News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by CWuestefeld on Friday May 01, 2009 @01:09PM (#588769)
Is this really lower-impact in climate change than traditional mowing? I think it's far from obvious.

With the goat solution, we must count the cost of the goat transportation. And I suspect that the methane emitted by goats -- a worse greenhouse problem than CO2 -- may actually have a greater effect than the exhaust from a lawnmower.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by seanc on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:03PM (#588951)
The carbon emitted by the lawnmower came out of the ground, where it had been for millions of years. Net effect, more carbon in the atmosphere.

The carbon in the goat methane comes from the grass, which took that carbon out of the air a few months back. Net effect, nil.

I hate it when people get anxious about cow farts contributing to global warming.

But the thoughts about the transportation of the goats are worth exploring.

However, if you want to go that route you also have to add the net carbon emissions for construction, maintenance, and transportation of the lawnmower, which are non-trivial.

I strongly suspect the goats are a net win.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by Alex3917 on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:36PM (#588997)
"The carbon in the goat methane comes from the grass, which took that carbon out of the air a few months back. Net effect, nil."

Can you explain this? The grass absorbs CO2, and the goats turn the grass into methane. Except that methane is a way more potent greenhouse gas than CO2. So how could the effect be nil?

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by seanc on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:49PM (#589017)
Well okay, not nil. But the methane eventually oxidizes back to CO2, half life 7 years: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Methane.

Contrast with fossil fuels, which take a looooong time to get (permanently) back into the ground.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by gregwebs on Friday May 01, 2009 @05:09PM (#589162)
From looking at the wikipedia page, methane is converted to water and ethane with broken down ozone. Ethane is a much milder greenhouse gas. Not sure what ethane half life is. If I understand this correctly, the net result will be putting carbon and hydrogen into the atmosphere (via ethane) and taking oxygen out of the atmosphere in the form of water and maybe reducing atmospheric ozone. With a side effect of 7 years of methane.

Regardless, this is not a closed carbon loop, and it results in global warming.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by lutorm on Saturday May 02, 2009 @11:00AM (#589892)
It is a closed carbon loop as long as the grass the goats turn into methane ultimately regrows. It's true that you have a sustained amount of methane due to the flux through this loop.

The same is true for fossil fuels, in principle the loop is closed because eventually plants will turn the CO2 back into fossil fuels. It's just that because the time constant of that loop is thousands of years and we burn it much faster than that, most of the fossil carbon will eventually make it into the atmosphere.

Even though methane is a more efficient greenhouse gas than CO2, the time constant on the CO2 cycle more than makes up for that difference. When making these calculations, you can't just look at the amount of emission, you need to look at what sustained amount of atmospheric level results from that emission.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by jules on Saturday May 02, 2009 @05:57AM (#589732)
The carbon will be used by the plants to regrow where the goats grazed. Goats turn grass into stuff and the grass will turn it back into grass. Net effect: zero. The difference with mowers is that they turn fossil fuels and grass into mowed grass. Other organisms will turn the mowed grass into stuff (like the goats) and grass will turn this back into grass. Net effect: burned fossil fuels.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by ggrot on Saturday May 02, 2009 @03:33AM (#589647)
It also depends somewhat on what you do with the grass from the lawnmower. If you just throw it on a landfill, as it decomposes, it too will release methane. This is why many (although not nearly enough) landfills have small methane-burning power plants next to them.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by TheSOB88 on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:37PM (#588999)
The problem with methane is that it's more efficient at keeping heat in than carbon dioxide is. So while the net carbon effect may be nil, the carbon is producing more trouble because of the cows.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by rcoder on Friday May 01, 2009 @01:12PM (#588772)
I don't disagree that livestock are a serious greenhouse gas factor, but goats may have multiple uses as a stock animal, including mowing, meat, and dairy. If these animals are raised as, say, a dairy herd, and incidentally feed on grass at corporate offices rather than private ranch land, that would seem to me to be a net win in terms of carbon emissions.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by CWuestefeld on Friday May 01, 2009 @01:46PM (#588838)
That's correct. If the goats are being raised anyway then there's no net addition from the creatures themselves.

But as I said, I suspect that the truck(s) that move the goats around emit more CO2 than a lawnmower would. I'm guessing that per-mile emissions from a mower are much higher than a car, but that the truck is moving a much greater distance.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by Femur on Friday May 01, 2009 @02:25PM (#588895)
This may be inaccurate. Due to the simpler engine design of a mower combined with the pollution curbing technology in use in cars and trucks (such as catalytic converters), mowers can be much worse.

Source: http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/Story?id=98532&page=1

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by chancho on Friday May 01, 2009 @01:55PM (#588849)
How do you propose to get the lawn mowers and crew to/from Google HQ?
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by delano on Friday May 01, 2009 @02:26PM (#588897)
A couple people in a truck with a couple lawn mowers would produce fewer emissions than a goat transport.

In any case, I believe the point he's trying to make is that it's not an obvious net win in terms of carbon emissions.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by graemep on Friday May 01, 2009 @04:23PM (#589085)
Then again, if you eventually sell the goats a for food into the local market you are likely to reduce emissions on food transport.

Of course, I have no idea what the demand for goat is in that area (surely there are some Indian restaurants that can do a "mutton" curry), or whether the US has the same idiotic regulations that the EU does that forces the shipment of animals for slaughter.....

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by Femur on Friday May 01, 2009 @02:21PM (#588890)
A smaller herd of goats perpetually maintained on the grassy area in question would do the trick.

Upkeep of this smaller herd may be an issue however. How much husbandry do goats need?

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by anigbrowl on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:04PM (#588952)
Not much. As long as you have a fence to stop them running out into the road, goats will just wander around and munch grass all day. As will sheep. They need to be checked by a vet a couple of times a year.

You guys are confusing the requirements for industrial farming (where you're committed to deliver a certain amount of milk or meat every x weeks) with the basics of animal husbandry. As long as you don't have so many goats that they eat the grass faster than it grows back, everything will be just fine.

Keeping animals on a free range basis is extremely low-maintenance and low-impact. They just eat, poop, sit around and reproduce every so often.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by aaronblohowiak on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:20PM (#588973)
"They just eat, poop, sit around and reproduce every so often." - where do I apply?
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by HeyLaughingBoy on Friday May 01, 2009 @05:12PM (#589168)
Yeah, but goats are escape artists

I raise chickens and have looked into having goats for milk (not this year: don't have the time) and fencing is a major issue. One of my neighbors has goats and they are always getting out.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by anigbrowl on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:08PM (#588959)
It's not a multi-day journey for the truck, whereas the lawnmower is likely to be running all day for several days. The distance is irrelevant, since a lawnmower can't travel at the same speed as a truck. Additionally, lawnmowers generally use 2 stroke engines which are inefficient and extremely noisy.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by anamax on Sunday May 03, 2009 @04:04AM (#590716)
> Additionally, lawnmowers generally use 2 stroke engines which are inefficient and extremely noisy.

I can't find any 2 stroke mowers at Home Depot, Lowe's, OSH, or Sears. (The vast majority use Briggs and Stratton engines. B&S makes a few 2 stroke engines, but AFAIK, they're only used in snow blowers.) Where are you finding "generally"?

The trucks driven by lawn service folks generally get around 10-20 mpg. They don't spend hours on most job sites - most jobs are much less than an hour of mowing, with an hour or so doing other stuff. Then it's back in the truck for 15-30 minutes. The mowers less than half a gallon during that time and the trucks use about a gallon between jobs.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by paul9290 on Friday May 01, 2009 @07:26PM (#589306)
Methane argument I wonder what company or organization is raking in the dough with that one? Who is living off the hog by preaching animals and people farts are killing the environment?

Being green is great and it's big business. I agree with most of it, but the fart argument is ridiculous.. though not to the people making a living from it!

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by lutorm on Saturday May 02, 2009 @10:54AM (#589885)
If you want to go down that route, you must include the CO2 emitted by the manufacture of the lawn mowers and their transport from China (we can assume) to Mountain View.

Regardless of whether trucking a load of goats around uses more gas than running the lawn mowers (a hypothesis I seriously suspect is incorrect), goats manufacture themselves whereas making steel and aluminum uses a lot of energy.

And if you want to argue that demand for goats breeds more goats which increases their methane emission, shouldn't you also include the fact that demand for more lawnmowers makes the lawnmower factory hire more people, which then have a salary to do things like buy cars that they wouldn't if they were unemployed?

It's effects like that that people appeal to when they say corn ethanol leads to a net increase in CO2 compared to running gasoline directly. Somehow assuming a baseline that implies that people would be homeless bums living at 3rd world level unless they are employed by the ethanol industry seems like a dubious calculation to me.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by Keyframe on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:10PM (#588964)
Goats are already alive, they would fart either way,
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by icey on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:59PM (#589028)
That's just like saying the gas has already been processed and would be used anyway.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by jacoblyles on Saturday May 02, 2009 @12:31AM (#589547)
Higher demand for goats leads to more goat breeding.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by chaosmachine on Friday May 01, 2009 @01:16PM (#588778)
Indeed, unless the goats are walking to Google, I imagine more fuel would be used. Maybe the goat transport vehicles are electric?
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by proee on Friday May 01, 2009 @02:32PM (#588907)
FYI, electric does not mean green. Most electricity is generated from dirty coal so there's no net benefit from using electric cars until we can generate cleaner power production.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by anigbrowl on Friday May 01, 2009 @03:09PM (#588961)
You get greater economies of scale at a central power plant than with numerous distributed motors, plus you only need to install one set of scrubbers. Joule for joule, it's cleaner to run an electric motor on AC than to run your own generator.
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by proee on Friday May 01, 2009 @06:19PM (#589251)
The point I'm trying to make is that converting cars over to electric right now is not a green solution. I believe there is less pollution by running an efficient combustion engine than running an electric card that's powered off a coal plant. There's a lot of efficiency lossed from starting with the coal, to converting to electricity, to charging the batteries. With a gas powered car, the bulk of the efficiency is in the last stage. Wish I had some more numbers to back this claim but I've read it before...
Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by rms on Friday May 01, 2009 @06:20PM (#589253)
>I believe there is less pollution by running an efficient combustion engine than running an electric card that's powered off a coal plant.

I'm pretty sure the numbers go the other way. Current voting on comments would put the burden of proof on you to change the minds of the rest. Here is one I googled up very quickly from an industry source. http://www.pluginamerica.org/images/EmissionsSummary.pdf I didn't read it, so I am by no means trying to hold it up as definitive and without any fallacy.

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by proee on Friday May 01, 2009 @07:56PM (#589330)
Well I did a little research and it looks like when gas powered cars reach 40-50mpg they achieve the same level of pollution as an electric car in terms of net BTUs required to run them.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bob-schildgen/evs-vs-gas-power...

Re:Google: Mowing lawn with goats by chaosmachine on Friday May 01, 2009 @08:34PM (#589362)
Assuming you're not using solar, wind, hydro, or nuclear power sources.