News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No One Is Innocent by anigbrowl on Friday June 21, 2013 @10:26PM (#5922303)
The second problem with these sorts of laws is that they never expire. Legislators are never forced to debate old laws, even if the laws no longer make sense.

Not actually true, lots of laws have sunset provisions built in. LAws are often repealed or overturned. New laws are typically passed because egregious situatiosn occur and there's not prosecutable under existing law. In the meantime, defendants rely on procedrualism as much as prosecutors do.

The growth and complexity of law is a problem, but misrepresenting the situation as people like Silverglate do (without ever explaining the legal philosophy behind how it came to be this way) leaves everyone worse off because they're just as ignorant as before.

The media loves this of course. That's why when government agencies ask for comment ias part of their rulemaking process (which requess for comments are published in the state or federal register, as all pro journalists know), the media hardly ever bothers to mention it ot the public until the deadline for comment sis looming, in order to create a false sense of urgency and an impression ofa government that doesn't give the people time to react to what's being done in their name.

We should live in a society where no reasonable person has to worry about whether or not they are breaking the law. That means we need our laws to expire periodically, so that we keep debating whether or not they make sense, and that means we need to not just pass laws every time someone happens that we do not like.

Suppose the statute on murder expired automatically every 10 years and had to be reauthorized. What makes you think it would not just be expanded every single time the review period came around? Switching out the legislative mechanism isn't going lead to a magical improvement in human psychology.

Re:No One Is Innocent by AnthonyMouse on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:46PM (#5922499)
>Suppose the statute on murder expired automatically every 10 years and had to be reauthorized. What makes you think it would not just be expanded every single time the review period came around?

It would be. But who would expect it wouldn't be? The law against murder is not the issue here. It's all the laws against all the things no one would necessarily even expect to be illegal.

So how about this: A law can be passed with a simple majority but expires after 10 years. A law can be made permanent (in the sense that it doesn't expire, not that it can't be repealed) only if it is passed unanimously in both houses and not passed using a veto override. Obviously then murder can become permanently illegal since that will have 100.00% support. But every decade we have to have a debate about each of the laws that didn't have unanimous support originally, and anything so unimportant that nobody even remembers it can fall off the books before it becomes an anachronism.

Re:No One Is Innocent by anigbrowl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:00AM (#5922528)
I can see plenty of problems with that approach too, eg Murder never becomes permanent people people keep trying to shoehorn in a clause making abortion into murder. I've said it before and I'll say it again, you are not going to change human behavior just by rejigging the legislative system. You talk about 'things that no one would expect to be illegal' but all those laws got passed because for some group of people, they address a real problem. People like Silverglate cherry-pick weird stories that most people aren't familiar with to try and make it seem like the entire game is rigged. It's total BS. The average person is not committing 3 felonies a day. I would love to meet Silverglate some time and call him out on his bullshit.
Re:No One Is Innocent by AnthonyMouse on Saturday June 22, 2013 @12:26AM (#5922587)
>eg Murder never becomes permanent people people keep trying to shoehorn in a clause making abortion into murder.

I don't see how that's a real problem. Even assuming they can never once pass it unanimously, they're still going to renew it every time rather than allowing murder to become legal. Also, an amendment expanding the definition of murder to nontraditional entities is going to get killed if necessary to save the bill, and if the vote on the clean bill isn't unanimous then there are going to be Congress Critters who have to explain to their constituents why they voted against prohibiting murder.

As I see it the real trouble with this approach is that it encourages Congress to just reauthorize everything without a debate because there are so many laws they don't have time to do their jobs thoroughly. And that's kind of a different problem -- which is already a problem today, since they should be considering whether laws on the books should be repealed on a regular basis regardless.

But if the strongest argument you can make against something is "it might only help a little instead of a lot," it's maybe still the sort of thing we should try.

Re:No One Is Innocent by anigbrowl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @01:48AM (#5922725)
But if the strongest argument you can make against something is "it might only help a little instead of a lot," it's maybe still the sort of thing we should try.

That's not the argument I'm making. Don't put words in my mouth.

I don't think it will help at all.

Re:No One Is Innocent by AnthonyMouse on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:02AM (#5923814)
OK fine, suppose it's totally useless. It still doesn't seem to have any serious disadvantage over the status quo, which means we could still benefit by implementing it if only in order to test your hypothesis that it won't work.
Re:No One Is Innocent by anigbrowl on Saturday June 22, 2013 @05:39PM (#5925236)
I've already outlined what I consider the potential disadvantages. By all means see if you can get your state legislature to give it a whirl, that's what they're there for,