>>>> That was how slavery was abolished.
No it's not. Slavery was abolished when the state refused to recognize that human being can be owned by anybody and so nobody could make a person to work for another person unvoluntarily. Since then, all employment is voluntary. What the article asks for is to ban voluntary employment of some sort because of some stupid ideas of this columnist about how everybody else should behave.
>>> Well, a lot of people seems to not like it, but keeps doing it not to be seen as an asshole.
So to ask for the government coercion to force people to change the whole way their business works - on the way probably putting a lot of people out of business and out of work is not being asshole, but actually standing up for what you believe in - is being asshole? Talk about perverted ethics... That's like saying the only moral way of doing charity is if you hire a thug to mug somebody and then donate the proceeds. Then again, that seems to actually be very common opinion that charity can not be done without being coerced, so I shouldn't be surprised.
>>> Can you offer any counter argument to the actual points in the actual article?
I just did. I can do it again and very briefly: it absolutely does not matter if you don't like how other people pay for their services and how other people earn their money, and how they behave in general, provided these people are happy with the arrangement. If you don't like tipping restaurant - open non-tipping one and have the happiest servers in the universe and put all others out of business. Or eat at the McDonalds - I have never seen anybody tipping McDonalds cashier.
It seems you misunderstood my point. Slavery was abolished when the state declared it illegal. That kind of thing is what the state is for. If there is a majority of support for "abolishing" tipping, that is where the state can step in and enforce it. That is the point of democracy.
> So to ask for the government coercion to force people to change the whole way their business works - on the way probably putting a lot of people out of business and out of work is not being asshole (...)
This smells very much like the logical fallacies used by the copyright industry. No business would have to go out of business and no costs would need to change. It is simply about making the implicit explicit and to stop pretending it is a gift. You yourself gave a great examples of how McDonalds manages to run their restaurants without tipping.
>>> Can you offer any counter argument to the actual points in the actual article? > I just did.
No you didn't? The article had very specific arguments. They are even nicely numbered. Your "counter argument" is basically "I like it the way it is and no one should tell me to change", backed up by a vague claim that people would somehow lose jobs and business.
>>> No business would have to go out of business and no costs would need to change.
Of course they would need to change - changing the structure of charges would require changing all the prices, and as any price rise, perceived or real, would cost business.
>>> You yourself gave a great examples of how McDonalds manages to run their restaurants without tipping.
I don't go to McDonalds, but I go to other restaurants. So converting all restaurants to McDonalds would cost them my business, that's kinda the point. That'd the difference between our positions - I advocate that both models can work for different people and different situations, and people should be allowed to choose which one they prefer. You advocate that only one model is right for everybody and all others should be banned by the threat of government coercion, and nobody should be allowed to choose what you dislike.
>>> I like it the way it is and no one should tell me to change
It's called freedom. There was time it had some value in America. Now one has to explain what's so valuable about it.
...But it isn't mutually agreed. It is enforced by social stigma. Very unfree if you ask me.
> I don't go to McDonalds, but I go to other restaurants. So converting all restaurants to McDonalds would cost them my business, that's kinda the point.
Now you are just trolling. You seriously believe every restaurant would turn into McDonalds by not accepting tips?
> It's called freedom.
No, it is called anarchy.
>>> You seriously believe every restaurant would turn into McDonalds by not accepting tips?
No, I believe there is place for different things, even if I don't like some of them. You, on the other hand, believe only things you like deserve to exist and for some reason feel entitled to use government coercion to serve you.
> other people do like it and keep doing it
Well, a lot of people seems to not like it, but keeps doing it not to be seen as an asshole.
> I must force them to behave as I want by applying the force of government coercion
That was how slavery was abolished... Is that really your best argument?
Imho, the arguments were very well motivated. Can you offer any counter argument to the actual points in the actual article?