News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by burntsushi on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:39PM (#5901923)
> So by revealing the number of FISA requests they receive and what sort of data is being sought they hope to clear this "direct access" mess. As even FISA orders are much more acceptable than wholesale access.

Not necessarily. As another commenter pointed out [1], a single FISA order doesn't have to correspond to a single citizen. One order can encompass millions of accounts.

> their denials address that, they clearly say that is not the case, instead they sftp the data after being served with court orders or warrants and such, including the secretive FISA requests.

While I think it's reasonable to doubt the claim that the NSA has true direct access to servers, I haven't been given a reason to doubt that information can be requested without court orders, warrants or FISA requests.

[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5901811

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by GreatBuck on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:48PM (#5901962)
> Not necessarily. As another commenter pointed out [1], a single FISA order doesn't have to correspond to a single citizen. One order can encompass millions of accounts.

The court document from Google (http://assets.nationaljournal.com/img/MOTION.pdf) clearly states the desire to clearly list, in aggregate, the number of accounts impacted.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by burntsushi on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:53PM (#5901991)
I know. I wasn't responding to Google's court document. I was responding to rasterizer.
Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by rasterizer on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:49PM (#5901975)
They would want to publish the scope of the FISA requests.

The other companies aren't going this far and I think they deserve a credit for what they're doing.

And I disagree with commend you link to, the solution isn't limiting data collection, sure it makes you a target but more data equals a better product. It's an issue of government overreach not engineering decisions.

Re:Google challenges U.S. gag order, citing First Amendment by burntsushi on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:54PM (#5901996)
We've had a misunderstanding.

I agree with this entire comment. Even the part where you disagreed with part of the comment I linked to. I even responded to that poster before replying to you. :-)

(Sorry about that. I meant to link to the comment for the text of the FISA order, and not for the jab against Google.)