Re:Windows 8.1 Preview
by RyanZAG on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:50PM
(#5947221)
I clicked through to the live feed on http://channel9.msdn.com/ from the link there. I was right in time for the presenter to click on the new windows button which makes an incredibly jarring animation of tons of randomly colored tiles pop up over the screen. The presenter then says "not at all jarring ... not at all jarring". Sure, right, I think you need to get out of that reality distortion field - it's not working.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Windows 8.1 Preview
by counterpointer on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:54PM
(#5947255)
Have you actually used Windows Phone or Windows 8 for any length of time? The animations are very subtle on actual devices and work very well with the flat look.
Can't speak for the animations being screencasted across the internet via streaming video though which can introduce lag, jitter, FPS drops and artifacts, especially for fast moving scenes like animations. I'll reserve my judgment till I install the preview.
The full screen, multi-colored tile metro screen is subtle and not jarring? The one that pops up whenever you want to launch a new program, completely removing any context of what you are currently working on? Is that what you're actually saying?
The strange rotating 'subtle' animation you are trying to say makes up for this just makes it all the worse by putting completely unnecessary 'bling' all over a workstation.
So you haven't used it, then?
Clearly he hasn't.
'Jarring' is different from 'subtle'. Jarring implies that the transition between states is abrupt and confusing, nothing about how obvious of a transition it is. In fact, in order to not be jarring, a transition should be very obvious to the user.
Re:Windows 8.1 Preview
by ChikkaChiChi on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:12PM
(#5947400)
The metro interface can and will continue to be jarring when its allowed to change the contextual relevance on screen in situations where I may not want that.
It's the same reason why you sometimes walk into another room and ask "now what was I coming in here for?"