Re:Poll: Would it be OK for the NSA to spy if the code was p...
by jedmeyers on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:58PM
(#5901637)
"there's nothing in the Constitution about the rights of non-citizens." - you are wrong. Just read the text of the Fourth Amendment and try to find the word "citizen" there.
Re:Poll: Would it be OK for the NSA to spy if the code was p...
by pionar on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:40PM
(#5901931)
You're right about the citizens thing, but multiple court cases over the years have asserted that constitutional protections only apply to "US persons". So, citizens, legal residents, non-legal residents, visitors, anyone physically in the US.
Re:Poll: Would it be OK for the NSA to spy if the code was p...
by jedmeyers on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:48PM
(#5901967)
Visitors will be kind of a stretch, as they might not have any substantial ties with the US "community" to be protected by the Fourth. The opposite thing goes for the legal temporary worker who went to visit home country for a couple of weeks - he should be protected. In any case I do not think NSA takes all those things into account when they figure out who is a "US person" and who is not, if they ever do that, of course.
However, spying on foriegn governments and militaries is okay. Non-governmental terrorist organizations like Al-Qaeda are also fair game for spying. However, if the Al-Qaeda members that you are spying on are American citizens, then you need a warrant, preferrably one granted by a reputable court and not a secret rubber-stamp court.