It seems to me that there is a pretty typical mix of criticism coming from inside the Ruby and JS communities being responded to thoughtfully, and criticism from outside being responded to defensively.
If somebody who has never posted came out of the blue, and listed some criticisms (which are well researched and valid), it should be taken just as seriously as Tony Morris's piece.
Citation needed, Rubyists in particular have been whining (and rightfully so) about MRI's poor concurrency support for the past year or two. That's just one counterexample.
Everyone that I know that's good at Ruby has their own favorite wart where it does something they hate.
To be fair, there's a huge difference between complaining about an implementation and complaining about the design of a language.
A lot longer than that, but, to be fair, that's a criticism of the main implementation, not the language -- and one of the selling points of JRuby. OTOH, there's been lots of criticism, and dissection, in the community of infelicities in the language design that make it difficult to implement efficiently.
To most of these people, Scala is merely a tool, often just one among many others. They fully realize that it has flaws, and are very willing to acknowledge the existence of these flaws. They don't take it personally when somebody points out such problems. This is quite evident after reading through the discussion in this case.
This does differ from how members of the the Ruby and JavaScript communities take criticism of those languages, for example. Such people do tend to be much more emotionally attached to those programming languages, for whatever reason. They react with hostility and denial when they encounter legitimate criticism.
Technological improvement happens best when criticism can flow freely. The people involved are focused on acknowledging and accepting that flaws exist, and then proceed to try to fix them. On the other hand, when legitimate criticism is shunned or blindly denied, like in the JavaScript community, technological progress proceeds at a much slower pace. More effort is placed on defending and maintaining the status quo, even when this is the most ineffectual and non-beneficial thing to be doing, than is expended on improving the situation.