News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by mbenjaminsmith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:42AM (#5926840)
My opinion of the HK SAR, which has always been quite high, just went up a couple of notches.

I hope Snowden finds asylum and can live a reasonably comfortable life. He's a patriot. I'm a US citizen and I'm pro-US but this bullshit has to stop.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by reinhardt on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:30AM (#5926972)
Best part was the closing: "Meanwhile, the HKSAR Government has formally written to the US Government requesting clarification on earlier reports about the hacking of computer systems in Hong Kong by US government agencies. The HKSAR Government will continue to follow up on the matter so as to protect the legal rights of the people of Hong Kong."
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by simonbarker87 on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:07PM (#5928034)
I laughed out loud at this bit. Translation "Maybe we would have helped but seeing as you're monitoring our networks without our say so - we won't"
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:14PM (#5928062)
Or, alternatively, "You jerks have a lot of nerve, expecting favors from us after being caught with your hands in our pockets."
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by samstave on Sunday June 23, 2013 @04:30PM (#5929300)
"But... but.. I was getting this cookie for you!!"
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by malandrew on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:37AM (#5933584)
I'm curious if this is going to happen with every country he visits. I really wouldn't be surprised if he has documents for transgressions made by the NSA against every country on his list of places to go. For every alliance we have won with diplomacy, it only takes an act of espionage to act as the fire that burns it down.

I'm all in favor of espionage, but only against companies we are actively hostile with.

I'm really curious if he is going to produce damning evidence of deep, active, ongoing espionage against any of the other four of the five eyes (Britain, Canada, Australia, New Zealand).

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by malandrew on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:12PM (#5937293)
oops. meant "countries" not "companies"
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by npalli on Sunday June 23, 2013 @07:12AM (#5927051)
>>My opinion of the HK SAR, which has always been quite high, just went up a couple of notches.

How so? For the past 10 days we have been hearing non-stop reports of the infamous extradition process that will drag on for 10-15 years in HK, providing asylum to Snowden. Turns out a mere day after espionage case was filed Snowden is allowed to leave HK. Do you seriously believe Snowden thought, wow it was great living in HK for 10 days but now I need to go to Venezuela or Cuba (via Russia) since they are havens of freedom and human rights? Snowden put HK in a very tough position this is literally the best way they could get the US off their backs. The strong language in the press release is all show, look at what people do not what they say.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by mbenjaminsmith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:36AM (#5927507)
> For the past 10 days we have been hearing non-stop reports of the infamous extradition process that will drag on for 10-15 years in HK

Have we? I didn't read those. I also didn't expect HK to grant asylum and I don't think there's any precedent for a US citizen seeking asylum in or being extradited (or not) from HK.

HK's track record with asylum seekers isn't that great (around 10% are granted asylum) and the bulk of those cases involve people from the region. HK doesn't have its own laws in place regarding asylum seekers and instead defers to the UNHRC for those decisions.

Did Snowden leave HK because they asked him to? I don't think there's any evidence of that. (Correct me if I'm wrong.) What they did do is refuse to arrest him at the request of the US and refuse to treat him like anything other than an American tourist. I'd say they did all that could be expected of them.

> Snowden put HK in a very tough position this is literally the best way they could get the US off their backs.

I think you might be overestimating how much HK & China care about what the US wants. The US isn't in a position to dictate policy to Beijing.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:11PM (#5928044)
>For the past 10 days we have been hearing non-stop reports of the infamous extradition process that will drag on for 10-15 years in HK,

That was an optimistic assessment, best case. Either Snowden has received advice leading him to reconsider his course of action, and/or HK has expressed to him that they are not confident in their ability to, or haven't the will to resist the US/China in a diplomatic battle over his extradition, or maybe they just aren't confident that they can assure his safety. If one of the latter is the case then it is gracious of them to provide an opportunity for Snowden to leave unmolested.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by nthj on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:47AM (#5926856)
> I'm a US citizen and I'm pro-US and this bullshit has to stop.

FTFY

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by mbenjaminsmith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @05:56AM (#5926877)
Agreed.
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by return0 on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:08AM (#5927239)
Its sad that european governments dont step up support and asylum for snowden. After all the surveillance scandal affects mostly non-US citizens, with countries like germany being targeted specifically. If this guy did such a service for us, why are we not actively protecting him the way we protect chinese dissidents?
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by binderbizingdos on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:42AM (#5927352)
don't you realize that the european governments are very much under US influence still?

US = good, China and Russia etc. = bad

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by corford on Sunday June 23, 2013 @04:03PM (#5929177)
Unfortunately, the answer can be summed up in one sentence: The US has Europe by the balls.

Not a very eloquent way to put it but it's true.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by seferphier on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:02AM (#5926892)
HK just dodged a bullet. this was the most strategically sound thing to do.

HK govt would just listen to the officials in China on this matter. In the same time, it has to respect the judicial system (if he applies to be asylum seeker). A very careful line must be struck between the two.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by lostlogin on Sunday June 23, 2013 @06:14AM (#5926931)
Great comment on the awkwardness of their situation. A bullet it was not, however. It would have been slow, protracted and very painful. There are some happy officials, feeling 10 years older but having a celebratory drink I'm sure.
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:21AM (#5927462)
> He's a patriot

Daniel Ellsberg is a patriot.

Edward Snowden crossed the line a long time ago when he fled to China to reveal more than domestic surveillance but foreign intelligence activities.

I'm probably just as indignant as you are about the domestic surveillance, but the activities of Snowden started out as patriotism, but very quickly crossed into defection.

tldr - champions of human rights don't flee to china & russia. Those places are where defecting spies go.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by grey-area on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:02PM (#5928295)
I don't agree with you, but have given you an upvote as the downvoting was not justified. I wish people wouldn't use downvotes just because they disagree with a post or think it is false - it stifles discussion and leads to the tyranny of a loud majority, not to the debate on these issues which is so sorely needed.

BTW here's why I disagree - apart from the widespread domestic surveillance already admitted the NSA has used dragnet foreign surveillance from other five eyes nations like the UK to spy on American communications with no suspicion of wrongdoing, and has attempted dragnet surveillance in other nations like China (text messages). All of those things deserve debate - even on foreign surveillance the NSA should not have a free hand IMHO - they're supposed to target enemies of the US, not engage in blanket surveillance - that's a dangerous and massive expansion of their powers and in the hands of a president like Nixon would be truly terrifying. It also undermines the position of the US in the world and allows nations like China to indulge in cyberattacks with absolutely no moral high ground for the US.

Re where Snowdon goes, I think that has far more to do with pragmatism that his wish-list of most desired countries - from his own words I think he would have preferred to stay in the US and fight this if he felt he'd be given a fair trial, but that has been made impossible by the calls of traitor from the current administration (what they mean of course is traitor to the NSA and administration, not to the country, but those two are confounded).

The alternative interpretation of his actions is that a champion of human rights has been obliged to flee the US and seek refuge with enemies of the US, because he risks imprisonment without bail, torture and indefinite detention at home (all of those have been used in the war on terror in the last decade). It is quite credible that he wouldn't be allowed to state his case or argue his defence as Ellsberg did, and in fact Ellsberg agrees with him on that, and the treatment of Manning justifies his fears. So maybe champions of human rights do now flee the US?

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:11PM (#5928338)
I do appreciate your response. Thanks.

On your first point, I barely disagree with you at all.

The second point is where I feel like no one is paying much attention: For me personally, the irony of criticizing the US on unethical activities from the patronage of countries that routinely and violently trample the human rights of their citizens completely destroys and legitimacy of the broader point he's trying to make.

And your third point is also disturbing and true. I don't disagree.

Edit: BTW, my above post all day long has been hovering between +5 upvotes to -5 votes. It's the wildest ride I've seen on an HN thread ever :)

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by bobwaycott on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:57PM (#5928578)
> For me personally, the irony of criticizing the US on unethical activities from the patronage of countries that routinely and violently trample the human rights of their citizens completely destroys and legitimacy of the broader point he's trying to make.

Interesting. For me, it doesn't destroy credibility and legitimacy at all. Nor does it smell of defection. The irony, however, is what is most tangible. If we have, through the actions of our intelligence agencies, reached a point where American citizens must flee the country and take refuge in a traditionally maligned foreign power to effectively protect the Constitution and the People, it is a clarion call for the need to make a full stop, publicly work out these problems, and get ourselves back on the right track. If protecting constitutional and human rights requires one to flee a nation that champions those causes publicly, but prosecutes their defenders privately, we have a serious problem.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by grey-area on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:37PM (#5928475)
That's a fair criticism, and actually I doubt Snowden would disagree with you, though we don't really know his views at this point. What we do know is that he has little choice if he wishes to avoid being arrested in travel, rendered or becoming a stooge to a powerful enemy of the US like China or Russia. Ecuador may be his least-worst option, as HK was to avoid detention initially.

While it would be admirable to remain and try to fight the administration in spite of their policies on Manning and calls of traitor, I do understand his choice to try to remain free.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by Cushman on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:39PM (#5928484)
Can you clarify what you're saying here? That the existence of a massive unlawful surveillance state is not an issue because the sorts of tinpot dictatorships a person has to flee to to escape political reprisal by a massive unlawful surveillance state themselves have poor human rights records?

What does one have to do with the other?

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by devcpp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:21PM (#5928711)
Two wrongs don't make a right. He can criticize the US all he wants. We all can. And we all can criticize whichever leaders we want for being assholes. It may be unfair but Snowden had no choice given the reaction of the US.

Don't look at it as separate points. You have to understand the situation as a whole and that if you prized the US and had been in his situation and didn't want to rot in jail forever, you'd have done the exact same.

EDIT: Or, you know what? Perhaps you're smarter than me. What would you have done different? It's easy to criticize but you'll have to come up with solutions. For the US, they could've just obeyed their own law and requested warrants wherever there was probable cause. But for Snowden? What could he have done different while preserving his own life?

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by danbruc on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:50AM (#5927537)
Edward Snowden crossed the line a long time ago when [...] [he] reveal[ed] more than domestic surveillance but foreign intelligence activities.

Foreign intelligence activities are not necessarily legal and I am pretty sure quite a few of the revealed NSA foreign intelligence activities are illegal. This whole US-citizens-vs-foreign-country-citizens-thing really pisses my off - people are people no matter where they live. Spying at them without suspicion is illegal. And even if it would not be illegal it would still be wrong.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by mbenjaminsmith on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:13AM (#5927605)
Wikipedia:

"Ellsberg also shared the documents with New York Times correspondent Neil Sheehan under a pledge of confidentiality. Sheehan broke his promise to Ellsberg, and built a scoop around what he'd received both directly from Ellsberg and from contacts at IPS."

No, Ellsberg got duped. He also went into hiding afterwards (although briefly). He never deliberately put it all on the line.

Snowden made this information public and shortly thereafter admitted to it -- knowing full well that it would end his life as he knew it. That's the act of a patriot.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:01PM (#5928007)
Get trolled much? HK isn't exactly the seat of the Chinese politburo. The fact that the guy needs to go to avail himself of un-friendly-ish hospitality such as flights through Moscow and Cuba ought to tell you something about nature of our government's conduct; or at least Ed Snowden's opinion of it. I can't fault him for expecting the worst. It underscores the need for nations to maintain their sovereignty and independence from the US. It ought to be possible to travel in the world against the wishes of any one country, or cartel of allies.

>I'm probably just as indignant as you are about the domestic surveillance

No, you aren't. Snowden hasn't (doesn't appear to have) revealed conduct that other governments were unaware of. Most of these thing have been leaked before. He's merely outed that conduct publicly, at a time when the press was under attack from the DOJ. If it weren't for that fact, and or maybe his flight from the US, I suspect we may not even still be talking about any of this.

tl;dr Don't be trollbait.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:44PM (#5928200)
I actually do appreciate this response. I think it well encapsulates the gist of the debate of what's going on here on HN.

There's a great irony going on that I think few people here are appreciating. Snowden "blew the whistle" on illegal and unethical government programs and surveillance. This is a noble deed for a citizen. There is little disagreement there. And he make these revelations precisely because governments shouldn't do illegal and unethical things.

And then it turns out he's seeking refuse in places that have (less sophisticated, but) much more violent and brutal intelligence and police arms. Not to mention countries that have completely rigged elections (Venezuela, Russia) or no elections at all (Cuba, HK to some extent), and countries in which journalists are routinely murdered (Russia) or forbidden (Cuba).

So now I'm confused to what his point is? (I need to flee from a country that spies on its citizens.... to a country that terrorizes its people, but hey, as long as it's not me it's cool.) What is your point? (Nevermind the thousands of political prisoners etc in these countries, at least they are a place for US whistleblowers to seek refuge)?

Why couldn't he have gone straight to Iceland, Norway, Switzerland... any number of countries for which extradition to US may be difficult but at least have nominal respect for human rights. Perhaps it's also asking too much, but - IMO - if he really wanted to make a statement with full moral authority he could have just pulled a Socrates and stood trial here in the US.

tldr - while sitting comfortably in his seaside villa in Cuba or Venezuela, I'll regain respect for Snowden when he criticizes his host country as vocally and forcefully as he criticizes the US intelligence apparatus, but I think he's too much of a hypocrite/coward to do that.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by bobwaycott on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:06PM (#5928628)
> Why couldn't he have gone straight to Iceland, Norway, Switzerland... any number of countries for which extradition to US may be difficult but at least have nominal respect for human rights.

Well, there is the recent statement from Birgitta Jónsdóttir that asylum in Iceland would be a difficult achievement. Beyond that, you seem to be having difficulty understanding (and passing judgment on) Snowden choosing to act in a way that you wouldn't. This is hardly a judgment against Snowden. He's not necessarily making moves to maintain a good PR story. One might be justified in the assumption that he is making necessary and strategic choices.

> Perhaps it's also asking too much, but - IMO - if he really wanted to make a statement with full moral authority he could have just pulled a Socrates and stood trial here in the US.

That's a curious judgment of 'full moral authority'. Humans are an imperfect creature. Full moral authority is not derived from actions alone, but also from the intentions behind those actions. Who knows, perhaps Snowden will pull a Socrates when he has completed his current mission of strategically releasing information until his cache is exhausted.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by Cushman on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:48PM (#5928533)
I'm having trouble following. Can you complete this argument for me:

1. Edward Snowden has revealed unethical behavior by his home state.

2. Edward Snowden has fled to a foreign state that itself does unethical things.

3. ????

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @01:58PM (#5928581)
3. Edward Snowden doesn't really care about government behaving ethically or respecting human rights (as evidenced by accepting largess of such countries).

4. Edward Snowden has crossed the line from being a wistleblower and activist, to basically being little better than a defecting spy. He should not be praised the way he is around here.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by Cushman on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:06PM (#5928626)
Okay, and even if I grant that enormous equivocation, it has what to do with #1?
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by krapp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:13PM (#5928669)
At the very least, some people should apply a bit more critical thinking.
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:14PM (#5928672)
>I actually do appreciate this response. I think it well encapsulates the gist of the debate of what's going on here on HN.

I guess that's sarcasm. That's fair. I called you trollbait. I think you're taking the propaganda campaign against Snowden at face value, and perhaps not considering the limits of Snowden's real alternatives.

>There's a great irony going on that I think few people here are appreciating. Snowden "blew the whistle" on illegal and unethical government programs and surveillance. This is a noble deed for a citizen. There is little disagreement there. And he make these revelations precisely because governments shouldn't do illegal and unethical things.

I'm glad we can agree on that.

>And then it turns out he's seeking refuse in places that have (less sophisticated, but) much more violent and brutal intelligence and police arms.

I'm ashamed to have to say it, but I disagree that a US citizen can make such a claim after the disclosure that our country has rendered prisoners to Jordan, Syria, Egypt, who knows where else, with the knowledge and intention that they'd be tortured. Also, the obvious point of the continued operation of the Guantanamo Bay facility, and the known treatment of prisoners there. Also, the carelessness with which our gov't carried out those operations, that has allowed the torture of so many now known to be unrelated to any warfighting, terrorism, or otherwise aggressive actions against the US. We have no room to talk, in fact it is much worse that we are both barbarian thugs and hypocrites.

>Not to mention countries that have completely rigged elections (Venezuela, Russia) or no elections at all (Cuba, HK to some extent),

Don't look now, but elections in this country don't pass the giggle test. Electronic black box voting machines which have no ability to audit them? In one case manufactured by a partisan businessman who promised victory to a presidential candidate?

> and countries in which journalists are routinely murdered (Russia) or forbidden (Cuba).

No comment.

>So now I'm confused to what his point is? (I need to flee from a country that spies on its citizens.... to a country that terrorizes its people, but hey, as long as it's not me it's cool.)

Maybe every move he makes is not made with the intention of making a point? Maybe, it's the adversarial nature of those relationships that he is depending upon to protect his safety. Can you give me a list of countries that you'd approve of Snowden fleeing to, that have the political/economic clout to resist US demands? Oh, btw, WE the USA, our country terrorizes its people, how else do you explain people confessing to crimes which they did not commit in order to avoid a trial? How else do you explain attorneys giving their clients that advice?

>What is your point? (Nevermind the thousands of political prisoners etc in these countries, at least they are a place for US whistleblowers to seek refuge)?

What about the prisoners in our country? What about the treatment that people receive from our own country?

>Why couldn't he have gone straight to Iceland, Norway, Switzerland... any number of countries for which extradition to US may be difficult but at least have nominal respect for human rights.

I don't know.

> Perhaps it's also asking too much, but - IMO - if he really wanted to make a statement with full moral authority he could have just pulled a Socrates and stood trial here in the US.

Come on, I thought we were having a mildly serious chat. Binney, Drake, Radack, Edmunds, Tice, Manning, Tamm, Leibowitz, every one of these people and more have suffered terrible consequences for whistleblowing. Most used official channels, none fled to adversarial jurisdictions. Most support Snowden's flight, none have condemned him for it.

>tldr - while sitting comfortably in his seaside villa in Cuba or Venezuela, I'll regain respect for Snowden when he criticizes his host country as vocally and forcefully as he criticizes the US intelligence apparatus, but I think he's too much of a hypocrite/coward to do that.

You expect saintly impeccable behavior from critics of our government? Saintly people are busy feeding starving children, they have no time for a job at the NSA. And who cares how much you respect Snowden? Why does it matter? Look man, the "rule of law", our constitutional principles, it's a sham. The Emperor has no clothes. Why would you be surprised if the naked Emperor tried to discredit anyone who reported his nakedness?

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by darkarmani on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:36PM (#5928781)
This is exactly the part people should weight heavily -- these patriots used official channels, were punished and support his actions:

> Binney, Drake, Radack, Edmunds, Tice, Manning, Tamm, Leibowitz, every one of these people and more have suffered terrible consequences for whistleblowing. Most used official channels, none fled to adversarial jurisdictions. Most support Snowden's flight, none have condemned him for it.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by vbtemp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @03:12PM (#5928944)
No, the thing is, I actually did appreciate your response. Maybe you are one of those people that have a hard time accepting that other people can have different opinions and be quite valid.

Anyway, I do appreciate the continued response. You got to convincing me with your point before, but now that you have fleshed it out more I am stepping back. If, underlying your argument, is that the rule of law "is a sham", then we have nothing further to talk about. Our universes are a little too different.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @03:36PM (#5929054)
My apologies. I can't always fish nuance out of text, and in your case, it looks like a fished some out that wasn't there.

Maybe sham is too strong of a word. How about eroded?

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by tomp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:35AM (#5927504)
They barely have any other choice than to choose a non-US-friendly country that cannot be bullied into extraditing them.
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by darkarmani on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:31PM (#5928753)
> tldr - champions of human rights don't flee to china & russia. Those places are where defecting spies go.

Why wouldn't he go to a country that is less likely to release him back to the US? Of course he has to go to an country that has conflict with the US.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by mehwoot on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:56AM (#5927759)
More like they wanted absolutely nothing to do with any of this, and just let him get on the plane whilst panning off whatever excuse they could think of ("um.. your paperwork isn't in order").

They really didn't want to have to make a decision about anything, and now they won't.

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by pekk on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:55AM (#5927986)
Question: when does dumping secrets of the US stop being patriotic?
Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by cheald on Sunday June 23, 2013 @02:50PM (#5928852)
When the disclosure of those secrets actively harms the citizens of the United States.

I maintain that Snowden had engaged in activity that is beneficial to the citizens of his country, and to the ideals of the Constitution of his country, and is therefore very deserving of the title of "patriot".

Re:HKSAR Government issues statement on Edward Snowden by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday June 23, 2013 @12:19PM (#5928088)
>Question: when does exposing secret crimes of the US stop being patriotic?

Never?

>Question: when does dumping secrets of the US stop being patriotic?

When the US' conduct approaches the conduct it professes?