News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:This is a web page by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 20, 2013 @02:15PM (#5913789)
First time [1] my in-laws saw "the web" they were trying to find information about vacation spots in Brazil but their travel guide was obsolete, I found a web page a student had written up about where the best places to stay and see were in Brazil.

I could almost see the dots connect when they realized that someone they didn't know, in Brazil, had written up a piece of information at some point that they were now seeing and using, and anyone could do that. It was like watching a Pachinko machine pay out a jackpot :-)

[1] It was circa Christmas 1994 since I was trying to explain to them what Java was and why I thought it might have an impact on the world.

Re:This is a web page by simpleglider on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:22PM (#5914691)
That's a great anecdote. Out of curiosity, how did you find the site? I had just turned four at the time, so I don't quite remember what browsing the Internet was like then.
Re:This is a web page by petercooper on Thursday June 20, 2013 @06:47PM (#5915431)
Because other people have given good answers, I just wanted to add.. the Web was so much better linked together back then. Prior to Altavista made searching useful most of the time, it was common to rely on jumping from one site to another through plentiful link pages, web rings, and lists of resources that people had put together. There was also Usenet which people often posted links on and which was sorted by topic and a handy way to find stuff.
Re:This is a web page by Nate75Sanders on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:28PM (#5915590)
Seconded.

Even after Altavista was clearly better than Yahoo for ad-hoc searches, I still used Yahoo a lot because their topic hierarchy was a really great way to sit down and learn about some topic and its sub-topics.

I was particularly keen on this while eating because you could browse the web with just the mouse very easily.

Re:This is a web page by at-fates-hands on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:47PM (#5915826)
>There was also Usenet which people often posted links on and which was sorted by topic and a handy way to find stuff.

When my college roommate showed me how to download a graduate student's thesis from Usenet, I thought my head was going to explode I thought it was so cool. Here I am, halfway across the country, and I can download, read and cite some grad student's paper from the University of California Berkeley.

I now feel like a guy who grew up during the 1950's when you tell kids, "Yeah, the internet wasn't always about Reddit and Porn kiddies."

Re:This is a web page by dwd on Thursday June 20, 2013 @11:28PM (#5916348)
You had alt.religion.kibology and the first crowd-sourcing app in The Internet Oracle.

The technology changes but we seem to keep reinventing the wheel every time the cart gets overcrowded.

Re:This is a web page by hobs on Friday June 21, 2013 @12:56AM (#5916601)
Re:This is a web page by derleth on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:26AM (#5916986)
Implying we should 'fix' Eternal September is pretty close to implying we should keep important technology out of the hands of those the current users deem unworthy. That prevents both spam and the Arab Spring, both 4chan and Wikileaks.

Keeping the Internet as it was prior to 1991, when commercial access was first allowed, means keeping it a small, controlled entity with obvious choke points that make it trivial to censor or kill entirely. It largely prevents its use for social or political change other than the kinds of change its owners want to see. It would trivialize the Internet by relegating it to a tiny fraction of its current usefulness.

It's easy to idealize what we had. However, losing sight of what we have now, and what we could have, is actively harmful to the prospect of future moral growth.

Re:This is a web page by jbert on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:19AM (#5917332)
> Implying we should 'fix' Eternal September is pretty close to implying we should keep important technology out of the hands of those the current users deem unworthy. That prevents both spam and the Arab Spring, both 4chan and Wikileaks.

Not necessarily. The holy grail is growth where culture is preserved, i.e. the rate of acquisition of new users is below the point where they overwhelm the culture.

New users acculturate over time and exposure, so you can roughly model it as "at any time, no more than x% of the users should be 'new'".

That's still exponential growth, so it needn't be elitest. In time, you'll still get to everyone who wants in.

Making it work tho, that's the rub :-)

Re:This is a web page by bradfordarner on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:03AM (#5918361)
I completely disagree with your statement. Maybe there is a bigger question: 'Is crossing the chasm to widespread adoption always a good thing?' Maybe we should be trying to build platforms that are high-quality instead of high-quantity. We are caught in a world that is obsessed with inclusion rather than exclusion. Is that, by necessity, the default position? Should it be?

The internet contributed to building support for the Arab Spring throughout the world but it was tyrannical regimes that were the root cause. Wikileaks is not new. We used to have a little thing called 'investigative journalism', a profession in which people would put their live's on the line to reveal scandals and uncover secrets they felt the world should have known.

Technology does not motivate moral growth. People motivate moral growth. Nazi Germany was the most technologically advanced society in the world when they invaded Poland and set the course for World War II.

The reality is that we are segmenting ourselves from other internet users just by taking part in the HN community. Most people here would admit, the minute HN would spread to the point of being widely adopted, we would all leave. I don't come to HN to be inundated with cat pictures. I'm here because I learn things every time I visit a link posted on HN.

Re:This is a web page by derleth on Friday June 21, 2013 @05:34PM (#5921159)
> Wikileaks is not new. We used to have a little thing called 'investigative journalism',

We still do. And, historically, it never got us anything as important as cablegate.

> Technology does not motivate moral growth.

Technology enables moral growth by reducing the amount of morality-crushing cruelty we're exposed to on a daily basis and allowing our natural morality to flourish. It's easier to care about others when you haven't just lost your child to smallpox.

http://www.edge.org/3rd_culture/pinker07/pinker07_index.html

> Nazi Germany was the most technologically advanced society in the world

They were, at best, on a par with the rest of the Western World, and, frankly, mismanaging themselves into defeat due to the very nature of their society.

The idolization of the Nazis as being so efficient and so advanced is due to what some Western observers thought before the war, when Hitler was using basic Keynesian-style pump-priming in the form of military spending to get the country out of the Depression, mixed with a few largely worthless wonder-weapons, such as the V2 rockets and the early jets, which did nothing to win the war.

> The reality is that we are segmenting ourselves from other internet users just by taking part in the HN community. Most people here would admit, the minute HN would spread to the point of being widely adopted, we would all leave. I don't come to HN to be inundated with cat pictures. I'm here because I learn things every time I visit a link posted on HN.

This is true but it misses my point: Everyone can have their little niche space, which is amazing if you're not an upper-middle-class heterosexual cissexual white male who would have niche spaces anyway.

Gays can have spaces where being gay isn't weird. Trans people can have spaces where being trans doesn't mean you get your head kicked in. That kind of social interaction was pretty well impossible before the Internet, especially in places like Iran or Alabama, where advertising that you are 'a certain way' could be an invitation to violence.

The Internet is both a network of linked networks and a community of linked communities; both aspects are vital to what it is and what it can become.

Re:This is a web page by DanBC on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:59AM (#5917406)
I don't know - you can try to be inclusive and also set some standards. That doesn't have to be for the entire Internet.

The future people will have fun comparing and contrasting different reputation systems and online communities. Assuming enough information stays for them to study.

Usenet was archived by Deja, which got bought by Google. It's in a sorry state, but at least it's stil there.

Who's archiving Reddit, or HN, or 4chan, or all the rest?

Re:This is a web page by cytokine_storm on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:40AM (#5917523)
I agree with your argument. But I think the internet's strongest trait is not necessarily revolutionary changes (wikileaks and arab spring). The things that have been built on the internet have been incredible. Think of crowdsourced projects like wikipedia and how ridiculously trivial it is for a scientist (or someone like me; a student in a lab) to access information or search for experimental data (genes are the tip of the iceberg here).

I don't want to belittle the Arab Spring, but the NCBI database and Wikipedia have arguably had an even larger impact on society than social networking's capability for kickstarting revolution. It's just slower and less obvious.

Re:This is a web page by howeman on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:49PM (#5915663)
I was at a computer camp sometime around '94, and the camp had a printed "Directory of web pages" which was exactly like the yellow pages of the phone book. You would look up a subject, and it had a printed list of urls on that subject.
Re:This is a web page by andyjohnson0 on Friday June 21, 2013 @04:48AM (#5917167)
I still have a copy of "The Whole Internet User's Guide and Catalog" published by O'Reilly in 1992. It has a whole section devoted to lists of addresses of sites grouped by subject. Many of the sites didn't have urls because they were operating over ftp or telnet or WAIS or Gopher.

I just checked and the terms "google", "altavista", and "search engine" do not appear anywhere in the index. Also, no weird web2.0-style domain names.

Different times.

Re:This is a web page by weland on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:48AM (#5917025)
Yes! I will gladly second that.

The sheer amount of information back then was nothing compared to what it was today, but it was so much easier to browse around. Something as trivial as a webring was a cement for a community rather than a pledge for traffic.

Despite the nostalgia, I do think that, overall, the WWW experience has mostly gotten better since then, if only for the amount of information and communication. However, the density of quality has rather shrunk...

Re:This is a web page by SilasX on Thursday June 20, 2013 @10:47PM (#5916233)
As late as 1998 I remember a friend griping about people who said that a site on topic X was good "because of the links".
Re:This is a web page by qw on Friday June 21, 2013 @01:12AM (#5916664)
Couldn't the same be said about Hacker News? Search has improved, but we still rely on "sites with links" to find interesting content.
Re:This is a web page by SilasX on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:07AM (#5916944)
He (and they) meant the static links, not the regular updates.
Re:This is a web page by euxneks on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:12PM (#5915535)
ah.. web rings.. I remember babylon 5 web rings... Nostalgia's a hell of a thing.
Re:This is a web page by visarga on Thursday June 20, 2013 @11:28PM (#5916352)
If we knew back then what is common knowledge today, we could build an early version of Google search in a few months. Web spider, parsing HTML, extracting links and text, computing Page Rank and then making an inverted index to look up info by keyword. Imagine this would have been 100 times better than Yahoo's links and Altavista's search.

By the way, syntax highlight thinks "Altavista" is a spelling error. Talk about becoming the footnote of history. Google was the company that took the lead from AV and now Google's own browser can't understand their main competitor of 10 years ago. AV did it to themselves, putting all that shit on the homepage and not providing good results. LOL

Re:This is a web page by dredmorbius on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:18AM (#5923198)
Search was actually anticipated (along with social graphs) by TBL in his first WWW proposal documents, posted to HN a few months back.
Re:This is a web page by TazeTSchnitzel on Saturday June 22, 2013 @10:17AM (#5923634)
It was anticipated in the protocol, that's what ? is for.
Re:This is a web page by mickeyp on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:15AM (#5917327)
Web Rings were amazing though; found a great site about X-Files plot theories? -- no problem, chances are you'd find more that were like that by following the web ring. We lost something back then that, even today, we never really got back...
Re:This is a web page by devb on Thursday June 20, 2013 @11:54PM (#5916423)
Does anyone know why altavista.com and altavista.digital.com were different? I just remember preferring the digital.com version for some reason.

I wish I could go back in time to 1996... everything on the internet seemed so much more meaningful, not to mention textual (because images took so long to download).

Re:This is a web page by Alex3917 on Friday June 21, 2013 @12:26AM (#5916498)
> everything on the internet seemed so much more meaningful

Back then it almost felt like we were in the heroic age of internet communities, to borrow a phrase used about a period of American inventors. It'll never be like that again, but there are more good things coming in the future.

Re:This is a web page by TazeTSchnitzel on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:47PM (#5922189)
So, the web back then is what Wikipedia is today?
Re:This is a web page by dredmorbius on Saturday June 22, 2013 @07:14AM (#5923188)
That's not a bad characterization.

Web pages were static, many were long-form, they tended to provide information, and link copiously to one another.

What they lacked was collaborative editing, though Ward Cunningham was already working on that at the time. Wikis postdated the Web only by a brief bit.

Re:This is a web page by lewispollard on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:57AM (#5918677)
Wow, web rings, huge nostalgia for that!
Re:This is a web page by swah on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:15AM (#5918415)
Did you use tabs back then?
Re:This is a web page by soundgecko on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:07AM (#5916946)
I wish there was still a curated list of categorized websites.
Re:This is a web page by brazzy on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:47AM (#5917386)
Re:This is a web page by teh_klev on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:58PM (#5915693)
Back in the day you bought magazines like ".NET" (a UK publication) that told you where the hotspots were on the web.

There were other physical publications like the "Internet White Pages" or some such thing (no seriously) which I remember seeing in UK bookshops and thinking "that's gonna be outa date in a week or two".

Back then you felt you could contain all of the websites (or pointer sites) in your head. It was truly an exciting and exploratory time.

Oh and I forgot, using KA9Q [1] for your TCP/IP stack on Windows 3.1, because Microsoft had't quite caught up at that point. And hacking the UK's PSS network to find your way into a university that was connected so you could access usenet. And the early days of Demon Internet in the UK....oh the nostalgia of it all :)

[1]: http://www.ka9q.net/code/ka9qnos/

Re:This is a web page by thejosh on Thursday June 20, 2013 @09:06PM (#5915896)
Ah yes, you are probably referring to the Internet Yellow Pages[1], use to be one of my favourite things to use at a library and write down websites..

http://i.imgur.com/1n6mH4N.jpg

Re:This is a web page by teh_klev on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:09AM (#5917314)
That one as well. But there was also "The 1994 Internet White Pages" published by Wiley Press which is credited with Seth Godin as a co-author [1][2].

[1]: http://i.imgur.com/HxDWs9c.jpg [2]: http://amzn.com/1568843003

Re:This is a web page by bcRIPster on Thursday June 20, 2013 @06:27PM (#5915349)
In 1994, the main way you found websites was mostly from hub sites that maintained large libraries of links to other sites (like a directory), newsgroups (UUCP/Usenet), friends in IRC trading links, AOL, Delphi and Compuserve forums and print magazines. Webcrawler was revolutionary when it came on-line in 1994, but there were no comprehensive search engines that had a high index count until probably 1996.

The mother of all link directories started from NCSA who distributed the first web browser (Mosaic) and they ran a site where they would publish a monthly list of "What's New" on the web. They pulled the pages from their site a few years ago but fortunately I made a mirror on my server for historical reference that you can check out here:

http://www.kitchencloset.com/realstuff/ncsa/whats_new-archiv...

Enjoy!

edit: forgot to mention web rings someone else just mentioned.

Re:This is a web page by Torgo on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:22PM (#5915567)
I remember circa-1994/1995, our library got a book called something like "World Wide Web Yellow Pages" and it was a printed book of a couple hundred pages of curated web URLs. Even then the irony was not lost on me. Why didn't they just put it online? The answer was, well, then how would you find that?
Re:This is a web page by chebucto on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:09PM (#5915721)
Many sites, including most home pages (remember those?) had a page of links, a small curated set of links[1]. Ooh, and guestbooks! Thousands and thousands of guestbooks!

[1] http://web.archive.org/web/19991022011955/http://www.geociti...

Re:This is a web page by elleferrer on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:15AM (#5916961)
Mosaic, totally remember those WorldWideWeb days.
Re:This is a web page by ChuckMcM on Thursday June 20, 2013 @06:21PM (#5915318)
In context, I was part of the group that would eventually become the Java group (at that time it had transitioned from being the Oak group to being the 'Liveoak' group[1]) Patrick Chan had written a web spider in Java, we marvelled that it seemed like it could visit every site on the web over night :-) But mostly what it found were the 'big' web sites (computer companies, early movers in the Internet space) and students who had downloaded X-mosaic and the httpd from CERN and were playing around with early HTML.

[1] The name was a somewhat morbid joke on James Gosling's part as Sun was cancelling the Java project at the end of the fiscal year and had been split into the "part that the hardware guys liked" (Sun Interactive) and "the part no one knew what to do with." (Liveoak)

Re:This is a web page by Aloisius on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:54PM (#5914896)
I don't know about the OP, but in 1994, I was mostly using Webcrawler as my search engine. Lycos came out around then too. Switched to Altavista pretty quickly after it came out.
Re:This is a web page by jon_dahl on Friday June 21, 2013 @12:21AM (#5916487)
Quick answer: links. Hypertext. It's important enough to the original vision of this whole contraption to actually be the name.

While were reminiscing... In 1994, the web felt like technology. You typed in "http://" and it felt exotic. You were connecting to a server. Literally: _a_ server. You wondered what would happen if you hit the same address with gopher or (more likely) telnet.

As often as not, something would happen.

Re:This is a web page by drcube on Thursday June 20, 2013 @05:03PM (#5914968)
I didn't have a computer at the time, but my friends who were online all used AOL, which came with its own search engine, chat rooms, email, etc.
Re:This is a web page by flaktrak on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:05PM (#5915504)
One year away from being annoyed at the web to being blown away by yahoo.com. A friend searched for some game or something on yahoo and I was like what is the trickery?
Re:This is a web page by kmfrk on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:23PM (#5915571)
I feel like such a hipster for having used AltaVista and Dogpile as search engines.
Re:This is a web page by teh_klev on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:39PM (#5915624)
What is hipster about that? Your statement makes no sense.

I'm 46 and started using the "internet" in 1992 - usenet, gopher, FTP et al. Then came the World Wide Web". Altavista was really all there was before google, why is that "hipster"?

That's like saying you were a hipster for using horse and carriage before Henry Ford started mass producing cars.

If anything being an early adopter of Google seems more "hipster" than using Altavista. Gawd, I musta been and early hipster, how much more "hipster" can you get than that.

Re:This is a web page by makeset on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:03PM (#5915706)
Between Altavista and Google, alltheweb.com (FAST Search) also had their day. I was in charge of a major web portal around 2001, and we were contracting out site search queries to FAST. One day I got a call from a new company named Google. The guy said he could give me a better price than FAST. I asked what price. He said, "Any price."
Re:This is a web page by hboon on Friday June 21, 2013 @12:10AM (#5916466)
Little nugget:

the FAST Search guys sold alltheweb.com to yahoo.com and focused on enterprise search (i.e. they sell/license their software to companies) with customers such as newspaper companies, yellow pages companies and government agencies. They were then acquired by Microsoft a few years ago and rolled into their Sharepoint offerings.

Re:This is a web page by pge on Friday June 21, 2013 @07:10AM (#5917427)
Dont forget northern light. It was a great search engine targeted at researchers and academics that grouped results in folders of topic areas. They made the unfortunate business decision to transition to a paid service right as google was becoming popular.
Re:This is a web page by melvinram on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:24PM (#5915761)
lol that's great. Wonderful to think that even Larry and Sergey had to hustle. Everyone has to put in their time.
Re:This is a web page by lmm on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:39AM (#5917369)
To have used Altavista or Dogpile one must have either been on the internet before it was cool, or made a deliberately retro choice of search engine. Either qualifies for hipsterdom.
Re:This is a web page by gbog on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:35PM (#5915612)
And Astalavista.
Re:This is a web page by Ecio78 on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:01AM (#5916926)
yep, astalavista.box.sk, still remember the full domain by heart... :)

Edit: OMG it's still alive..

Re:This is a web page by Nux on Friday June 21, 2013 @05:43AM (#5917275)
Of course it's alive. Check the whois data for that IP, hosted by "ANTIK Telecom". :-)
Re:This is a web page by jk4930 on Friday June 21, 2013 @03:10AM (#5916951)
code.box.sk was my favorite resource on programming languages then. The whole *.box.sk was amazing.
Re:This is a web page by robeasthope on Friday June 21, 2013 @04:14AM (#5917085)
My god, it even uses tables for the layout, takes you back uh?
Re:This is a web page by hexasquid on Friday June 21, 2013 @11:46AM (#5918600)
Check out hacker news.
Re:This is a web page by joe24pack on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:38PM (#5915622)
Hipster huh? Well what about Lycos, remember that search engine?
Re:This is a web page by StavrosK on Friday June 21, 2013 @06:40AM (#5917372)
Remember the search aggregators, like Magellan (maybe Columbus? Something like that) that searched X different engines and aggregated the results in a desktop app for you to use?

Then I found Google, and I never used anything else again.

Re:This is a web page by eterm on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:56AM (#5917786)
That was Copernic. (After Copernicus) I remember using it and there was a list of perhaps 20 engines. I remember the first to return (like, would return in 1 second not 30 seconds for the rest) was google.

Every single time, google was the first back. It wasn't always ranked the top result back then, but it was fast.

Re:This is a web page by StavrosK on Friday June 21, 2013 @09:09AM (#5917832)
Yes! That's it. Yeah, Google came and blew everything else out of the water. I remember searching for an ocx file for something that wouldn't run, and everything kept returning some spam sites. I somehow stumbled upon Google, after some recommendation, and tried it, and the first result was a legitimate download of the actual file.

It's not hard to see why everyone switched to it.

Re:This is a web page by kmfrk on Friday June 21, 2013 @01:24PM (#5919509)
That's what Dogpile did - at one point - albeit as a regular browser search engine, which was its allure to me. I often got better results than on Google, which must have been around their formative stages.
Re:This is a web page by adefa on Thursday June 20, 2013 @10:19PM (#5916138)
HotBot was where it was at.
Re:This is a web page by kmfrk on Thursday June 20, 2013 @07:45PM (#5915648)
Oh yeah. Vividly.
Re:This is a web page by conanbatt on Thursday June 20, 2013 @03:01PM (#5914136)
Just like your Pachinko reference
Re:This is a web page by mcovey on Thursday June 20, 2013 @04:50PM (#5914873)
Just being cynical here, but books written by people from far away places have circulated for a lot longer than the internet has been around.
Re:This is a web page by drcube on Thursday June 20, 2013 @05:01PM (#5914948)
Not just anybody. You had to have a publisher, and it took weeks to years to get a piece published. Which means nothing got published if there wasn't a chance at a monetary return. The web is a significant improvement if you ask me.
Re:This is a web page by criley2 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @05:26PM (#5915082)
Before Gutenberg et al, you had to have someone spend weeks or months to hand copy your book, one at a time.

To me, the web is just the next step in the improvement in the publishing of the written word. I don't see it as different than a book.

Re:This is a web page by bonobo on Thursday June 20, 2013 @06:11PM (#5915287)
First time my in-laws saw "the book" they were trying to find information about vacation spots in Brazil but their grandpa's diaries were obsolete, I found a printed book a monk had written up about where the best places to stay and see were in Brazil.

I could almost see the dots connect when they realized that someone they didn't know, in Brazil, had written up a piece of information at some point that they were now seeing and using, and many people could do that. It was like looking into the darkness and suddenly seeing a firefly blinking :-)

...

My point here is, the printing press had it's impact, nobody denies that. Seeing the times changing is what leaved ChuckMcM's in-laws astounded.