News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:07AM (#5897978)
Dear God, it's like I'm a kid again.

I didn't grow up in the US; when I was a kid, we didn't have this kind of interviews on TV. For one thing, most of the TV shows they aired was propaganda, and it was so utterly boring most of us didn't bother. The newspapers, on the other hand, carried propaganda along with the news, so you kindda had to read it, too, if you were to know what's happening. The smarter folks could even read between the lines.

This one struck the most sensible chord:

> And what that does is that does not apply to any U.S. person. Has to be a foreign entity.

Entities. Not individuals, not groups, but entities. If you're an American citizen, you're cool. If you're a foreign entity, you're preeeetty much either a ladybug or a human, either way, it's pretty much the same thing.

This was Communist speak for non-Communist (to be fair, it was the twisted kind of Soviet-inspired Communism). We had communist workers and teachers and housewives, but foreign elements. Our country had communist friends but the democratic entities weren't that friendly.

This defensive depersonalization makes it very easy to strip away ethics. Butchering unarmed civilians sounds a lot more horrifying than annihilating non-combatant, but dangerous entities.

> The — because — the — first of all, Charlie, the number of requests are surprisingly small… number one. Number two, folks don’t go with a query unless they’ve got a pretty good suspicion.

This sounds very much like the kind of conversation that, at some point, was taking place between Soviet representatives and representatives of various other subordinated, but somewhat nasty countries of the Soviet block.

It's the kind of stuff that was handed out to us during the talks about the Warszaw pact. Is it true that the Soviet Union has supreme command of all troops and can invade any territory, even that of its allies? Well, no, I mean, it wouldn't be an invasion. It's a trade-off we have do for our freedom: should the Revolution be abandoned in any of the member countries, the allied countries should intervene to restore the right values. That is why the Soviet Union has to have representatives at all levels, must be informed of every decision. It's one of those things we must concede for democracy -- we need to entrust our freedom to people who can protect it. Words like freedom, democracy, values and way of life were freely thrown in -- ours was the land of the brave and free, unlike that of the oppressed working-class friends living in imperialist, totalitarian states.

I shivered a bit when I read this.

Edit: BTW, just to practice my reading-between-the-lines muscle, my guess is that a) FISA hasn't turned down any request yet and b) the requests were summarily "reviewed" and approved, through a short process that should give legal backing. In other words, FISA isn't there to actually review the requests, it's there simply in order to fill in the paperwork that's needed in order to make the whole thing seem legitimate.

In the early days of the regime, we had something similar to this, too. The curious dudes submitted a request to a committee of representatives of the people -- the request was basically a form which said that the following people have highly suspicious activities that can be a threat to the security of our people, to the Revolution and the communist way of life we have so hardly fought for (actual fucking words!) and was recommended to be placed under surveillance. These were signed pretty much in bulk -- the representatives of the people usually signed a big list at the bottom. Later on, this was eventually dropped: complaining about paperwork was useless, and after a few years it became obvious complaining about paperwork was so dangerous that when it was no longer required, no one dared do anything about it.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by Spearchucker on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:42AM (#5898187)
> And what that does is that does not apply to any U.S. person. Has to be a foreign entity.

Referring to a living, breathing human being with feelings, emotions, needs and wants (just like any American) as an "entity" is what Rory Miller calls "othering" [1]. The point of othering is to remove the humanity from someone or from a group of people. It makes it easier for someone to monitor, torture and... kill someone else.

And Americans are masters at it. People in the middle east, regardless of anything, are referred to by Americans as hajis. Gooks in Vietnam. And so on. It's subtle, but it works on Joe Public as well as it does on American soldiers invading some random country.

It's inhumane.

[1] Facing Violence: Preparing for the Unexpected - http://www.amazon.com/dp/1594392137

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by sneak on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:33AM (#5898323)
Yeah, Snowden pointed this out in his QA today:

> More fundamentally, the "US Persons" protection in general is a distraction from the power and danger of this system. Suspicionless surveillance does not become okay simply because it's only victimizing 95% of the world instead of 100%. Our founders did not write that "We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all US Persons are created equal."

It's insane that the president is openly declaring that they are more than willing to violate people's civil rights, just as long as they didn't happen to be born in the USA.

(And what about dual citizens? Or US citizens like me that live abroad? OR THE SIX AND A HALF BILLION OTHER HUMANS WHO DESERVE PRIVACY TOO)

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by mtgx on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:37AM (#5898451)
The media could help here, by instead of using the administration words in their articles, they'd be using their words - the normal words.

Also, at every press conference where they say "entities", they could ask, do you mean "people"? Or something along those lines. The people in the media are American citizens, too. It would help if they'd try to defend their own rights, too, instead of being nice to the government, which they are supposed to keep in check.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:17AM (#5899300)
If "the media" were going to help, they could have done that at any time since 9/12/2001.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @02:53AM (#5904075)
Yeah, but why would the media want that?
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by nikster on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:04AM (#5898380)
Exactly.

It's 2013 and the USA needs a Glasnost movement. It's ironic but here we go.

Secret courts, secret court orders, rubber stamped approvals. Gag orders on anybody coming in contact with said secret court orders. Where are we? Khmer Rouge Cambodia? Because it sure does not sound like the Land Of The Free.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by bad_user on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:03AM (#5898111)
You skipped something - besides the foreign entities that represent a perpetual threat, you also have the internal elements classified as "fierce civil libertarians", for now ;-)
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:50AM (#5898354)
Yes, yes, we had those, too. In the beginning, they were fierce opposites of progress, prisoners of the old mentality. It then became rather uncomfortable to label them as such, when a twenty-year old mentality was about as old as the regime itself, so we ended up with similar derogatory terms: fiercely anarchist, adversaries of order, hippies, and as the reality got more and more dire, mentally-troubled and drug users.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by angersock on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @05:54AM (#5898362)
These "dedicated malcontents", I presume?
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:13AM (#5898401)
Yeah, there were enough terms for it. The scarring this left in the popular consciousness is impressive though. More than twenty years later, the exact same phrasings are still being used occasionally, and with the same meanings, especially by older people.

The sorriest part is that today's teenagers don't notice it, or don't know it. and underestimate what's under the words. A couple of years ago I went to visit my parents and I went hiking. There was a group of secondary school students who were on a school trip with their teacher, an obtuse, uptight old lady who had probably missed a couple of anger management appointments. I wasn't travelling with them, we were just hiking on the same trail, but hearing her yell and shout was probably doable a couple of hike trails away, too.

I don't interfere with this -- I hated school and firmly believe in natural selection, so I leave it to kids to make the life of these people as miserable as possible -- but when she scoffed at two particularly dedicated malcontents, calling them the "most agitating elements of the classroom" and "hooligans" (the word is actually somewhat more politically-loaded, but untranslatable -- it's roughly similar with, but not quite, "hooligan"), I snapped and asked her if this assessment is going to go on the record she'll write (again, untranslatable -- what I used was slang for "are you going to write this in your signed declaration for the state security apparatus", as a couple of decades into the regime, it became well-known that some citizens were actually spying and reporting on their neighbours, colleagues and friends). The combination of hatred, surprise, and desperation at not being able to "write me up" or otherwise screw with me, since -- not being her pupil -- I wasn't subject to he whims was chilling.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by bad_user on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @01:21PM (#5900623)
Dude, all of what you said happened in Romania, word for word, including the usage of "hooligans" and the reporting of "agitating elements" to the security apparatus. People were scared shitless that their own neighbours are going to report them for whatever crap they were doing (I distinctively remember my mother bringing home bananas and telling me to be quiet about it, as bananas, like other tropical fruits were quite rare).
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @02:55AM (#5904078)
It was fairly similar all over the place :-).
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by angersock on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @06:33AM (#5898445)
It's distressing, because the way that felonies and whatnot are handled nowadays, there does seem to be a rough approximation of this sort of black book phenomenon.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by JonnieCache on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:14AM (#5899261)
In the UK we're called "domestic extremists."
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by brown9-2 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @08:52AM (#5898817)
FISA has provisions for surveilling "facilities", buildings, and locations, and is not limited to orders to surveil just an individual.

A more generous reading would suggest that is what "foreign entity" is referring to - cases where the NSA is surveilling a safehouse or a military base and not necessarily a human being.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:13AM (#5899240)
A foreign company might also qualify as an entity. Even a company that merely has offices abroad might qualify. US Citizens who work for foreign entities might very well be included.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by brown9-2 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:25AM (#5899345)
The law makes it clear that US persons (defined as citizens or legal residents) are not to be included whether they are presently in the USA or travelling abroad.

Even foreign persons who are under surveillance are to be excluded when they travel to the US.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:38AM (#5899424)
Care to point out where the law makes that clear? It's my understanding that communications to/from "foreign entities" are subject to monitoring; as are any communications which have been routed outside the continental US, without regard to the endpoints.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by warfangle on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @10:37AM (#5899420)
Yet the system can only figure with 51% probability whether or not an entity being targeted is, in fact, foreign or US-born.
Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by JonSkeptic on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @12:16PM (#5900146)
You may be right. However, "foreign entity" does not strictly mean "non-US person" and this is highly intentional. A foreign entity does not have to be a person. It can be a bank, a corporation, a nation, an foreign based activist group.

You view it as discriminatory and it may very well be; I purport that its purpose is to encompass literally everything that is not a U.S. person, thereby allowing them nearly unlimited use of all programs that are allegedly not used against U.S. persons. The discrimination aspect is import, but I think the definition aspect that extends the reach of their scope to nigh-unlimited, is also an important way to view that particular word choice.

Re:Obama Can’t Confirm If Courts Ever Rejected Spying Requests by weland on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @02:58AM (#5904091)
When you are spying on a foreign bank or corporation, aren't you spying on a bunch of foreign people?

I mean, arguably, if the NSA were spying on Google, would that make it reasonably all right? It's not like Google has feelings or a right to privacy -- it's not a person, it's a corporation.

Unless they're spying on bulldozers or kitchen ustensils, "entity" could be easily replaced with "one or more people" and the phrase would retain the same meaning. It's one of the many procedures in the family of othering: we're not shooting at people, we're shooting at the 4th platoon.