The core idea is to make the recruiting bonus recurring.
Similarly, I'm not sure that the 100% over 10 years rule isn't arbitrary. Someone who stays with a company for ten years is incredibly valuable. Why not pay in year 11, and year 12?
AVP: Assistant Vice President
VP: Vice President
Some say this is a corrupt conspiracy, but I think it's just how things are traditionally done, and I don't think it's much different from not making your price lists public knowledge, etc. It's just business. That said, it's in the employees' interest to arm themselves with the going rate for their job duties, and to aggressively push to get a fair rate.
It's hard to say if one approach is "better," because every company is different, and you can't easily switch models. If you decide to go to public salaries, you may be pressured to "correct" a lot of people, some downward. If you decide to go private, everyone is going to be asking why.