News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by Locke1689 on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:05AM (#5931110)
This whole NSA thing should be enough to push things like named data networking/content centric networking, WebRTC and meshnets (http://www.reddit.com/r/darknetplan) into the mainstream.

I've tried multiple times to engage on this topic. From my experience, the people set of people who are interested in these topics for "freedom" reasons and the set of people who are technically informed enough to contribute even minimally to technical discussions are non-overlapping.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by stephengillie on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:51AM (#5931254)
The people I talk with about this, who also have the technical acumen to build these things, or those with the political connections to drive change, are both groups of people who have known this level of spying has been going on through their lifetimes, and are unconcerned.

The response on HN has been an order of magnitude larger than the response from any person I know. Of everyone I know, I'm more concerned about the NSA spying than anyone else, and I'm less concerned than most commenters. I begin to wonder if this isn't some kind of nerd-sniping paranoia-groupthink.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by mtgx on Monday June 24, 2013 @05:30AM (#5931890)
Most people aren't "visionaries" or aren't as good at "connecting the dots" as the NSA likes to say. They live their lives in the present - today. Does the NSA spying affect them today? If not, then they aren't concerned about it.

But that's a very wrong way to approach things. You have to connect the dots and see where this is going, before it's too late to do anything to stop it.

Plus, I bet most don't even realize that even if authorities don't come knocking at their door because through their spying they saw they downloaded that last Game of Thrones episode (how long until that happens, anyway?), they could still use the spying to influence judges, politicians, mayors, and so on - which will affect their day to day lives, depending on the decisions those people take through blackmail.

But as I said, most people can't connect the dots like that. Ignorance is a bliss, as they say.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by stephengillie on Wednesday June 26, 2013 @04:33AM (#5944803)
You make a very good point. I was looking for someone to make this point to me, but I didn't know that when I made the post.

The first and easiest argument to make about this is the chilling effect it will have on journalism -- even some things that are unclassified and should be public knowledge can be prosecuted as whistle-blowing.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by flyinRyan on Monday June 24, 2013 @04:08AM (#5931616)
People's feelings about something is an irrelevant metric. It doesn't fucking matter if no one is concerned. There are plenty of past disasters and tragedies that happened because no one was concerned.
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by jtheory on Monday June 24, 2013 @05:40AM (#5931917)
Your third sentence is a pretty effective rebuttal for the first two...?
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by flyinRyan on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:52AM (#5932080)
No, I'm saying no one cared then and disater or tragedy struck anyway. There is little correlation about how we feel vs. what happens to us.
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by jtheory on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @05:37AM (#5938363)
Obviously not caring doesn't accomplish anything, because people who don't care about something won't act.

But if people do care about something, they are motivated to act, and may significantly alter the course of what happens -- not always, and not always as they wanted, but even a small number of motivated people can make serious waves, depending on their skill, charisma, cleverness, opportunity, etc..

Hence, what we feel matters.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by stephengillie on Monday June 24, 2013 @05:14AM (#5931844)
If other people aren't worried about it, why should I be?
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by AnthonyMouse on Monday June 24, 2013 @08:18AM (#5932393)
If other people litter, why shouldn't I? If other people forgo vaccinations, why shouldn't I? If other people are just following orders, why shouldn't I?
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by stephengillie on Monday June 24, 2013 @03:14PM (#5935016)
But other people do not litter. Others do get their kids vaccinated, regardless of what the vocal antivox minority says. Why are the others just following orders -- what are the orders like?

If all of your friends were jumping off of a bridge, why wouldn't you? If you don't trust them in what they do, why are they your friends?

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by jtheory on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:23AM (#5938488)
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by stephengillie on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @07:31AM (#5938685)
This xkcd inspired me
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by jtheory on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @06:05AM (#5938436)
As a human adult, you are probably capable of making moral judgements, and making limited predictions about how your actions will affect you & others in the future.

The minority of people who litter make the experience of walking/living/sitting in that area less pleasant for everyone else, and they increase the likelihood that others will litter ("this park is already full of trash; should I really go chasing after that wrapper that fell?"). Alternatively, you could not make it worse, or you could even make it better by picking up a few things and throwing them out as you pass through.

The minority who don't vaccinate encourage others to avoid vaccinations, and it doesn't take very many of them to undercut or even nullify the benefits of population vaccination (like protecting newborns who can't yet be vaccinated).

Etc. etc..

Do you want to be worse, meaner, less moral, etc. than the average? Or do you want to strive for a little more than that in life?

Realistically, most of us aren't going to have a huge positive or negative impact on the world; but thinking locally, if you are going to seek a mate, friendships, etc., you'll probably do better (and be happier) in life if you at least try to do better than the average.

You may even get an opportunity to make a seriously good decision somewhere along the way, if you have good moral habits and keep your wits about you.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by flyinRyan on Monday June 24, 2013 @06:53AM (#5932083)
Because other people are clueless and apathetic?
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by wavefunction on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:24AM (#5931178)
Don't be so sure. In the great game there must be gambits and feints, misdirections and intentional losses. Some things are better left unsaid in public places with many ears.

Certainly not speaking about myself, but that's the sense I get from talking to people whose interests overlap like you'd hope.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by Locke1689 on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:17PM (#5934285)
Yeah, this is mostly bullshit.

The people who hide away are the same as the people who want you to sign an NDA before they talk about their startup because it's just too revolutionary and cranks who invent new crypto algorithms in their basement.

DS design is extremely complex and requires the coordinated effort of a lot of really smart people to get right. Anyone building these systems in secret just has no idea how terrible they are at it.

Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by chris_mahan on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:23PM (#5933927)
Re:Skype's Principal Architect explains why peer-to-peer was... by rdl on Monday June 24, 2013 @05:52AM (#5931944)
There are plenty of people who want to build things in a decentralized, distributed way for fault tolerance and cost reasons -- those people tend to be fairly competent.

Or, decentralization in the face of a very specific threat (e.g. MAFIAA and piracy-optimized things like BitTorrent, and FinCEN and things like Bitcoin).

Until recently, there weren't widely-believed threats to general Internet use.