Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:20AM
(#5904356)
If we could figure out economical nuclear fusion, we wouldn't be arguing right now. We are always 20 years from figuring it out also.
Once we have fusion, producing hydrogen liquid fuel should be cake.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by welterde on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:28AM
(#5904381)
Or about 80bn EUR away from figuring it out.. would be a more useful scale imho (that's at least the number that the local plasma physics institute estimated iirc), as the ETA will keep changing if you change the yearly budget.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by hetman on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:44AM
(#5904434)
The problem with fusion is that in the form accessible to us here on Earth (deuterium-tritium), it still creates radioactive waste. It is not the sort of long lived waste you would see from Uranium based nuclear fission, it is more comparable to Thorium based fission reactors. In other words we already have a pretty decent alternative.
The real holy grail would be Hellium 3 fusion, but first we have to figure out how to import the fuel back to Earth from places like the surface of the Moon or from Jupiter.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by sneak on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:40AM
(#5904611)
> first we have to figure out how to import the fuel back to Earth from places like the surface of the Moon
All we need is a psycho korean holding company and Sam Rockwell and we should be good.
(See "Moon" if you haven't. It's amazingly excellent.)
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by sillysaurus on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:33AM
(#5904592)
Interesting. The moon has Helium 3, but the Earth doesn't?
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by welterde on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:46AM
(#5904626)
It does, but only in rather small quantities. In fact it seems that most He-3 that's used is produced in Tritium decay reactions rather than extracted.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by rfvtgb123 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:21AM
(#5904867)
There are no working reactors (not even tested designs) that harness the potential of thorium. Experimental plants have had serious problems (edit:)and low power generation from thorium (see for example THTR-300 in germany; beware of the english wikipedia page, it is incomplete).
So... come up with a safe design for a thorium reactor? (Edit2:) Until then, you might as well say fusion. Anyway, none of this is a reason to keep classic LWRs going.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by dsego on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:35AM
(#5904916)
What about the liquid fluoride thorium reactors? There's been some hype about these recently: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bbyr7jZOllI
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by rfvtgb123 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:44AM
(#5904943)
This is just molten salt reactors all over again. They have disastrous security problems. Basically the salt eats away metal parts of the reactor, the graphite moderators are flammable and large parts of the reactor become radioactive because they catch neutrons which makes repair, maintenance and deconstruction almost impossible.
(edit:) I forgot about loss of fuel solubility events and the unsolved problem of tritium retention.
(edit:) It's interesting how the english wikipedia pages miss all the details on the failed projects in this field.
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by dsego on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @08:20AM
(#5905066)
Strange, Kirk Sorensen (the guy in the video) seems very sure that these are much safer then any other alternatives. They don't have to be pressurised and water-cooled. Instead there's passive security with a frozen plug and a drain tank.
Here's a longer documentary with lots of details (about 2 hours) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31HEijtqF5I
Re:The real reason to fight nuclear power has nothing to do ...
by codeulike on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:58AM
(#5904497)
> In the long term I really think nuclear is optimal, after all that's what the universe chose... In a way, solar energy is fusion based. ;)
But fusion != fission
For solar, you need sun, for wind, you need wind. The real issue to solve is being able to store electricity. Once you have that, a lot of issues disapear, because you can procude when you can, consume when you need.
In the long term I really think nuclear is optimal, after all that's what the universe chose... In a way, solar energy is fusion based. ;)