News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Tipping Should Be Outlawed by smsm42 on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:33PM (#5936701)
I understood your point completely and I disagree completely. The point of the democracy is not to enforce majority's views on the minority, at least if we're talking about modern democracy. The point of the democracy is to protect people's rights. Since you have no right to tell the restaurant how to pay their servers, or to restaurant patrons if they should leave tips of not, no democracy can or should give you this right, and it shouldn't matter how many people agree with you - otherwise slavery would be OK as long as slave owners are the majority. On the contrary, one has the right not to be enslaved (or, made to work for other man involuntarily and without mutually agreed compensation) - which makes slavery not OK. It is rather ironic that you invoke slavery - i.e. work forced, ultimately, by government coercion - in support of applying government coercion to mutually agreed trades between people.

>>> No business would have to go out of business and no costs would need to change.

Of course they would need to change - changing the structure of charges would require changing all the prices, and as any price rise, perceived or real, would cost business.

>>> You yourself gave a great examples of how McDonalds manages to run their restaurants without tipping.

I don't go to McDonalds, but I go to other restaurants. So converting all restaurants to McDonalds would cost them my business, that's kinda the point. That'd the difference between our positions - I advocate that both models can work for different people and different situations, and people should be allowed to choose which one they prefer. You advocate that only one model is right for everybody and all others should be banned by the threat of government coercion, and nobody should be allowed to choose what you dislike.

>>> I like it the way it is and no one should tell me to change

It's called freedom. There was time it had some value in America. Now one has to explain what's so valuable about it.

Re:Why Tipping Should Be Outlawed by geon on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @03:51AM (#5944703)
> in support of applying government coercion to mutually agreed trades between people.

...But it isn't mutually agreed. It is enforced by social stigma. Very unfree if you ask me.

> I don't go to McDonalds, but I go to other restaurants. So converting all restaurants to McDonalds would cost them my business, that's kinda the point.

Now you are just trolling. You seriously believe every restaurant would turn into McDonalds by not accepting tips?

> It's called freedom.

No, it is called anarchy.

Re:Why Tipping Should Be Outlawed by smsm42 on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @04:00AM (#5944727)
Of course, free means you get to do what you like and everybody has to like it and tell you so in polite yet colorful language. Otherwise it is not a true freedom - true freedom can only be total absence of consequences for you actions and complete subjugation of others to your wishes, right? If you do something and somebody says its wrong, then is it "very unfree", right? In true freedom, he'd be forbidden from doing this.

>>> You seriously believe every restaurant would turn into McDonalds by not accepting tips?

No, I believe there is place for different things, even if I don't like some of them. You, on the other hand, believe only things you like deserve to exist and for some reason feel entitled to use government coercion to serve you.