Re:Do You Have A Right to Remain Silent? Thoughts on Salinas...
by hga on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @11:24AM
(#5899763)
I have to disagree, the body language as described in the Nth hand reports I've read sounds like a useful "tell", especially in the context of the questioning.
But as you imply, let the jury decide by watching the video.
Re:Do You Have A Right to Remain Silent? Thoughts on Salinas...
by gizmo686 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @07:31PM
(#5902729)
>But as you imply, let the jury decide by watching the video.
That is not at all what I intended to imply. If the defendant choices to do so, let him present to video to the jury. If the prosecution wants to show the video (or use the gesture at all), they should be prepared to demonstrate that it is not prejudicial evidence, and probably get an expert to testify and explain what the gestures do and do not suggest.
Of course, they should also maintain a recording of the interview so the defense can use it, and to mitigate the potential for human failures. The cost of this seems negligible, so the only reason I can see them not doing this is if they don't want the full account of what happened precisely to be shown.