I don't think a felony conviction or any kind of jail sentence is appropriate here due to no property damage being done and lack of intent to intimidate, but this is not a free speech issue. This is "prosecutors being douche bags" issue (still a very serious problem).
I am not in any way saying that property rights should always trump free speech right: California, for example, extends free speech to private spaces open to the public ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pruneyard_Shopping_Center_v._Ro... ). I could even tangibly see a case if, e.g., wall of a privately owned building in a busy area has been set aside as a public chalkboard (for any kind of messages), but certain (otherwise protected) speech was excluded.
Defacement of property that isn't yours and to which you've not been granted access, however, isn't exercise of free speech.
I also find it ironic that most of the posters here disagree with ACLU on Citizens United: apparently showing a political film before an election is not free speech, but vandalism is...
I think I do too, but I'm not sure.
However, I just find it silly that many HNers claim to be unequivocally for political speech, when they're clearly willing to restrict certain kinds of political speech. The latter is an understandable position: I have plenty of concerns about money in politics leading to electioneering, I just personally think the cure has potential to be worse the decease. I'm all in favor of campaign finance regulations that do not restrict free speech, but I'll acknowledge that they may be less effective comparatively[1].
In general, I think it's important to acknowledge that there are trade-offs between liberty, safety, and equality and state which trade-offs one is willing to make. Equivocation or wishful thinking just makes one look dishonest ("will you buy my 100,000 node commodity-hardware distributed database that has 0.00001 ms latency, read-committed transaction isolation, and 100% uptime?")
[1] That said I doubt restrictions on speech will fix the problem of rent-seeking by moneyed interests -- it will continue through other channels; however, now these moneyed interests will have another tool at their disposal: politicians' ability to restrict political speech, e.g., MPAA lobbying congress to restrict the ability of ACLU/EFF to oppose parts of the DMCA.
Whether he ends up being sentenced this harshly doesn't alter the fact that it is absurd, and immoral, that it's possible and at the discretion of a prosecutor who has a vested interest in putting people in jail for a long time.
That the state is taking the bank's word that washable children's chalk caused $6000 worth of damage is also absurd. There's a lot of absurdity and unethical behavior in this story, and I think outrage is justified.
The RT story is still ridiculous.
From the article:
"[Olsen] eventually got a call from San Diego's Gang Unit in August 2012, when he gave up the artistic protests. The Reader reports that Freeman aggressively pressured city attorneys to bring charges against Olson until they announced that they would do so in April"
I wonder if there's a public choice/political economy theory on prosecutorial overreach and how to discourage it other than on a case-by-case basis (which is very difficult, generally).
I hope you're right.
Hear. Hear. From an earlier comment thread about the unreliability of rt.com as a source:
> The source of the submitted article, rt.com, is not known for careful journalism.
Understatement of the year.
http://www.10news.com/news/jeff-olson-man-who-used-chalk-to-...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/23/alexander-schaefer-...
The story is being accurately reported, so your criticism of the source has no merit. Here is the exact same story from other sources.
http://www.sandiegoreader.com/weblogs/news-ticker/2013/jun/2...
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/25/jeff-olson-californ...
http://www.10news.com/news/jeff-olson-man-who-used-chalk-to-...
This prosecution of an activist for writing slogans critical of a bank, on a public sidewalk, and using sidewalk chalk that disappears with a small amount of rain, or a light hosing, has absolutely no merit, and is an abomination to humanity, human rights, and sanity. Justifying it and claiming it is a reasonable prosecution and the judge is being fair as you are doing is absolutely inexcusable.
And you're a misinformed fool. Quoting other sensationalist and equally inaccurate sources does not validate your point. The jury in a common law trial is a trier of fact, not of law. The proper place for defense counsel to make his first amendment argument is in the appeals court.
These procedural niceties, as much as you dislike them, are what underpin the rights of criminal defendants in the first place, by providing a mechanism for challenging the law itself.
I'm not that hot on jury nullifaction, since it has the potential to systematically disenfranchise victims. Of course there's also the questions of victimless crimes, but like any good fence-sitter I can make an argument for the existence of a collective injury.
Where does it end? If you recognize anti-human's rights, then they'll want to get anti-human married, and what happens if an anti-human wants to marry a human? A catastrophic release of kinetic energy, that's what.
We need to avoid this slippery slope! It's Protons and Electrons, not AntiProtons and Positrons! (I'll be Kickstarting bumper stickers for the cause later this week).
Here's the statute:
http://www.leginfo.ca.gov/cgi-bin/displaycode?section=pen&gr...
In refusing to hear the First Amendment arguments of Olson's attorney, the judge is presumably just reading the statute narrowly; there is no "political speech" exemption to the vandalism statute, nor should there be, since we're talking about private property.
But it's hard to believe that any sane jury would recognize more than a few dollars damage from water-soluble chalk, and equally hard to believe anyone would receive a custodial sentence --- which would surely cost the city vastly more to defend at its near-certain appeal --- for chalking a bank with a political message.
Don't get your news from RT.