News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by bad_user on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:49AM (#5945961)
I cannot verify the claims, but I'll state the reasons once again about why I'm not using ad blockers:

1) free websites and web services need revenue and as long as the ads are tasteful, I don't mind them

2) I actually want websites to annoy me with lots of stupid ads, as I want to stop using such websites, because I want to reward publishers that don't do that

Ad blockers are trying to fix a symptom of the disease and in doing so they only help spreading and growing that disease.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by betterunix on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:37AM (#5946319)
"as long as the ads are tasteful"

This is the problem: the ads stopped being tasteful. Remember pop-ups? Remember how, when browsers started having pop-up blockers as a default, the response by the advertising industry was to try to circumvent the blockers, resulting in even more annoying ads? Remember how ad companies did not get the message when people stopped accepting their cookies, and now use dozens of techniques to track people? Remember how they said they thought Do Not Track meant "track but do not show targeted ads?"

Unfortunately, the annoying, intrusive, privacy-invading advertising is not limited to a handful of sites. It is all over the place. That's why ad blocking is important and necessary: we users should not have to suffer because of the advertising industry's greed.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by mdip on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:38AM (#5946324)
I agree with both of those principals, but I continue to run an ad filtering proxy on my home network.

I don't do this because ads annoy me (of course they do, but for the above reasons, it feels wrong). I do this because a few years ago, certain less technical members of my family received a nasty bit of malware/rootkit combo delivered -- as best I could discern -- via a song lyric look up site. Another laptop picked up malware around the same time, though its source was more difficult to discern. In addition, about this same time, Microsoft and Google's ad networks were found to have some Flash ads that were malicious.

After spending a few hours reloading laptops (with the offending individual being my first experiment with Ubuntu on a non-technical user's PC), I got fed up and installed a proxy.

My computers all have local firewalls and anti-virus, but I'm sure nobody's surprised that they were still infected.

I wonder, is the state of these ad networks improved at all? Are there advertisement blocking tools that just target ads that have the greatest probability of being exploits (flash, java, smaller ad networks)?

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ljoshua on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:48PM (#5947208)
Out of curiosity, how did the experience go for the non-technical Ubuntu user? Did it work out well?
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by mdip on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:00PM (#5950075)
I ended up switching to openSuSE because she was having a difficult time remembering how to connect to our network shares and I didn't have the spare time to sort out what it took to get Active Directory membership working. After the switch, though, we never went back. This was 4 or 5 years ago, and she's now my ex- (unrelated to software choices), but for what she used it for -- e-mail, basic document creation, YouTube (Flash at the time), music organization (I believe we used SongBird? ... whatever it was, she was happy with it), and (at the time) a SageTV client. Aside from having to learn what did what, where (which was pretty minimal, she was already using OpenOffice on Windows, and Firefox was Firefox, SageTV was SageTV, most things were familiar), it was great. She figured out, on her own, how to customize the background and some of the other user settings.

And I had fun from time to time connecting via SSH and making a song or two play when I knew she had to be cheered up. She thought that was a little creepy, but hey.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by skue on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:38AM (#5946325)
Not all of us block ads because they are annoying to look at. They are also a very real threat to privacy because ad companies track us across multiple websites (yes, I block Google Analytics and other trackers as well).

OTOH, I also feel tremendous sympathy towards websites trying to survive on ad revenue. I'm actually the type of person who still buys music to support artists.

I don't know what the solution is. We are forced to choose between being watched as we browse the web, staying completely offline, or blocking ads but not supporting the websites we visit.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ianlevesque on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:30AM (#5946673)
Would you pay to subscribe to a service that paid the sites you use instead of them showing you ads?
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by JoshTriplett on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:37AM (#5946713)
No. Not because I won't pay certain sites for their content (I subscribe to LWN, for instance), but because I don't want to pay some aggregating middleman service that by necessity can then track across all the sites I visit.

In principle I like the concept of paying a fixed amount per unit time and splitting that across the sites I care about. In practice I don't see any obvious privacy-respecting way to do that.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by skue on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:43AM (#5946757)
That is an excellent point about micropayments. Creating a system that pays sites without a middleman that tracks visits would be challenging (though I imagine it's technically feasible).
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by skue on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:38AM (#5946715)
Sure, I was always intrigued by the micro payments idea. Heck, if that we're the norm I wonder if it wouldn't promote better web content. I'd be more likely to spend more time on sites I wanted to support than the sensational sites I may feel guilty about having clicked through to.

But I don't think most folks think this way, so practically speaking I don't see micropayments ever working. Would love to be proven wrong.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by citricsquid on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:09AM (#5946110)
Plus a huge number of people that adblock have been doing it for years and are basing the continued usage on the assumption that adverts now are similar to the adverts in 2006 - 2009. I use a lot of different websites with advertisements and I can't think of the last time I've seen an advertisement that auto-played sound or caused lag, whereas in 2008 it was a daily occurrence. The value that advertisements provide (support websites) greatly outweighs the inconvenience that current advertisements cause, even Youtube pre-roll adverts are not that bad after getting used to them.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by mtrimpe on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:22AM (#5946210)
I started blocking ads less than a year ago because of YouTube's pre-roll advertisements, since I'm perfectly capable of filtering out text based ads but a format that requires me to watch the ad to be able to view the content without letting me pay them is a deal-breaker for me.

Is it really that hard to let me pay a monthly fee to turn ads off?

Google is serving the vast majority of ads online and they already have the infrastructure in place to channel part of that fee to the content creators including knowing whom I visit and when.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ianlevesque on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:36AM (#5946304)
Exactly this. Everyone needs to offer the option to pay in some way. If we could pay for a bundle of all sites even better.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by lifeformed on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:37AM (#5946711)
Someone should make a paid adblocker service that shares revenue with site owners. Site owners can opt in to get a share of the revenue, so that each time a visitor using the adblocker visits their site, the site owner gets paid an amount equivalent to the potential ad revenue from that visit. That means they could serve up a custom ad-less page that's designed to look nice sans ads.

Users get a good adblocker that they don't have to feel bad about using, and site owners get to sustain the revenue they would've lost.

Maybe it could provide more benefits than just ad blocking? Perhaps it would just be a "premium membership to the internet". Site owners can take even more revenue if they implement even more features. More web app options, custom styling options, social badges, etc. The more a user pays a month, the more features he gets all over the internet.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ianlevesque on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:47AM (#5946785)
Yep I'd buy it.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:02PM (#5949903)
The tech I'm developing makes this possible. The basic model is subscription sharing based on views, but it can be adjusted for time on-site etc. My intention is that the agreement with publishers is that they won't show ads to subscribers.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jimm on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:00AM (#5946455)
If you're old enough to remember the start of cable TV, one of the promises was that it would have few/no commercials, because you're paying for it.

I'd trust very few web sites to stay ad-free if they switched to a pay model. The money is just too good for them.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by pyre on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:08AM (#5946516)
The ethics of Ad-Blocking when you were promised / sold on something that was "Ad Free" only to end up with ads is a different question.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by sciurus on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:55PM (#5947263)
See Hulu, which says they still have ads in order to lower the subscription price.

http://www.hulu.com/support/article/20356372

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:43AM (#5946365)
I happen to be working on the technology to make this possible.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by dfc on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:32PM (#5947053)
Exactly this? WTF? The "this" response was bad enough as it was. Now we are lowering the SNR even more by prepending "Exactly"?
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by MichaelGG on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:43PM (#5947176)
s/Exactly this/I agree

Or eliminate it. He provided a small comment afterwards, and the replies to that comment are good. Not what I'd call noise.

Your comment and my response however...

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by dfc on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:47PM (#5947202)
I thought that "this" meant I agree. What additional information is conveyed by adding "Exactly"? Now when I encounter "This" I am going to be confused as to whether the author is agreeing in whole or in part with the parent comment.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:44AM (#5946763)
Your comment has convinced me to turn off AdBlock; we'll see how it goes.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by criley2 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:16AM (#5946164)
As if I need every single website hooked into Google Ads, all of them reminding me that I'm single, trying to sell me clothes, trying to sell me dating websites, trying to predict what I want in life.

It's invasive, and quite frankly, it's disturbing and creepy that the same advertisements follow me regardless of website. I feel like the guy in Pachebel's Rant, finding Canon in D across modern music, except what I'm finding is invasive Google ads, and I find them on most websites...

So no, I actively refuse the narrow demographic Google placed me into, and chases me around the internet with.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by orourkek on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:35AM (#5946298)
FYI, you can change some settings for google ads[1] so that you're not shown targeted ads at all (for example). You can also block ads to have them and related ads never be shown again.

[1] https://www.google.com/ads/preferences

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by HarshaThota on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:32PM (#5947054)
Google also has an add-on if you want to opt out from Google Analytics.

[1] https://tools.google.com/dlpage/gaoptout

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by maxmcd on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:25AM (#5946228)
You can opt-out of retargeting. Seems that would solve your problem.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by vonuebelgarten on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:34AM (#5946283)
I opt-out by preventing the browser from emitting that HTTP requests. Why will I trust the ad-server from doing evil things?
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by betterunix on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:41AM (#5946347)
We should live in a world where people who want this need to opt-in.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by Osmium on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:46AM (#5946772)
Conversely, three very practical reasons to use ad blockers:

1) You save battery life

2) You save data

3) Pages load quicker

And you lose no content in the process. So why wouldn't you? If you're using a fast machine hooked up to fibre broadband, perhaps it's a different matter, but as a mobile user it's a no brainer. And that isn't even mentioning the content of ads or privacy concerns...

If you think ads are necessary for the health of the internet, then they need to be presented a way that doesn't actively harm the experience of using the internet.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ianlevesque on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:32AM (#5946274)
There's a growing segment of users that just don't want advertising in their faces, period. Thankfully a not-insignificant portion of these are willing to pay for it through subscriptions on sites that offer this. Not enough sites offer this.

I envision an "ad network" appearing eventually that doesn't display any ads, just distributes revenues from an aggregate subscription. Then sites can still be supported by spontaneous visitors and users can control their exposure to advertisements online.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:46AM (#5946381)
This idea has been around for a while; I call it "microsubscription". Several companies have tried and failed to make a go of it. Kachingle is still limping along, though fatally hamstrung itself by picking a dumb, public fight with the New York Times.

As I said in reply to another of your comments, I've been working on the technology to make it possible to do this reliably for some time now. It's harder than it looks.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by ianlevesque on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:02AM (#5946471)
Very interesting. I figured someone must have tried it but hadn't found examples. Kachingle looks like a deeply flawed implementation of it.

What were the others?

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:00PM (#5949893)
From memory there was a few, but I've lost the links file I had. Contenture was one of them. There was a project at one of the journalism schools trying to push the same model too.

It's a good idea on paper, but actually making the market-building side work is really hard.

I've been focused on the technology side because hey, that's how I'm wired. Essentially, you can't rely on standard web bugs or javascript approaches; they're much too easy to subvert.

In my honours dissertation I identified 9 distinct attacks on the "naive" protocol and developed countermeasures for each. But that design is fatally flawed too. I have another design which ... well, watch this space: http://robojar.com/

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by tomflack on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:37AM (#5946313)
I pay for Arstechnica premium for this reason. I have adblockers turned off on The Verge, and emailed them asking for a subscription option but received no reply.

I don't want advertising in my face, full stop.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by andrewflnr on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:26PM (#5947503)
That would be tricky. People would need to have a good idea of which sites they care about would have ads removed if they pay X dollars/month. Then maybe their favorite sites use three different networks, all of which they have to pay for. Maybe you could do it where the user picks the network, not the site.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @08:06PM (#5949916)
Having looked at this for a while, the show/not-show needs to be decided at the publisher's server based on input from an authentication service.

eg.

    if ( auth.is_subscriber )
      puts advertisement_block
    end
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by andrewflnr on Thursday June 27, 2013 @10:13AM (#5952359)
Right, my idea is that the user gets to pick which auth object to check against on the server
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by jacques_chester on Thursday June 27, 2013 @10:16PM (#5955817)
My design is authenticating per-request, so the publisher's server is the one that would decide what to query. From the user perspective it's opt-in.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by foobarqux on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:09PM (#5947373)
The reason everyone should have ad blockers is to be free from exploitative coercion.

If someone could attach electrodes on your cranium and "reprogram" it so that it would permanently increase your propensity to buy product X by 10% in exchange for viewing an article on a website would you do it? Would you justify doing it by statements like "free websites and web services need revenue and I don't really mind the electrodes"?

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by pi18n on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @01:10PM (#5947387)
I block all advertisements because the majority I've seen are manipulative and push us to constantly be purchasing shit we don't need by making us afraid we aren't good enough. Or they're just nakedly bold; "come spend your real dollars on this online game featuring this witch's breasts".

If websites have a problem with this they can just respond 402 to all my requests and I won't cry to anyone.

Some advertisers are just honest people trying to make money and I hope word-of-mouth will cover those. But for the rest of it, let's just say my life is much better without TV, radio, or magazines.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by abraxasz on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:47PM (#5947196)
I do acknowledge a moral conflict when using add blockers, for the first reason you give. But ads and trackers have gotten out of hands, to the point where most of the chrome extensions I have installed deal with that type of things:

- Adblock - DoNotTrackMe - Disconnect

in addition to

- Quick Javascript Switcher (if I really get pissed)

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by rustynails on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:43PM (#5947168)
Malware is also delivered by ads, a very important reason to block ads.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by theorique on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:28AM (#5946247)
Ad blockers are trying to fix a symptom of the disease and in doing so they only help spreading and growing that disease.

They are like antibiotics creating stronger bacteria?

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by mike-cardwell on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @02:26PM (#5947958)
I don't block ads, I block surveillance. The lack of ads that I see is just a side effect of this.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by kybernetyk on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @09:58AM (#5946022)
Hmm, I haven't seen it that way. I guess I start stop using adblockers, too.

Now some of my daily news sources will become pretty unbearable ... but I guess I better look out for other websites that don't need to put up full site flash wrap-banners.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by Shivetya on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @12:43PM (#5947167)
I too do not mind "tasteful" ads but unfortunately being a gamer leads me to man game related sites I do not trust and for good reason. More than once I have read postings where ad servers were hacked to server malicious items and more than once it was suggested the site operators didn't care. Fortunately being on a Mac as well as defaulting to strict blocking has protected me in every case.

I would not mind a solution that provides trusted ads. A system by which I can inspect what the site is trying to feed me and whitelist what I am willing to deal with.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by zeckalpha on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:05AM (#5946084)
How do ad blockers affect revenue? Don't they still fetch the ads but just limit the presentation of the ads? So it would be indistinguishable from someone who just does not click on the ads?
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by citricsquid on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:10AM (#5946116)
1. No they don't

2. Even if they did this would be very unreasonable, either you view adverts and the publisher gets paid or you don't view adverts and the publisher doesn't get paid. If you're triggering the pay-out criteria without actually doing whatever is required (view, click, interact) it's just moving the financial hit to the advertiser, which is still unreasonable.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by acheron on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:24AM (#5946220)
Not my problem. The entire point of HTML is that the server sends files and I have a client that decides how to interpret them. I may be using a browser that is set to display larger fonts for my poor eyesight, or I may be using a mobile browser that decides to use different CSS, or I may be using Lynx that doesn't show images, or I may be using a browser that displays some images and not others based on a blacklist. It's not up to the server to determine.
Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by namdnay on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:10AM (#5946114)
No, one of the advantages of ad blockers is that they cut down on the amount of traffic, you don't download the ads.

In fact, several websites show you a warning message, or refuse to load, if you're running an adblocker.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by caust1c on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @10:08AM (#5946108)
Most block the loading of the url that contains the ad content. The website owners rarely host the ads they're displaying.

In that regard, it's very easy to detect if someone is using AdBlock or not.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by orclev on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:17AM (#5946579)
Only if you own both the site and the ad network otherwise you'll be unable to tell if they made a request for the ad or not. There are also ways of getting false positives with that sort of test, for instance if for whatever reason the server that has the ad on it isn't reachable from the client (say a problem in one of the major backbones, or a bad DNS entry).

The usual approach I've seen sites take is they have some sort of "Please disable your ad-blocker" image that they load everywhere ads go, and then just overlay the ad image on top of that one when it loads.

Re:Adblock Plus “typo correction” feature adds affiliate IDs... by throwaway10001 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @11:42AM (#5946739)
I use mainly so I can search with Google. Without adblock, it's a nightmare on many searches, the first screen of my laptop is all ads (not including youtube, maps, Google local etc.