why does one need to be "inside" the community and have gained reputation before making valid criticism?
If somebody who has never posted came out of the blue, and listed some criticisms (which are well researched and valid), it should be taken just as seriously as Tony Morris's piece.
I actually didn't say that one needs to be "inside" a community to criticize it, merely that all human communities tend to respond differently to criticism from within than from without. (For instance, Seinfeld's dentist Tim Wotley converting to Judaism "for the jokes".)
It seems to me that there is a pretty typical mix of criticism coming from inside the Ruby and JS communities being responded to thoughtfully, and criticism from outside being responded to defensively.