News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by yuvadam on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:36AM (#5932736)
Do you honestly believe we've understood this surveillance complex enough that we can keep on with our lives? Why accept that "PRISM [won't go] away" or that "Snowden's fate is grim"?

Honestly? Is this cause not worth fighting for anymore?

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by ebbv on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:44AM (#5932790)
Most of these stories themselves are at best tangentially related to the larger issue.

Upvoting them or reading a story about Edward Snowden's favorite brand of chicken pot pie is not doing anything to fight for civil liberties, though it will give views to garbage web sites like Business Insider and its ilk.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by gori on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:55AM (#5932845)
Oh give up.

"Edward Snowden's favorite brand of chicken pot pie" "Kim Dotcom braids his hair!" "Julian Assange orders Cherry Coke instead of regular!" "Elon Musk buys three rare white leopards!"

Do you really like to argue by ridiculing others this much? There hasn't been a story even resembling anything like this, people have actually upvoted things they found interesting.

More links means more people are writing about it. This is good.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by ebbv on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:04AM (#5932920)
It does not mean more people writing about the actual issues, it means more people writing about irrelevant details of these people's lives like Edward Snowden's girlfriend's blog. That's the point.

Nobody's saying don't post thoughtful opinion pieces or details about legislation or court cases or anything else actually having to do with the issues.

You can claim that most or all of the posts that have appeared on here are relevant, but they aren't all relevant. That's why this post that we're commenting on exists and has gotten upvoted; the quality of those posts has been abysmal.

And your response is not to argue the point but to basically tell us to shut up. Thanks for contributing.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by gori on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:12AM (#5932974)
No, my point is that people are upvoting articles they find interesting, which might not be the same things that I find interesting, and I'm ok with this.

I find the personal stuff in a story like this quite interesting, btw.

Of course there's a lot of duplicates and posts with similar information in them, but is that such a big issue? I think people who are flagging posts because they think it's sort of the same as another article is basically abusing the system.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by PavlovsCat on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:31PM (#5933975)
You can claim that most or all of the posts that have appeared on here are relevant, but they aren't all relevant.

Yeah, but "most" are. See how it works when you leave the sophistry out?

And your response is not to argue the point but to basically tell us to shut up. Thanks for contributing.

Are you kidding? Are you projecting?

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by gyardley on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:21AM (#5933044)
Good lord, there was something up here this morning that talked about the pizza and fried chicken Snowden had for his birthday. Before that, it was 'his girlfriend's a pole dancer and here's the cache of her deleted blog'.

This guy stabbed his own cause in the back by going public, doing press interviews, and doing whatever else he could to make the story all about him, and for some inexplicable reason y'all want to shove the knife in deeper and twist.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by mcherm on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:38AM (#5933590)
> This guy stabbed his own cause in the back by going public, doing press interviews, and doing whatever else he could to make the story all about him

Really? Because I don't think "the goal" is to get detailed articles written up in blogs that will show up on Hacker News, I think "the goal" is to get the story out to as many people as possible and raise its profile in hopes of influencing governments.

And you have to understand the way that the press works. They've already WRITTEN a story about PRISM... so they can't write another one, because it's not "new". However, they CAN report on the daily movements of this guy, Snowden. And they can publish every interview he gives. And each time they can (will!) review just what it is that he revealed.

I think that, intentional or not, Snowden has successfully managed to bring media attention to this issue in a way that previous efforts had not.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by gyardley on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:24PM (#5933931)
Yeah, really. Just anecdotal, of course, but from my own conversations with (and eavesdropping on) normal people around my town, it's clear that some people know who Snowden is and are following his travels but they don't have the slightest clue what he revealed. 'Some military secret to the Chinese' is the best guess I've gotten so far.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by rgraham on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:37PM (#5934012)
I tend to think he knew they would find him and he preferred to be famous and hopefully talked about when they did. He wanted to control what he could of how he might be presented to the public. He probably also did not want to disappear one day with nary a word about him or spoken by him ever again. He wanted change. He risked a lot for it.

I don't think he risked it so he could do a few interviews. The fame and media attention is a tool.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by darkarmani on Monday June 24, 2013 @03:50PM (#5935234)
> This guy stabbed his own cause in the back by going public, doing press interviews

Yeah. His cause is completely dead. No one is following the spying on Americans issue now.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by pvnick on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:29AM (#5933521)
Nobody is talking about chicken pot pie. I don't appreciate your obvious straw man attack. The stories about a political refugee trying to escape the grasp of the United States, a country which stands for freedom and human rights, is arguably one of the most important stories of our lives.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by shawabawa3 on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:39AM (#5932756)
Is posting hundreds of mundane "news" articles with no substance really fighting?
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by joshstrange on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:42AM (#5932775)
We complain all the time that the major news networks don't cover what is really important or that they cover them and move on like it never happened. I think it is a good think that it is kept present in our minds so we don't forget it or write it off as "There is nothing we can do about it".

Seeing the entire front page of HN covered in stories on it might be slightly annoying but it is much better than the alternative (no coverage) IMHO.

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by gori on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:41AM (#5932766)
Is not talking about it better?
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by criley2 on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:18AM (#5933020)
How about- and I know this is shocking- we find a balance.

A balance between nothing and tabloid.

We're dangerously close to tabloid currently. Lots of irrelevant articles, lots of speculation and opinion, and the real stories are hidden in the noise.

I still think about 80% of the Snowden articles are worse than useless -- they're actively hiding the 20% of articles that are worthwhile, that we should all be reading.

But hey, I guess diverting our attention to the pointless bits of the story is an effective diversion tactic /conspiracy

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by threeseed on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:53AM (#5932834)
The problem is that Snowden has become the story. It's no longer about PRISM or the legitimate surveillance and privacy concerns it's about him.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by yuvadam on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:13AM (#5932979)
It's up to us - the people - to make the story about illegal surveillance and privacy concerns. The media sure as hell won't address those issues for us.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by hysterix on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:37AM (#5933176)
It's pathetic the defeatist attitude the majority of americans have. We finally get a week or so of pushing these sort of stories to the front page and now people are complaining.

Ironically if you look at a list of recent submissions by this "peterwwillis", you will see a list of boring nothing-to-see-here content that should also be downvoted due to a lack of originality and new content.

Anchoring (wikipedia.org) - yep he linked to a random wikipedia article. I'm so glad we have people like peter to lead hn to a new promise land of link filled content to wikipedia.

Graph of BitCoin market price (USD) (blockchain.info) - Yes because what hn readers need is a link to blockchain.info as we were too incompetent to find it alone.

Ironic a poster crying about content submits such boring, shallow and useless posts.

But something that is actually relevant to current affairs should be flagged and downvoted? The guy who started this thread is a joke.

To all the foreigners claiming this is "american politics" and should be ignored, do you all really have such short sightedness you can't see this effects everybody in the world, not just americans?

Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by chaz on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:06PM (#5933792)
Please dont make this a personal issue about just OP. Hundreds of upvotes on this -- he's clearly not alone.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by hysterix on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:57PM (#5934549)
I don't mean to make this personal, but someone who submits a wikipedia entry as a submission should not decry posts that are about current affairs directly relating to software development and the tech industry.
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by levosmetalo on Monday June 24, 2013 @10:13AM (#5932977)
So go out and fight. Upvoting these kind of smap on HN could hardly be called "fighting".
Re:Ask HN: Can we please slow down the stories about Edward ... by devilcm3 on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:43AM (#5932783)
do people still post about Bradley Manning?

how about wikileaks? Julian Assange?

all those cables?