> ... I find it unsatisfying that the solution to such a
> simply stated theorem requires 100s of pages of mathematics.
The mathematics involved is getting easier and easier to understand as more and more work is being put into it. Although Wiles originally only proved the underlying result for semi-stable elliptic curves (which was enough for FLT), the full modularity theorem (formerly called the Taniyama–Shimura–Weil conjecture) is now proven, and the field continues to grow. I have little doubt that in 100 years or so this will be within the scope of later stage undergraduate work, just as many results in number theory (and other areas) become more and more accessible as we come to understand them properly.Wiles' proof is still comparatively new, it's still messy, it needs to be enhanced, clarified, expanded, and then "re-factored" to find the cleanest path to the result. The underlying arc of the proof is relatively easy to understand, it's the details that need the long, tedious, and careful arguments that take 100s of pages. One day it will be an obvious consequence of the full Modularity Theorem, discussed in honors projects of undergraduates.
> Would have been cooler if the proof was extremely simple to
> write out, but required outside-the-box thought process that
> evaded thousands of humans for centuries.
In some sense, perhaps. That's what happened with the proof that primality testing is in P. Three undergrads produced an elementary argument that had eluded people for centuries. And yet it's provided no really new insights into anything, and seems to be effectively a dead end. In that sense it's much more exciting to have genuinely new work that wasn't just a simple argument overlooked for centuries.Only on the 18th century the series were discovered http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_trigonometric_functi...
Correction : A Professor(Manindra Agrawal) who had been working on the problem for quite some time and 2 undergrads.
E=mc^2 is just a statement of a relationship, it isn't a proof or a solution to a problem. Mathematical work in modern physics is in fact just as complicated and messy.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abel%E2%80%93Ruffini_theorem
For the Ruffini theorem, http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/286927/why-cant-ther... states:
"The reason five is special is that the group A5 of all even permutations of 5 letters is the smallest non-abelian simple group".
An example from computer science that some may understand better: A monad is just a monoid in the category of endofunctors.
Both are short statements that one cannot grasp without prior knowledge, but that become simple once one has 'some' prior knowledge.
And in some sense, it is turtles all the way down. Even the statement 1+1=2, when studied deeply enough, requires huge amounts of prior knowledge (about 380 pages, and that excludes the definition of 'addition' (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principia_Mathematica#Quotation...) :-))
Some say that there are three kinds of theorems: false, trivial and not yet trivial.
(Proving theorems is hard work!)
A good example is the Jordan curve theorem[1], which at first sight seems like a trivial problem but in effect requires a good deal of topology and analysis to even understand why it is so complicated in the first place.
I use this as an example of why "obvious" things aren't always true, need proving, and understanding their proofs can lead to useful insights.
[0] Edit: corrected "sphere" to "ball"
That is, most people think of physical objects, where there is a minimum "planck length", and no fractal-ish structures with infinitely fine-scale structure.
It is still abstractly interesting that even 2-D fractals satisfy the Jordan Curve therorem, whie 3-D faractals do not satisfy the 3-D version of the conjecture.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_horned_sphere (search for "jordan")
In essence, the "outside" gets very "tangled" and can't be smoothly converted into a "proper" exterior.
[0] S^2 = { (x,y,z) : , x, y, z, in R with x^2+y^2+z^2 = 1 }
I'd be interested to learn whether a linear version (straight pipes instead of curved/broken torus ones) also has the same topological properties. It is clearly fractal, and clearly also homotopy identical to S^2, but obviously the two ends are no longer interlocking, and I wonder if this is as crucial to the result as both 'ends' being fractal clearly is.
In any case, cool! thanks :)
It takes a while to get your head around what this really is.
Having said that, it's quite possible that a more "elegant" proof will be discovered in the future. Maybe it requires further thinking outside the box -- it will more likely require new mathematics.
If you want really non-elegant proofs, take a look at computer-assisted proofs (e.g. proof of the four color theorem). These make the subject of this thread seem extremely elegant!
If for example you simply accept everything up to and including the Taniyama–Shimura–Weil conjecture as true, then the proof of FLT gets pretty close to one line.
So someone Very familiar with the system is happy with one line of interactive shell running a trusted and well understood script. But if its weird, someone might demand to see the PBS batch script contents, or the innards of the perl, of if life and safety aerospace depended on it maybe they'd demand a down to the transistor formal proof of correctness (good luck with any non-trivial problem)
Or put another way I could teach you the equation for the current flow thru a MOS transistor vs gate voltage, maybe even run a simple lab until you're happy, and then say, well, there you go, and thats why my batch script works, and I have an elegant proof of how it works, beginning with this transistor equation, but the margin of my HN comment is too narrow to contain it, so...
Think of this - I can use the number two and refer to it with just a single character - 2. However, properly stating all its properties and what it is starting from just the axioms of set theory, I'll need quite a lot of pages.
And that's how "lets store the number 2" goes from 1000 pages and ten hours of lecture to explain to CS grads, to some 5 minute Kahn academy video that any goof off the street can more or less understand.
There is no proof that any simpler explanation exists. Its quite possible no one will ever teach the proof of FLT to grade school kids. But if it ever happens it'll be like the analogy above.
Would have been cooler if the proof was extremely simple to write out, but required outside-the-box thought process that evaded thousands of humans for centuries.
I hope the same thing does not happen to physics. Discoveries that lead to simple equations like e=mc^2 are so cool!