News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by sneak on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:09PM (#5930160)
Well, if you generate a deterministic key based on a passphrase known only to you, and send the bitcoin to the corresponding public key, you can store bitcoin using ONLY YOUR MIND.

Seize that.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by dlitz on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:31PM (#5930224)
Sure, here's a court order compelling you to turn over N BTC by such-and-such a date, or you'll be held in contempt of court.

I suppose you can file a motion to quash, but now you'll need to submit evidence that you no longer control those Bitcoins. Good luck. Maybe you'll say the passphrase was destroyed. You might be lying, but in any case, they're as good as seized, because if the Bitcoins are ever spent, we'll see it in the blockchain.

And that's all assuming that the loss or destruction of the Bitcoins even matters to the court. Maybe the current USD value of N BTC is just added to your non-dischargeable debt.

Bitcoins raise some interesting legal & law enforcement questions, but it's wrong to assume that they somehow exempt their users from the law, or prevent all enforcement of the law.

People have been trying to bypass the law for millennia, and it rarely works: The law just isn't that fragile.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by biomechanica on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:24PM (#5930435)
When there are laws that attempt to force people to do things they do not wish to do you get a push back - you get something like Bitcoin or Tor or I2P, etc. Law is always a step behind.

What you see right now is Law trying to play catch up. However, it seems quite obvious that the people involved in creating Laws don't quite know exactly what Bitcoin is fully. We'll see a bunch of really dumb bills being introduced in retaliation then, like always, they will adapt slowly and find a way to take control.

Bitcoin isn't exempt, you're right. Though, Bitcoin can be changed or something new will come out.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by cube13 on Monday June 24, 2013 @12:23PM (#5933926)
I don't see where this is a new rule. This is the exact same thing the DEA has done with large quantities of money or bank accounts.

The US Government's response so far has been pretty good, actually. They're not making new rules for bitcoin. They're making it explicitly known that they're treating BTC like all other forms of money.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by jrockway on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:33PM (#5930469)
Contempt of court is a trivial sentence compared to the sentences that you'd otherwise get for selling drugs and laundering money. It's not even clear that the government can compel you to give up something that only exists in your mind.
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by rdtsc on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:44PM (#5930508)
In some jurisdictions contempt of court has ended up being a virtually endless jail sentence. Even in civil cases on can be held indefinitely in jail until they comply with the court order. There was a case when one person was held this way for years because they wouldn't reveal where they put some large amount of money that their spouse was supposed to get after a divorce...or something of that sort, I believe it was in California. The point is sometimes contempt of court is not a whole lot different effectively than just a prison term.
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by pyre on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:21PM (#5930612)
According to Wikipedia, the guy was jailed for 14 years: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#United_States
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by krichman on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:35AM (#5931217)
For fucks sake, USA. Do you even want to be free anymore?
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by smsm42 on Monday June 24, 2013 @04:52AM (#5931768)
This has nothing to do with freedom, the guy owed money by court decision, refused to pay it to his divorced wife, so he got contempt sentence. If you want to get some outrage going, read about civil forfeiture.
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by krichman on Tuesday June 25, 2013 @12:14AM (#5937477)
I'm already angry about that, thanks :)
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by peteretep on Monday June 24, 2013 @03:07AM (#5931420)
Contempt of court is a potentially infinite jail sentence; hardly trivial
Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by eksith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:05PM (#5930573)
There's something to this. It's entirely possible that the password is some randomly generated one that you wrote on a piece of paper taped under a desk somewhere.

During the "raid" (I.E. your desperate attempt to set fire to your own property to destroy evidence), this password was lost.

The court can't force you to hand over something you no longer have. Of course, the court also can't give you a polygraph test since it isn't admissible as evidence anyway.

If the Bitcoins do get spent sometime later, you could argue someone likely bruteforced the passphrase (it was only 12 characters long). That's still reasonable doubt.

Edit: After reading my own post, I'm quite terrified of my own imagination. I think you're a bad influence on me :(

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by anigbrowl on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:07PM (#5930760)
If the Bitcoins do get spent sometime later, you could argue someone likely bruteforced the passphrase (it was only 12 characters long). That's still reasonable doubt.

Good luck arguing that that a password with 78-bit entropy (12 characters out of 95 in the ASCII set) was likely broken by brute force. 'Reasonable doubt' does not mean 'no matter how improbable,' otherwise nobody would ever get convicted.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by eksith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:45PM (#5930877)
Reasonable doubt means there is reasonable doubt. Or if you prefer metaphors, the term is naked. Doubt, that the progenitor of the pass phrase was likely the one who transferred the coins to another address(s) is sufficient to preclude it as a determining factor. That is, of course, if your lawyer is good enough to be persuasive.

Meanwhile, people have been convicted with far more implausible evidence (eyewitness testimony comes to mind) so this will be the least of your worries.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by anigbrowl on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:25AM (#5931179)
Reasonable doubt means there is reasonable doubt.

Wow. You've certainly persuaded me.

Re:Bitcoins Seized by DEA by eksith on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:14AM (#5932157)
You tried to infuse more meaning to that term by trying to add to its definition a-thing-that-it-isn't.

  >'Reasonable doubt' does not mean 'no matter how improbable,'
You're right. "Reasonable doubt" also does not mean "Ice Cream Sunday", but that doesn't make it "Pudding" instead. The term means exactly what it says, so I say again, "Reasonable doubt means there is reasonable doubt".

It's times like this I genuinely wish HN had an "ignore" feature since I don't believe in down votes.