titus Oakes (the historical cause of that clause).

Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by mithras on Thursday June 27, 2013 @12:10PM (#5953032)
Doesn't this make various three strike laws unconstitutional?
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by RyanMcGreal on Thursday June 27, 2013 @01:00PM (#5953333)
I certainly think so, not to mention inhumane, fiscally irresponsible and in defiance of all evidence about how to craft an effective criminal justice system.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by babebridou on Thursday June 27, 2013 @08:10AM (#5951864)
Do you have an example of a "cruel" punishment?
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by homosaur on Thursday June 27, 2013 @09:59AM (#5952292)
How about solitary confinement, the long term use of which is most clearly torture? This happens very commonly in the US for all manner of "disrespect of authority" in prison, usually over political matters (prison politics, not red v blue for whichever dummy was going to say that after this post).
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by btilly on Thursday June 27, 2013 @10:38AM (#5952494)
Many punishments are cruel. Prison is cruel. So is death.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by D_Alex on Thursday June 27, 2013 @07:53AM (#5951804)
I think he meant:

Punishments are PERMITTED to be either cruel, or unusual. But not both.

Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by AmVess on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:28AM (#5951351)
Ask the SCOTUS. It was their interpretation.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by whyleyc on Thursday June 27, 2013 @06:29AM (#5951522)
I took it as an ironic comment.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by Kliment on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:31AM (#5951359)
The way I understand the comment is that a punishment has been deemed legal if it is cruel XOR unusual, but not both.
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by Svip on Thursday June 27, 2013 @05:21AM (#5951336)
How about pulling people's nails out? Isn't that both?
Re:The Strange Case of Barrett Brown by timdev2 on Thursday June 27, 2013 @06:20AM (#5951488)
Evidently, only if you fail to do it regularly.