But if the strongest argument you can make against something is "it might only help a little instead of a lot," it's maybe still the sort of thing we should try.
That's not the argument I'm making. Don't put words in my mouth.
I don't think it will help at all.
Re:No One Is Innocent
by AnthonyMouse on Saturday June 22, 2013 @11:02AM
(#5923814)
OK fine, suppose it's totally useless. It still doesn't seem to have any serious disadvantage over the status quo, which means we could still benefit by implementing it if only in order to test your hypothesis that it won't work.
I don't see how that's a real problem. Even assuming they can never once pass it unanimously, they're still going to renew it every time rather than allowing murder to become legal. Also, an amendment expanding the definition of murder to nontraditional entities is going to get killed if necessary to save the bill, and if the vote on the clean bill isn't unanimous then there are going to be Congress Critters who have to explain to their constituents why they voted against prohibiting murder.
As I see it the real trouble with this approach is that it encourages Congress to just reauthorize everything without a debate because there are so many laws they don't have time to do their jobs thoroughly. And that's kind of a different problem -- which is already a problem today, since they should be considering whether laws on the books should be repealed on a regular basis regardless.
But if the strongest argument you can make against something is "it might only help a little instead of a lot," it's maybe still the sort of thing we should try.